{"schemaVersion":"astrotechne.public-doctrine-report.v1","report":{"id":"job_vcaTfe8D7naGQ9J9JfOgbV8g","title":"Vladimir Putin Doctrine Report","generatedAt":"2026-08-19T20:36:20.444Z","attribution":"Anonymous","attributionProfileUrl":null},"chart":{"publicChartId":"vladimir-putin","title":"Vladimir Putin","url":"/chart/vladimir-putin"},"analysis":{"ruleEvidenceRows":[{"id":"evidence-medieval-besiegement-by-ray","factorKey":"body:mars","factorLabel":"Mars","ruleKey":"medieval_besiegement_by_ray","ruleTitle":"Medieval besiegement by ray","doctrineClaim":"Medieval besiegement by ray","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Medieval","predicateKeys":["bodies.configured"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-GEORGE-AA2"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"}],"chartEvidence":["configured(Mars, Sun, configured)","configured(Saturn, Sun, configured)"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"bodies.configured","predicateLabel":"configured(Mars, Sun, configured)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Sun","glyph":"☉","longitude":193.93174145103276,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":13.931741451032764,"house":12,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":[],"source":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"bodies.configured","predicateLabel":"configured(Saturn, Sun, configured)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Sun","glyph":"☉","longitude":193.93174145103276,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":13.931741451032764,"house":12,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":[],"source":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE 105","sortOrder":2}],"calculationExplanation":"configured(Mars, Sun, configured) ∧ configured(Saturn, Sun, configured) => Medieval besiegement by ray","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Sun is enclosed by Mars and Saturn specifically by ray, so this indicates the narrower besiegement-by-ray condition.","interpretation":"Sun is enclosed by Mars and Saturn specifically by ray, so this indicates the narrower besiegement-by-ray condition.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-medieval-besiegement-by-ray","factorKey":"body:mars","factorLabel":"Mars","ruleKey":"medieval_besiegement_by_ray","ruleTitle":"Medieval besiegement by ray","doctrineClaim":"Medieval besiegement by ray","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Medieval","predicateKeys":["bodies.configured"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-GEORGE-AA2"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"}],"chartEvidence":["configured(Mars, Moon, configured)","configured(Saturn, Moon, configured)"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"bodies.configured","predicateLabel":"configured(Mars, Moon, configured)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":[],"source":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"bodies.configured","predicateLabel":"configured(Saturn, Moon, configured)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":[],"source":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE 105","sortOrder":2}],"calculationExplanation":"configured(Mars, Moon, configured) ∧ configured(Saturn, Moon, configured) => Medieval besiegement by ray","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Moon is enclosed by Mars and Saturn specifically by ray, so this indicates the narrower besiegement-by-ray condition.","interpretation":"Moon is enclosed by Mars and Saturn specifically by ray, so this indicates the narrower besiegement-by-ray condition.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-medieval-besiegement-by-ray","factorKey":"body:mars","factorLabel":"Mars","ruleKey":"medieval_besiegement_by_ray","ruleTitle":"Medieval besiegement by ray","doctrineClaim":"Medieval besiegement by ray","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Medieval","predicateKeys":["bodies.configured"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-GEORGE-AA2"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"}],"chartEvidence":["configured(Mars, Mercury, configured)","configured(Saturn, Mercury, configured)"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"bodies.configured","predicateLabel":"configured(Mars, Mercury, configured)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":[],"source":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"bodies.configured","predicateLabel":"configured(Saturn, Mercury, configured)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":[],"source":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE 105","sortOrder":2}],"calculationExplanation":"configured(Mars, Mercury, configured) ∧ configured(Saturn, Mercury, configured) => Medieval besiegement by ray","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Mercury is enclosed by Mars and Saturn specifically by ray, so this indicates the narrower besiegement-by-ray condition.","interpretation":"Mercury is enclosed by Mars and Saturn specifically by ray, so this indicates the narrower besiegement-by-ray condition.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-core-nemesis-ruler-witnessed-by-malefic","factorKey":"lot:lot-of-nemesis","factorLabel":"Lot of Nemesis","ruleKey":"core_nemesis_ruler_witnessed_by_malefic","ruleTitle":"Nemesis ruler is witnessed by malefic","doctrineClaim":"Nemesis ruler is witnessed by malefic","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["body.in_house","body.witnessed_by_malefic","house.succedent","lot.in_house","lot.ruler"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-VALENS-ANTH"],"sourceKeys":["VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1631-1640"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1720-1728"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1724-1728"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1729-1736"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2360-2362"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2360-2363"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2361-2364"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2363-2365"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2365-2367"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2366-2368"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2368-2370"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2368-2371"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2370-2373"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2373-2376"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2375-2376"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2377-2381"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2378-2381"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2380-2383"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2382-2385"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2384-2386"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2386-2389"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2389-2390"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2389-2391"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2391-2392"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2392-2397"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2397-2399"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2399-2402"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2402-2404"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2403-2404"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2404-2405"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2405-2406"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2406"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2406-2407"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2407-2408"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2408-2409"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2409-2410"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2410-2411"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2441-2443"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2450-2451"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2454-2457"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2463-2465"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2465-2466"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2465-2468"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2472-2473"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2473-2474"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2479-2480"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2480-2481"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2481-2482"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2527"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2548"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2548; 4746-4756; 6326-6336"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2542-2544"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"4750-4753; 6331"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"68"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8024-8048"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8037-8041"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8098-8103"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"9388-9404"}],"chartEvidence":["house is 8","house is 9","malefic witness by opposition","malefic witness by trine","succedent(H8)","traditional ruler is Moon"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"lot.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Lot of Nemesis) = 9","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Nemesis","glyph":"⊗","longitude":97.91727870042257,"sign":"Cancer","degree_in_sign":7.917278700422571,"house":9},"object":null,"observed":["house is 9"],"source":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY 1631-1640","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"lot.ruler","predicateLabel":"ruler(Lot of Nemesis) = Moon","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Nemesis","glyph":"⊗","longitude":97.91727870042257,"sign":"Cancer","degree_in_sign":7.917278700422571,"house":9},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["traditional ruler is Moon"],"source":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY 1631-1640","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"house.succedent","predicateLabel":"succedent(H8)","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":["succedent(H8)"],"source":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY 1631-1640","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"body.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Moon) = 8","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["house is 8"],"source":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY 1631-1640","sortOrder":4},{"predicateKey":"body.witnessed_by_malefic","predicateLabel":"malefic_witness(Moon, Mars, opposition)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["malefic witness by opposition"],"source":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY 1631-1640","sortOrder":5},{"predicateKey":"body.witnessed_by_malefic","predicateLabel":"malefic_witness(Moon, Saturn, trine)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["malefic witness by trine"],"source":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY 1631-1640","sortOrder":6}],"calculationExplanation":"house(Lot of Nemesis) = 9 ∧ ruler(Lot of Nemesis) = Moon ∧ succedent(H8) ∧ house(Moon) = 8 ∧ malefic_witness(Moon, Mars, opposition) ∧ malefic_witness(Moon, Saturn, trine) => Nemesis ruler is witnessed by malefic","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Moon rules Lot of Nemesis and receives malefic testimony from Mars, Saturn, so it is read as expressing punitive, destructive, and death-quality topics under more pressure.","interpretation":"Moon rules Lot of Nemesis and receives malefic testimony from Mars, Saturn, so it is read as expressing punitive, destructive, and death-quality topics under more pressure.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-paulus-spirit-ruler-operates","factorKey":"lot:lot-of-spirit","factorLabel":"Lot of Spirit","ruleKey":"paulus_spirit_ruler_operates","ruleTitle":"Lot of Spirit is interpreted through its ruler, Jupiter","doctrineClaim":"Lot of Spirit is interpreted through its ruler, Jupiter","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Paulus","predicateKeys":["body.angular","body.condition_component_score","body.condition_valence","body.in_bound","body.in_house","body.in_sect","body.received_by","body.retrograde","body.solar_proximity","degree.bound_ruler","house.angular","lot.in_house","lot.ruler"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL"],"sourceKeys":["PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1299-1322"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1575-1590"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2684-2760"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2721-2770"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"68"}],"chartEvidence":["Taurus 19 ruler is Jupiter","angular(H7)","body is in sect","bound(Jupiter)","condition valence is bonified","dignity score is 1","house is 5","house is 7","house is angular","house_strength score is 3","joy score is -1","motion is retrograde","motion score is -2","received by Mars through participating_triplicity","received by Moon through exaltation","received by Moon through face","received by Venus through domicile","received by Venus through triplicity","reception score is 8","sect score is 1","solar proximity band is outside_under_beams_threshold","solar separation is 144.19 degrees","total score is 11","traditional ruler is Jupiter","visibility score is 1"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"lot.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Lot of Spirit) = 5","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Spirit","glyph":"⊗","longitude":344.22667416931654,"sign":"Pisces","degree_in_sign":14.226674169316539,"house":5},"object":null,"observed":["house is 5"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"lot.ruler","predicateLabel":"ruler(Lot of Spirit) = Jupiter","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Spirit","glyph":"⊗","longitude":344.22667416931654,"sign":"Pisces","degree_in_sign":14.226674169316539,"house":5},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"observed":["traditional ruler is Jupiter"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"house.angular","predicateLabel":"angular(H7)","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":["angular(H7)"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"body.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Jupiter) = 7","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"object":null,"observed":["house is 7"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":4},{"predicateKey":"body.in_sect","predicateLabel":"BodyInSect { body: Jupiter }","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"object":null,"observed":["body is in sect"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":5},{"predicateKey":"body.retrograde","predicateLabel":"retrograde(Jupiter)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"object":null,"observed":["motion is retrograde"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":6},{"predicateKey":"body.in_bound","predicateLabel":"bound(Jupiter)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"object":null,"observed":["bound(Jupiter)"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":7},{"predicateKey":"degree.bound_ruler","predicateLabel":"bound_ruler(Taurus 19) = Jupiter","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"observed":["Taurus 19 ruler is Jupiter"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":8},{"predicateKey":"body.solar_proximity","predicateLabel":"solar_proximity(Jupiter) = outside_under_beams_threshold at 144.19°","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Sun","glyph":"☉","longitude":193.93174145103276,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":13.931741451032764,"house":12,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["solar proximity band is outside_under_beams_threshold","solar separation is 144.19 degrees"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":9},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Jupiter, Moon, exaltation)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["received by Moon through exaltation"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":10},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Jupiter, Moon, face)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["received by Moon through face"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":11},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Jupiter, Venus, domicile)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Venus","glyph":"♀","longitude":221.71180161400247,"sign":"Scorpio","degree_in_sign":11.711801614002468,"house":1,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["received by Venus through domicile"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":12},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Jupiter, Venus, triplicity)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Venus","glyph":"♀","longitude":221.71180161400247,"sign":"Scorpio","degree_in_sign":11.711801614002468,"house":1,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["received by Venus through triplicity"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":13},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Jupiter, Mars, participating_triplicity)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["received by Mars through participating_triplicity"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":14},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Jupiter, dignity) = 1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"object":null,"observed":["dignity score is 1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":15},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Jupiter, sect) = 1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"object":null,"observed":["sect score is 1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":16},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Jupiter, house_strength) = 3","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"object":null,"observed":["house_strength score is 3"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":17},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Jupiter, motion) = -2","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"object":null,"observed":["motion score is -2"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":18},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Jupiter, visibility) = 1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"object":null,"observed":["visibility score is 1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":19},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Jupiter, joy) = -1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"object":null,"observed":["joy score is -1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":20},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Jupiter, reception) = 8","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"object":null,"observed":["reception score is 8"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":21},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Jupiter, total) = 11","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"object":null,"observed":["total score is 11"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":22},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_valence","predicateLabel":"condition(Jupiter) = bonified","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"object":null,"observed":["condition valence is bonified"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":23},{"predicateKey":"body.angular","predicateLabel":"angular(Jupiter)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"object":null,"observed":["house is angular"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":24}],"calculationExplanation":"house(Lot of Spirit) = 5 ∧ ruler(Lot of Spirit) = Jupiter ∧ angular(H7) ∧ house(Jupiter) = 7 ∧ BodyInSect { body: Jupiter } ∧ retrograde(Jupiter) ∧ bound(Jupiter) ∧ bound_ruler(Taurus 19) = Jupiter ∧ solar_proximity(Jupiter) = outside_under_beams_threshold at 144.19° ∧ reception(Jupiter, Moon, exaltation) ∧ reception(Jupiter, Moon, face) ∧ reception(Jupiter, Venus, domicile) ∧ reception(Jupiter, Venus, triplicity) ∧ reception(Jupiter, Mars, participating_triplicity) ∧ condition_component(Jupiter, dignity) = 1 ∧ condition_component(Jupiter, sect) = 1 ∧ condition_component(Jupiter, house_strength) = 3 ∧ condition_component(Jupiter, motion) = -2 ∧ condition_component(Jupiter, visibility) = 1 ∧ condition_component(Jupiter, joy) = -1 ∧ condition_component(Jupiter, reception) = 8 ∧ condition_component(Jupiter, total) = 11 ∧ condition(Jupiter) = bonified ∧ angular(Jupiter) => Lot of Spirit is interpreted through its ruler, Jupiter","derivationKind":"source_shaped_synthesis","synthesisNote":"Deterministic condition synthesis over visible dignity, sect, place, motion, visibility, reception, joy, and score components.","interpretiveImplication":"The ruler of Lot of Spirit is Jupiter in house 7 with a bonified condition, keeping Spirit's mental and active significations operative.","interpretation":"The ruler of Lot of Spirit is Jupiter in house 7 with a bonified condition, keeping Spirit's mental and active significations operative.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-medieval-besiegement","factorKey":"body:mars","factorLabel":"Mars","ruleKey":"medieval_besiegement","ruleTitle":"Medieval besiegement","doctrineClaim":"Medieval besiegement","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Medieval","predicateKeys":["bodies.configured"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-BRENNAN-HA"],"sourceKeys":["HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"123"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"42"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"85"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"95"}],"chartEvidence":["configured(Mars, Sun, configured)","configured(Saturn, Sun, configured)"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"bodies.configured","predicateLabel":"configured(Mars, Sun, configured)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Sun","glyph":"☉","longitude":193.93174145103276,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":13.931741451032764,"house":12,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"bodies.configured","predicateLabel":"configured(Saturn, Sun, configured)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Sun","glyph":"☉","longitude":193.93174145103276,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":13.931741451032764,"house":12,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":2}],"calculationExplanation":"configured(Mars, Sun, configured) ∧ configured(Saturn, Sun, configured) => Medieval besiegement","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Sun is enclosed by Mars and Saturn, so this indicates medieval besiegement rather than generic enclosure alone.","interpretation":"Sun is enclosed by Mars and Saturn, so this indicates medieval besiegement rather than generic enclosure alone.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-medieval-besiegement","factorKey":"body:mars","factorLabel":"Mars","ruleKey":"medieval_besiegement","ruleTitle":"Medieval besiegement","doctrineClaim":"Medieval besiegement","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Medieval","predicateKeys":["bodies.configured"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-BRENNAN-HA"],"sourceKeys":["HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"123"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"42"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"85"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"95"}],"chartEvidence":["configured(Mars, Moon, configured)","configured(Saturn, Moon, configured)"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"bodies.configured","predicateLabel":"configured(Mars, Moon, configured)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"bodies.configured","predicateLabel":"configured(Saturn, Moon, configured)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":2}],"calculationExplanation":"configured(Mars, Moon, configured) ∧ configured(Saturn, Moon, configured) => Medieval besiegement","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Moon is enclosed by Mars and Saturn, so this indicates medieval besiegement rather than generic enclosure alone.","interpretation":"Moon is enclosed by Mars and Saturn, so this indicates medieval besiegement rather than generic enclosure alone.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-medieval-besiegement","factorKey":"body:mars","factorLabel":"Mars","ruleKey":"medieval_besiegement","ruleTitle":"Medieval besiegement","doctrineClaim":"Medieval besiegement","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Medieval","predicateKeys":["bodies.configured"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-BRENNAN-HA"],"sourceKeys":["HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"123"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"42"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"85"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"95"}],"chartEvidence":["configured(Mars, Mercury, configured)","configured(Saturn, Mercury, configured)"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"bodies.configured","predicateLabel":"configured(Mars, Mercury, configured)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"bodies.configured","predicateLabel":"configured(Saturn, Mercury, configured)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":2}],"calculationExplanation":"configured(Mars, Mercury, configured) ∧ configured(Saturn, Mercury, configured) => Medieval besiegement","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Mercury is enclosed by Mars and Saturn, so this indicates medieval besiegement rather than generic enclosure alone.","interpretation":"Mercury is enclosed by Mars and Saturn, so this indicates medieval besiegement rather than generic enclosure alone.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-core-courage-ruler-witnessed-by-malefic","factorKey":"lot:lot-of-courage","factorLabel":"Lot of Courage","ruleKey":"core_courage_ruler_witnessed_by_malefic","ruleTitle":"Courage ruler is witnessed by malefic","doctrineClaim":"Courage ruler is witnessed by malefic","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["body.in_house","body.witnessed_by_malefic","house.succedent","lot.in_house","lot.ruler"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-VALENS-ANTH"],"sourceKeys":["VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1631-1640"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1720-1728"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1724-1728"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1729-1736"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2360-2362"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2360-2363"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2361-2364"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2363-2365"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2365-2367"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2366-2368"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2368-2370"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2368-2371"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2370-2373"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2373-2376"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2375-2376"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2377-2381"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2378-2381"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2380-2383"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2382-2385"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2384-2386"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2386-2389"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2389-2390"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2389-2391"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2391-2392"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2392-2397"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2397-2399"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2399-2402"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2402-2404"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2403-2404"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2404-2405"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2405-2406"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2406"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2406-2407"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2407-2408"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2408-2409"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2409-2410"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2410-2411"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2441-2443"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2450-2451"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2454-2457"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2463-2465"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2465-2466"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2465-2468"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2472-2473"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2473-2474"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2479-2480"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2480-2481"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2481-2482"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2527"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2548"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2548; 4746-4756; 6326-6336"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2542-2544"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"4750-4753; 6331"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"68"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8024-8048"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8037-8041"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8098-8103"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"9388-9404"}],"chartEvidence":["house is 2","house is 6","malefic witness by sextile","succedent(H2)","traditional ruler is Mars"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"lot.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Lot of Courage) = 6","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Courage","glyph":"⊗","longitude":28.85636579820971,"sign":"Aries","degree_in_sign":28.85636579820971,"house":6},"object":null,"observed":["house is 6"],"source":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY 1631-1640","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"lot.ruler","predicateLabel":"ruler(Lot of Courage) = Mars","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Courage","glyph":"⊗","longitude":28.85636579820971,"sign":"Aries","degree_in_sign":28.85636579820971,"house":6},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["traditional ruler is Mars"],"source":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY 1631-1640","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"house.succedent","predicateLabel":"succedent(H2)","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":["succedent(H2)"],"source":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY 1631-1640","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"body.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Mars) = 2","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["house is 2"],"source":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY 1631-1640","sortOrder":4},{"predicateKey":"body.witnessed_by_malefic","predicateLabel":"malefic_witness(Mars, Saturn, sextile)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["malefic witness by sextile"],"source":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY 1631-1640","sortOrder":5}],"calculationExplanation":"house(Lot of Courage) = 6 ∧ ruler(Lot of Courage) = Mars ∧ succedent(H2) ∧ house(Mars) = 2 ∧ malefic_witness(Mars, Saturn, sextile) => Courage ruler is witnessed by malefic","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Mars rules Lot of Courage and receives malefic testimony from Saturn, so it is read as expressing daring, force, and risk-bearing topics under more pressure.","interpretation":"Mars rules Lot of Courage and receives malefic testimony from Saturn, so it is read as expressing daring, force, and risk-bearing topics under more pressure.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-core-necessity-ruler-witnessed-by-malefic","factorKey":"lot:lot-of-necessity","factorLabel":"Lot of Necessity","ruleKey":"core_necessity_ruler_witnessed_by_malefic","ruleTitle":"Necessity ruler is witnessed by malefic","doctrineClaim":"Necessity ruler is witnessed by malefic","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["body.in_house","body.witnessed_by_malefic","house.cadent","lot.in_house","lot.ruler"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-VALENS-ANTH"],"sourceKeys":["VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1631-1640"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1720-1728"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1724-1728"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1729-1736"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2360-2362"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2360-2363"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2361-2364"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2363-2365"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2365-2367"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2366-2368"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2368-2370"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2368-2371"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2370-2373"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2373-2376"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2375-2376"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2377-2381"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2378-2381"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2380-2383"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2382-2385"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2384-2386"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2386-2389"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2389-2390"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2389-2391"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2391-2392"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2392-2397"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2397-2399"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2399-2402"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2402-2404"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2403-2404"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2404-2405"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2405-2406"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2406"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2406-2407"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2407-2408"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2408-2409"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2409-2410"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2410-2411"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2441-2443"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2450-2451"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2454-2457"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2463-2465"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2465-2466"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2465-2468"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2472-2473"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2473-2474"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2479-2480"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2480-2481"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2481-2482"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2527"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2548"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2548; 4746-4756; 6326-6336"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2542-2544"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"4750-4753; 6331"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"68"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8024-8048"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8037-8041"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8098-8103"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"9388-9404"}],"chartEvidence":["cadent(H12)","house is 12","house is 4","malefic witness by sextile","traditional ruler is Saturn"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"lot.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Lot of Necessity) = 4","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Necessity","glyph":"⊗","longitude":311.1520572393906,"sign":"Aquarius","degree_in_sign":11.152057239390615,"house":4},"object":null,"observed":["house is 4"],"source":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY 1631-1640","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"lot.ruler","predicateLabel":"ruler(Lot of Necessity) = Saturn","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Necessity","glyph":"⊗","longitude":311.1520572393906,"sign":"Aquarius","degree_in_sign":11.152057239390615,"house":4},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["traditional ruler is Saturn"],"source":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY 1631-1640","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"house.cadent","predicateLabel":"cadent(H12)","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":["cadent(H12)"],"source":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY 1631-1640","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"body.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Saturn) = 12","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["house is 12"],"source":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY 1631-1640","sortOrder":4},{"predicateKey":"body.witnessed_by_malefic","predicateLabel":"malefic_witness(Saturn, Mars, sextile)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["malefic witness by sextile"],"source":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY 1631-1640","sortOrder":5}],"calculationExplanation":"house(Lot of Necessity) = 4 ∧ ruler(Lot of Necessity) = Saturn ∧ cadent(H12) ∧ house(Saturn) = 12 ∧ malefic_witness(Saturn, Mars, sextile) => Necessity ruler is witnessed by malefic","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Saturn rules Lot of Necessity and receives malefic testimony from Mars, so it is read as expressing constraint, struggle, and coercive topics under more pressure.","interpretation":"Saturn rules Lot of Necessity and receives malefic testimony from Mars, so it is read as expressing constraint, struggle, and coercive topics under more pressure.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-paulus-nemesis-ruler-operates","factorKey":"lot:lot-of-nemesis","factorLabel":"Lot of Nemesis","ruleKey":"paulus_nemesis_ruler_operates","ruleTitle":"Lot of Nemesis is interpreted through its ruler, Moon","doctrineClaim":"Lot of Nemesis is interpreted through its ruler, Moon","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Paulus","predicateKeys":["body.condition_component_score","body.condition_valence","body.direct_motion","body.in_house","body.received_by","body.solar_proximity","house.succedent","lot.in_house","lot.ruler"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL"],"sourceKeys":["PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1299-1322"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1575-1590"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2684-2760"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2721-2770"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"68"}],"chartEvidence":["condition valence is bonified","house is 8","house is 9","house_strength score is 1","joy score is -1","motion is direct","motion score is 1","received by Jupiter through face","received by Jupiter through participating_triplicity","received by Mercury through bound","received by Mercury through domicile","received by Saturn through triplicity","reception score is 7","sect score is -2","solar proximity band is outside_under_beams_threshold","solar separation is 131.02 degrees","succedent(H8)","total score is 7","traditional ruler is Moon","visibility score is 1"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"lot.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Lot of Nemesis) = 9","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Nemesis","glyph":"⊗","longitude":97.91727870042257,"sign":"Cancer","degree_in_sign":7.917278700422571,"house":9},"object":null,"observed":["house is 9"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"lot.ruler","predicateLabel":"ruler(Lot of Nemesis) = Moon","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Nemesis","glyph":"⊗","longitude":97.91727870042257,"sign":"Cancer","degree_in_sign":7.917278700422571,"house":9},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["traditional ruler is Moon"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"house.succedent","predicateLabel":"succedent(H8)","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":["succedent(H8)"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"body.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Moon) = 8","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["house is 8"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":4},{"predicateKey":"body.direct_motion","predicateLabel":"direct_motion(Moon)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["motion is direct"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":5},{"predicateKey":"body.solar_proximity","predicateLabel":"solar_proximity(Moon) = outside_under_beams_threshold at 131.02°","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Sun","glyph":"☉","longitude":193.93174145103276,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":13.931741451032764,"house":12,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["solar proximity band is outside_under_beams_threshold","solar separation is 131.02 degrees"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":6},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Moon, Mercury, domicile)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["received by Mercury through domicile"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":7},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Moon, Mercury, bound)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["received by Mercury through bound"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":8},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Moon, Jupiter, participating_triplicity)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"observed":["received by Jupiter through participating_triplicity"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":9},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Moon, Jupiter, face)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"observed":["received by Jupiter through face"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":10},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Moon, Saturn, triplicity)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["received by Saturn through triplicity"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":11},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Moon, sect) = -2","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["sect score is -2"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":12},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Moon, house_strength) = 1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["house_strength score is 1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":13},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Moon, motion) = 1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["motion score is 1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":14},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Moon, visibility) = 1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["visibility score is 1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":15},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Moon, joy) = -1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["joy score is -1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":16},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Moon, reception) = 7","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["reception score is 7"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":17},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Moon, total) = 7","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["total score is 7"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":18},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_valence","predicateLabel":"condition(Moon) = bonified","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["condition valence is bonified"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":19}],"calculationExplanation":"house(Lot of Nemesis) = 9 ∧ ruler(Lot of Nemesis) = Moon ∧ succedent(H8) ∧ house(Moon) = 8 ∧ direct_motion(Moon) ∧ solar_proximity(Moon) = outside_under_beams_threshold at 131.02° ∧ reception(Moon, Mercury, domicile) ∧ reception(Moon, Mercury, bound) ∧ reception(Moon, Jupiter, participating_triplicity) ∧ reception(Moon, Jupiter, face) ∧ reception(Moon, Saturn, triplicity) ∧ condition_component(Moon, sect) = -2 ∧ condition_component(Moon, house_strength) = 1 ∧ condition_component(Moon, motion) = 1 ∧ condition_component(Moon, visibility) = 1 ∧ condition_component(Moon, joy) = -1 ∧ condition_component(Moon, reception) = 7 ∧ condition_component(Moon, total) = 7 ∧ condition(Moon) = bonified => Lot of Nemesis is interpreted through its ruler, Moon","derivationKind":"source_shaped_synthesis","synthesisNote":"Deterministic condition synthesis over visible dignity, sect, place, motion, visibility, reception, joy, and score components.","interpretiveImplication":"The ruler of Lot of Nemesis is Moon in house 8 with a bonified condition, keeping punitive, destructive, and death-quality themes active through the ruler.","interpretation":"The ruler of Lot of Nemesis is Moon in house 8 with a bonified condition, keeping punitive, destructive, and death-quality themes active through the ruler.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-core-asc-ruler-witnessed-by-malefic","factorKey":"body:mars","factorLabel":"Mars","ruleKey":"core_asc_ruler_witnessed_by_malefic","ruleTitle":"Ascendant ruler is witnessed by malefic","doctrineClaim":"Ascendant ruler is witnessed by malefic","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["body.in_house","body.witnessed_by_malefic","house.ruler","house.succedent"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-VALENS-ANTH"],"sourceKeys":["VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1631-1640"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1720-1728"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1724-1728"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1729-1736"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2360-2362"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2360-2363"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2361-2364"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2363-2365"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2365-2367"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2366-2368"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2368-2370"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2368-2371"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2370-2373"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2373-2376"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2375-2376"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2377-2381"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2378-2381"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2380-2383"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2382-2385"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2384-2386"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2386-2389"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2389-2390"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2389-2391"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2391-2392"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2392-2397"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2397-2399"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2399-2402"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2402-2404"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2403-2404"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2404-2405"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2405-2406"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2406"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2406-2407"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2407-2408"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2408-2409"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2409-2410"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2410-2411"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2441-2443"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2450-2451"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2454-2457"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2463-2465"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2465-2466"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2465-2468"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2472-2473"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2473-2474"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2479-2480"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2480-2481"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2481-2482"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2527"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2548"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2548; 4746-4756; 6326-6336"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2542-2544"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"4750-4753; 6331"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"68"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8024-8048"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8037-8041"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8098-8103"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"9388-9404"}],"chartEvidence":["house 1 ruler is Mars","house is 2","malefic witness by sextile","succedent(H2)"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"house.ruler","predicateLabel":"ruler(H1) = Mars","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["house 1 ruler is Mars"],"source":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY 1631-1640","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"house.succedent","predicateLabel":"succedent(H2)","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":["succedent(H2)"],"source":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY 1631-1640","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"body.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Mars) = 2","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["house is 2"],"source":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY 1631-1640","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"body.witnessed_by_malefic","predicateLabel":"malefic_witness(Mars, Saturn, sextile)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["malefic witness by sextile"],"source":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY 1631-1640","sortOrder":4}],"calculationExplanation":"ruler(H1) = Mars ∧ succedent(H2) ∧ house(Mars) = 2 ∧ malefic_witness(Mars, Saturn, sextile) => Ascendant ruler is witnessed by malefic","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Mars rules Ascendant and receives malefic testimony from Saturn, so it is read as expressing chart-level topics under more pressure.","interpretation":"Mars rules Ascendant and receives malefic testimony from Saturn, so it is read as expressing chart-level topics under more pressure.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-paulus-necessity-angular","factorKey":"lot:lot-of-necessity","factorLabel":"Lot of Necessity","ruleKey":"paulus_necessity_angular","ruleTitle":"Lot of Necessity is angular","doctrineClaim":"Lot of Necessity is angular","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Paulus","predicateKeys":["house.angular","lot.in_house","lot.ruler"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL"],"sourceKeys":["PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1299-1322"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1575-1590"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2684-2760"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2721-2770"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"68"}],"chartEvidence":["angular(H4)","house is 4","traditional ruler is Saturn"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"house.angular","predicateLabel":"angular(H4)","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":["angular(H4)"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"lot.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Lot of Necessity) = 4","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Necessity","glyph":"⊗","longitude":311.1520572393906,"sign":"Aquarius","degree_in_sign":11.152057239390615,"house":4},"object":null,"observed":["house is 4"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"lot.ruler","predicateLabel":"ruler(Lot of Necessity) = Saturn","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Necessity","glyph":"⊗","longitude":311.1520572393906,"sign":"Aquarius","degree_in_sign":11.152057239390615,"house":4},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["traditional ruler is Saturn"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":3}],"calculationExplanation":"angular(H4) ∧ house(Lot of Necessity) = 4 ∧ ruler(Lot of Necessity) = Saturn => Lot of Necessity is angular","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Lot of Necessity is angular in house 4, foregrounding constraints, struggle, and restrictive conditions.","interpretation":"Lot of Necessity is angular in house 4, foregrounding constraints, struggle, and restrictive conditions.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-core-eros-ruler-witnessed-by-malefic","factorKey":"lot:lot-of-eros","factorLabel":"Lot of Eros","ruleKey":"core_eros_ruler_witnessed_by_malefic","ruleTitle":"Lot of Eros ruler is witnessed by malefic","doctrineClaim":"Lot of Eros ruler is witnessed by malefic","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["body.in_house","body.witnessed_by_malefic","house.succedent","lot.in_house","lot.ruler"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-VALENS-ANTH"],"sourceKeys":["VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1631-1640"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1720-1728"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1724-1728"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1729-1736"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2360-2362"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2360-2363"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2361-2364"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2363-2365"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2365-2367"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2366-2368"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2368-2370"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2368-2371"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2370-2373"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2373-2376"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2375-2376"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2377-2381"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2378-2381"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2380-2383"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2382-2385"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2384-2386"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2386-2389"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2389-2390"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2389-2391"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2391-2392"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2392-2397"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2397-2399"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2399-2402"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2402-2404"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2403-2404"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2404-2405"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2405-2406"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2406"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2406-2407"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2407-2408"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2408-2409"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2409-2410"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2410-2411"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2441-2443"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2450-2451"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2454-2457"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2463-2465"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2465-2466"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2465-2468"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2472-2473"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2473-2474"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2479-2480"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2480-2481"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2481-2482"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2527"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2548"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2548; 4746-4756; 6326-6336"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2542-2544"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"4750-4753; 6331"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"68"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8024-8048"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8037-8041"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8098-8103"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"9388-9404"}],"chartEvidence":["house is 8","house is 9","malefic witness by opposition","malefic witness by trine","succedent(H8)","traditional ruler is Moon"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"lot.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Lot of Eros) = 9","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Eros","glyph":"⊗","longitude":115.25154647929185,"sign":"Cancer","degree_in_sign":25.251546479291846,"house":9},"object":null,"observed":["house is 9"],"source":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY 1631-1640","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"lot.ruler","predicateLabel":"ruler(Lot of Eros) = Moon","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Eros","glyph":"⊗","longitude":115.25154647929185,"sign":"Cancer","degree_in_sign":25.251546479291846,"house":9},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["traditional ruler is Moon"],"source":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY 1631-1640","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"house.succedent","predicateLabel":"succedent(H8)","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":["succedent(H8)"],"source":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY 1631-1640","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"body.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Moon) = 8","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["house is 8"],"source":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY 1631-1640","sortOrder":4},{"predicateKey":"body.witnessed_by_malefic","predicateLabel":"malefic_witness(Moon, Mars, opposition)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["malefic witness by opposition"],"source":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY 1631-1640","sortOrder":5},{"predicateKey":"body.witnessed_by_malefic","predicateLabel":"malefic_witness(Moon, Saturn, trine)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["malefic witness by trine"],"source":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY 1631-1640","sortOrder":6}],"calculationExplanation":"house(Lot of Eros) = 9 ∧ ruler(Lot of Eros) = Moon ∧ succedent(H8) ∧ house(Moon) = 8 ∧ malefic_witness(Moon, Mars, opposition) ∧ malefic_witness(Moon, Saturn, trine) => Lot of Eros ruler is witnessed by malefic","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Moon rules Lot of Eros and receives malefic testimony from Mars, Saturn, so it is read as expressing desire, friendship, and mutual-favor topics under more pressure.","interpretation":"Moon rules Lot of Eros and receives malefic testimony from Mars, Saturn, so it is read as expressing desire, friendship, and mutual-favor topics under more pressure.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-core-spirit-ruler-bonified","factorKey":"lot:lot-of-spirit","factorLabel":"Lot of Spirit","ruleKey":"core_spirit_ruler_bonified","ruleTitle":"Spirit ruler has condition support","doctrineClaim":"Spirit ruler has condition support","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["body.angular","body.condition_component_score","body.condition_valence","body.in_bound","body.in_house","body.in_sect","body.received_by","body.retrograde","body.solar_proximity","degree.bound_ruler","house.angular","lot.in_house","lot.ruler"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL"],"sourceKeys":["PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1299-1322"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1575-1590"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2684-2760"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2721-2770"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"68"}],"chartEvidence":["Taurus 19 ruler is Jupiter","angular(H7)","body is in sect","bound(Jupiter)","condition valence is bonified","dignity score is 1","house is 5","house is 7","house is angular","house_strength score is 3","joy score is -1","motion is retrograde","motion score is -2","received by Mars through participating_triplicity","received by Moon through exaltation","received by Moon through face","received by Venus through domicile","received by Venus through triplicity","reception score is 8","sect score is 1","solar proximity band is outside_under_beams_threshold","solar separation is 144.19 degrees","total score is 11","traditional ruler is Jupiter","visibility score is 1"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"lot.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Lot of Spirit) = 5","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Spirit","glyph":"⊗","longitude":344.22667416931654,"sign":"Pisces","degree_in_sign":14.226674169316539,"house":5},"object":null,"observed":["house is 5"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"lot.ruler","predicateLabel":"ruler(Lot of Spirit) = Jupiter","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Spirit","glyph":"⊗","longitude":344.22667416931654,"sign":"Pisces","degree_in_sign":14.226674169316539,"house":5},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"observed":["traditional ruler is Jupiter"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"body.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Jupiter) = 7","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"object":null,"observed":["house is 7"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"house.angular","predicateLabel":"angular(H7)","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":["angular(H7)"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":4},{"predicateKey":"body.in_sect","predicateLabel":"BodyInSect { body: Jupiter }","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"object":null,"observed":["body is in sect"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":5},{"predicateKey":"body.retrograde","predicateLabel":"retrograde(Jupiter)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"object":null,"observed":["motion is retrograde"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":6},{"predicateKey":"body.in_bound","predicateLabel":"bound(Jupiter)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"object":null,"observed":["bound(Jupiter)"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":7},{"predicateKey":"degree.bound_ruler","predicateLabel":"bound_ruler(Taurus 19) = Jupiter","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"observed":["Taurus 19 ruler is Jupiter"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":8},{"predicateKey":"body.solar_proximity","predicateLabel":"solar_proximity(Jupiter) = outside_under_beams_threshold at 144.19°","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Sun","glyph":"☉","longitude":193.93174145103276,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":13.931741451032764,"house":12,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["solar proximity band is outside_under_beams_threshold","solar separation is 144.19 degrees"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":9},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Jupiter, Moon, exaltation)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["received by Moon through exaltation"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":10},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Jupiter, Moon, face)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["received by Moon through face"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":11},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Jupiter, Venus, domicile)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Venus","glyph":"♀","longitude":221.71180161400247,"sign":"Scorpio","degree_in_sign":11.711801614002468,"house":1,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["received by Venus through domicile"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":12},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Jupiter, Venus, triplicity)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Venus","glyph":"♀","longitude":221.71180161400247,"sign":"Scorpio","degree_in_sign":11.711801614002468,"house":1,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["received by Venus through triplicity"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":13},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Jupiter, Mars, participating_triplicity)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["received by Mars through participating_triplicity"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":14},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Jupiter, dignity) = 1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"object":null,"observed":["dignity score is 1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":15},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Jupiter, sect) = 1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"object":null,"observed":["sect score is 1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":16},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Jupiter, house_strength) = 3","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"object":null,"observed":["house_strength score is 3"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":17},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Jupiter, motion) = -2","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"object":null,"observed":["motion score is -2"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":18},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Jupiter, visibility) = 1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"object":null,"observed":["visibility score is 1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":19},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Jupiter, joy) = -1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"object":null,"observed":["joy score is -1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":20},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Jupiter, reception) = 8","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"object":null,"observed":["reception score is 8"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":21},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Jupiter, total) = 11","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"object":null,"observed":["total score is 11"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":22},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_valence","predicateLabel":"condition(Jupiter) = bonified","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"object":null,"observed":["condition valence is bonified"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":23},{"predicateKey":"body.angular","predicateLabel":"angular(Jupiter)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"object":null,"observed":["house is angular"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":24}],"calculationExplanation":"house(Lot of Spirit) = 5 ∧ ruler(Lot of Spirit) = Jupiter ∧ house(Jupiter) = 7 ∧ angular(H7) ∧ BodyInSect { body: Jupiter } ∧ retrograde(Jupiter) ∧ bound(Jupiter) ∧ bound_ruler(Taurus 19) = Jupiter ∧ solar_proximity(Jupiter) = outside_under_beams_threshold at 144.19° ∧ reception(Jupiter, Moon, exaltation) ∧ reception(Jupiter, Moon, face) ∧ reception(Jupiter, Venus, domicile) ∧ reception(Jupiter, Venus, triplicity) ∧ reception(Jupiter, Mars, participating_triplicity) ∧ condition_component(Jupiter, dignity) = 1 ∧ condition_component(Jupiter, sect) = 1 ∧ condition_component(Jupiter, house_strength) = 3 ∧ condition_component(Jupiter, motion) = -2 ∧ condition_component(Jupiter, visibility) = 1 ∧ condition_component(Jupiter, joy) = -1 ∧ condition_component(Jupiter, reception) = 8 ∧ condition_component(Jupiter, total) = 11 ∧ condition(Jupiter) = bonified ∧ angular(Jupiter) => Spirit ruler has condition support","derivationKind":"source_shaped_synthesis","synthesisNote":"Deterministic condition synthesis over visible dignity, sect, place, motion, visibility, reception, joy, and score components.","interpretiveImplication":"Jupiter rules Lot of Spirit and has excellently bonified, limited by motion pressure and house joy pressure; its house 7 placement and house strength remain separately inspectable for mental, active, and intentional topics.","interpretation":"Jupiter rules Lot of Spirit and has excellently bonified, limited by motion pressure and house joy pressure; its house 7 placement and house strength remain separately inspectable for mental, active, and intentional topics.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-core-victory-ruler-witnessed-by-malefic","factorKey":"lot:lot-of-victory","factorLabel":"Lot of Victory","ruleKey":"core_victory_ruler_witnessed_by_malefic","ruleTitle":"Victory ruler is witnessed by malefic","doctrineClaim":"Victory ruler is witnessed by malefic","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["body.in_house","body.witnessed_by_malefic","house.cadent","lot.in_house","lot.ruler"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-VALENS-ANTH"],"sourceKeys":["VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1631-1640"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1720-1728"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1724-1728"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1729-1736"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2360-2362"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2360-2363"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2361-2364"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2363-2365"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2365-2367"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2366-2368"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2368-2370"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2368-2371"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2370-2373"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2373-2376"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2375-2376"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2377-2381"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2378-2381"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2380-2383"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2382-2385"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2384-2386"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2386-2389"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2389-2390"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2389-2391"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2391-2392"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2392-2397"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2397-2399"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2399-2402"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2402-2404"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2403-2404"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2404-2405"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2405-2406"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2406"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2406-2407"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2407-2408"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2408-2409"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2409-2410"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2410-2411"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2441-2443"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2450-2451"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2454-2457"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2463-2465"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2465-2466"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2465-2468"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2472-2473"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2473-2474"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2479-2480"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2480-2481"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2481-2482"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2527"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2548"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2548; 4746-4756; 6326-6336"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2542-2544"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"4750-4753; 6331"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"68"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8024-8048"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8037-8041"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8098-8103"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"9388-9404"}],"chartEvidence":["cadent(H12)","house is 12","house is 3","malefic witness by sextile","traditional ruler is Saturn"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"lot.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Lot of Victory) = 3","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Victory","glyph":"⊗","longitude":278.7196406829929,"sign":"Capricorn","degree_in_sign":8.719640682992917,"house":3},"object":null,"observed":["house is 3"],"source":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY 1631-1640","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"lot.ruler","predicateLabel":"ruler(Lot of Victory) = Saturn","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Victory","glyph":"⊗","longitude":278.7196406829929,"sign":"Capricorn","degree_in_sign":8.719640682992917,"house":3},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["traditional ruler is Saturn"],"source":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY 1631-1640","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"house.cadent","predicateLabel":"cadent(H12)","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":["cadent(H12)"],"source":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY 1631-1640","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"body.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Saturn) = 12","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["house is 12"],"source":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY 1631-1640","sortOrder":4},{"predicateKey":"body.witnessed_by_malefic","predicateLabel":"malefic_witness(Saturn, Mars, sextile)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["malefic witness by sextile"],"source":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY 1631-1640","sortOrder":5}],"calculationExplanation":"house(Lot of Victory) = 3 ∧ ruler(Lot of Victory) = Saturn ∧ cadent(H12) ∧ house(Saturn) = 12 ∧ malefic_witness(Saturn, Mars, sextile) => Victory ruler is witnessed by malefic","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Saturn rules Lot of Victory and receives malefic testimony from Mars, so it is read as expressing confidence, contest, and associative-success topics under more pressure.","interpretation":"Saturn rules Lot of Victory and receives malefic testimony from Mars, so it is read as expressing confidence, contest, and associative-success topics under more pressure.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-core-spirit-ruler-witnessed-by-benefic","factorKey":"lot:lot-of-spirit","factorLabel":"Lot of Spirit","ruleKey":"core_spirit_ruler_witnessed_by_benefic","ruleTitle":"Spirit ruler is witnessed by benefic","doctrineClaim":"Spirit ruler is witnessed by benefic","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["body.in_house","body.witnessed_by_benefic","house.angular","lot.in_house","lot.ruler"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-VALENS-ANTH"],"sourceKeys":["VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1631-1640"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1720-1728"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1724-1728"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1729-1736"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2360-2362"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2360-2363"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2361-2364"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2363-2365"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2365-2367"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2366-2368"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2368-2370"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2368-2371"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2370-2373"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2373-2376"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2375-2376"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2377-2381"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2378-2381"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2380-2383"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2382-2385"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2384-2386"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2386-2389"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2389-2390"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2389-2391"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2391-2392"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2392-2397"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2397-2399"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2399-2402"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2402-2404"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2403-2404"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2404-2405"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2405-2406"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2406"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2406-2407"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2407-2408"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2408-2409"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2409-2410"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2410-2411"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2441-2443"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2450-2451"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2454-2457"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2463-2465"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2465-2466"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2465-2468"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2472-2473"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2473-2474"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2479-2480"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2480-2481"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2481-2482"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2527"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2548"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2548; 4746-4756; 6326-6336"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2542-2544"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"4750-4753; 6331"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"68"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8024-8048"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8037-8041"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8098-8103"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"9388-9404"}],"chartEvidence":["angular(H7)","benefic witness by conjunction","benefic witness by opposition","house is 5","house is 7","traditional ruler is Jupiter"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"lot.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Lot of Spirit) = 5","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Spirit","glyph":"⊗","longitude":344.22667416931654,"sign":"Pisces","degree_in_sign":14.226674169316539,"house":5},"object":null,"observed":["house is 5"],"source":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY 1631-1640","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"lot.ruler","predicateLabel":"ruler(Lot of Spirit) = Jupiter","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Spirit","glyph":"⊗","longitude":344.22667416931654,"sign":"Pisces","degree_in_sign":14.226674169316539,"house":5},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"observed":["traditional ruler is Jupiter"],"source":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY 1631-1640","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"house.angular","predicateLabel":"angular(H7)","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":["angular(H7)"],"source":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY 1631-1640","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"body.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Jupiter) = 7","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"object":null,"observed":["house is 7"],"source":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY 1631-1640","sortOrder":4},{"predicateKey":"body.witnessed_by_benefic","predicateLabel":"benefic_witness(Jupiter, Jupiter, conjunction)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"observed":["benefic witness by conjunction"],"source":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY 1631-1640","sortOrder":5},{"predicateKey":"body.witnessed_by_benefic","predicateLabel":"benefic_witness(Jupiter, Venus, opposition)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Venus","glyph":"♀","longitude":221.71180161400247,"sign":"Scorpio","degree_in_sign":11.711801614002468,"house":1,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["benefic witness by opposition"],"source":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY 1631-1640","sortOrder":6}],"calculationExplanation":"house(Lot of Spirit) = 5 ∧ ruler(Lot of Spirit) = Jupiter ∧ angular(H7) ∧ house(Jupiter) = 7 ∧ benefic_witness(Jupiter, Jupiter, conjunction) ∧ benefic_witness(Jupiter, Venus, opposition) => Spirit ruler is witnessed by benefic","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Jupiter rules Lot of Spirit and receives benefic testimony from Jupiter, Venus, so it is read as expressing mental, active, and intentional topics with more support.","interpretation":"Jupiter rules Lot of Spirit and receives benefic testimony from Jupiter, Venus, so it is read as expressing mental, active, and intentional topics with more support.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-ptolemy-sect-light-in-aversion-to-ascendant","factorKey":"body:sun","factorLabel":"Sun","ruleKey":"ptolemy_sect_light_in_aversion_to_ascendant","ruleTitle":"Ptolemaic sect light in aversion to the Ascendant","doctrineClaim":"Ptolemaic sect light in aversion to the Ascendant","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Ptolemy","predicateKeys":["ascendant.in_aversion_to_body","body.in_house","house.cadent"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA"],"sourceKeys":["TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"49"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"57"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"79"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"81"}],"chartEvidence":["AscendantInAversionToBody { body: Sun }","cadent(H12)","house is 12"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"house.cadent","predicateLabel":"cadent(H12)","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":["cadent(H12)"],"source":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS 44","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"body.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Sun) = 12","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Sun","glyph":"☉","longitude":193.93174145103276,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":13.931741451032764,"house":12,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["house is 12"],"source":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS 44","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"ascendant.in_aversion_to_body","predicateLabel":"AscendantInAversionToBody { body: Sun }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS 44","sortOrder":3}],"calculationExplanation":"cadent(H12) ∧ house(Sun) = 12 ∧ AscendantInAversionToBody { body: Sun } => Ptolemaic sect light in aversion to the Ascendant","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"The sect light Sun is in house 12 but is in aversion to the Ascendant at the whole-sign level, so this is read as a Ptolemaic aversion condition.","interpretation":"The sect light Sun is in house 12 but is in aversion to the Ascendant at the whole-sign level, so this is read as a Ptolemaic aversion condition.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-core-nemesis-ruler-bonified","factorKey":"lot:lot-of-nemesis","factorLabel":"Lot of Nemesis","ruleKey":"core_nemesis_ruler_bonified","ruleTitle":"Nemesis ruler has condition support","doctrineClaim":"Nemesis ruler has condition support","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["body.condition_component_score","body.condition_valence","body.direct_motion","body.in_house","body.received_by","body.solar_proximity","body.succedent","house.succedent","lot.in_house","lot.ruler"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL"],"sourceKeys":["PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1299-1322"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1575-1590"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2684-2760"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2721-2770"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"68"}],"chartEvidence":["condition valence is bonified","house is 8","house is 9","house is succedent","house_strength score is 1","joy score is -1","motion is direct","motion score is 1","received by Jupiter through face","received by Jupiter through participating_triplicity","received by Mercury through bound","received by Mercury through domicile","received by Saturn through triplicity","reception score is 7","sect score is -2","solar proximity band is outside_under_beams_threshold","solar separation is 131.02 degrees","succedent(H8)","total score is 7","traditional ruler is Moon","visibility score is 1"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"lot.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Lot of Nemesis) = 9","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Nemesis","glyph":"⊗","longitude":97.91727870042257,"sign":"Cancer","degree_in_sign":7.917278700422571,"house":9},"object":null,"observed":["house is 9"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"lot.ruler","predicateLabel":"ruler(Lot of Nemesis) = Moon","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Nemesis","glyph":"⊗","longitude":97.91727870042257,"sign":"Cancer","degree_in_sign":7.917278700422571,"house":9},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["traditional ruler is Moon"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"body.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Moon) = 8","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["house is 8"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"house.succedent","predicateLabel":"succedent(H8)","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":["succedent(H8)"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":4},{"predicateKey":"body.direct_motion","predicateLabel":"direct_motion(Moon)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["motion is direct"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":5},{"predicateKey":"body.solar_proximity","predicateLabel":"solar_proximity(Moon) = outside_under_beams_threshold at 131.02°","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Sun","glyph":"☉","longitude":193.93174145103276,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":13.931741451032764,"house":12,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["solar proximity band is outside_under_beams_threshold","solar separation is 131.02 degrees"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":6},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Moon, Mercury, domicile)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["received by Mercury through domicile"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":7},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Moon, Mercury, bound)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["received by Mercury through bound"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":8},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Moon, Jupiter, participating_triplicity)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"observed":["received by Jupiter through participating_triplicity"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":9},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Moon, Jupiter, face)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"observed":["received by Jupiter through face"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":10},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Moon, Saturn, triplicity)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["received by Saturn through triplicity"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":11},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Moon, sect) = -2","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["sect score is -2"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":12},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Moon, house_strength) = 1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["house_strength score is 1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":13},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Moon, motion) = 1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["motion score is 1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":14},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Moon, visibility) = 1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["visibility score is 1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":15},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Moon, joy) = -1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["joy score is -1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":16},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Moon, reception) = 7","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["reception score is 7"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":17},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Moon, total) = 7","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["total score is 7"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":18},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_valence","predicateLabel":"condition(Moon) = bonified","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["condition valence is bonified"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":19},{"predicateKey":"body.succedent","predicateLabel":"succedent(Moon)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["house is succedent"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":20}],"calculationExplanation":"house(Lot of Nemesis) = 9 ∧ ruler(Lot of Nemesis) = Moon ∧ house(Moon) = 8 ∧ succedent(H8) ∧ direct_motion(Moon) ∧ solar_proximity(Moon) = outside_under_beams_threshold at 131.02° ∧ reception(Moon, Mercury, domicile) ∧ reception(Moon, Mercury, bound) ∧ reception(Moon, Jupiter, participating_triplicity) ∧ reception(Moon, Jupiter, face) ∧ reception(Moon, Saturn, triplicity) ∧ condition_component(Moon, sect) = -2 ∧ condition_component(Moon, house_strength) = 1 ∧ condition_component(Moon, motion) = 1 ∧ condition_component(Moon, visibility) = 1 ∧ condition_component(Moon, joy) = -1 ∧ condition_component(Moon, reception) = 7 ∧ condition_component(Moon, total) = 7 ∧ condition(Moon) = bonified ∧ succedent(Moon) => Nemesis ruler has condition support","derivationKind":"source_shaped_synthesis","synthesisNote":"Deterministic condition synthesis over visible dignity, sect, place, motion, visibility, reception, joy, and score components.","interpretiveImplication":"Moon rules Lot of Nemesis and has moderately bonified, limited by H8 aversion to Ascendant, sect pressure, and house joy pressure; its house 8 placement and house strength remain separately inspectable for punitive, destructive, and death-quality topics.","interpretation":"Moon rules Lot of Nemesis and has moderately bonified, limited by H8 aversion to Ascendant, sect pressure, and house joy pressure; its house 8 placement and house strength remain separately inspectable for punitive, destructive, and death-quality topics.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-core-spirit-ruler-in-sect","factorKey":"lot:lot-of-spirit","factorLabel":"Lot of Spirit","ruleKey":"core_spirit_ruler_in_sect","ruleTitle":"Spirit ruler is in sect","doctrineClaim":"Spirit ruler is in sect","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["body.angular","body.in_house","body.in_sect","house.angular","lot.in_house","lot.ruler"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","TRAD-VALENS-ANTH"],"sourceKeys":["PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1299-1322"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1575-1590"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2684-2760"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2721-2770"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"68"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1631-1640"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1720-1728"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1724-1728"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1729-1736"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2360-2362"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2360-2363"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2361-2364"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2363-2365"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2365-2367"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2366-2368"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2368-2370"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2368-2371"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2370-2373"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2373-2376"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2375-2376"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2377-2381"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2378-2381"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2380-2383"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2382-2385"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2384-2386"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2386-2389"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2389-2390"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2389-2391"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2391-2392"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2392-2397"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2397-2399"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2399-2402"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2402-2404"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2403-2404"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2404-2405"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2405-2406"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2406"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2406-2407"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2407-2408"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2408-2409"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2409-2410"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2410-2411"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2441-2443"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2450-2451"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2454-2457"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2463-2465"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2465-2466"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2465-2468"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2472-2473"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2473-2474"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2479-2480"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2480-2481"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2481-2482"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2527"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2548"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2548; 4746-4756; 6326-6336"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2542-2544"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"4750-4753; 6331"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"68"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8024-8048"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8037-8041"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8098-8103"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"9388-9404"}],"chartEvidence":["angular(H7)","body is in sect","house is 5","house is 7","house is angular","traditional ruler is Jupiter"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"lot.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Lot of Spirit) = 5","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Spirit","glyph":"⊗","longitude":344.22667416931654,"sign":"Pisces","degree_in_sign":14.226674169316539,"house":5},"object":null,"observed":["house is 5"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"lot.ruler","predicateLabel":"ruler(Lot of Spirit) = Jupiter","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Spirit","glyph":"⊗","longitude":344.22667416931654,"sign":"Pisces","degree_in_sign":14.226674169316539,"house":5},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"observed":["traditional ruler is Jupiter"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"body.in_sect","predicateLabel":"BodyInSect { body: Jupiter }","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"object":null,"observed":["body is in sect"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"house.angular","predicateLabel":"angular(H7)","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":["angular(H7)"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":4},{"predicateKey":"body.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Jupiter) = 7","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"object":null,"observed":["house is 7"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":5},{"predicateKey":"body.angular","predicateLabel":"angular(Jupiter)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"object":null,"observed":["house is angular"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":6}],"calculationExplanation":"house(Lot of Spirit) = 5 ∧ ruler(Lot of Spirit) = Jupiter ∧ BodyInSect { body: Jupiter } ∧ angular(H7) ∧ house(Jupiter) = 7 ∧ angular(Jupiter) => Spirit ruler is in sect","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Jupiter rules Lot of Spirit and is in sect, so it is read as better able to express mental, active, and intentional topics. It is also angular in house 7.","interpretation":"Jupiter rules Lot of Spirit and is in sect, so it is read as better able to express mental, active, and intentional topics. It is also angular in house 7.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-medieval-translation-of-light","factorKey":"body:mercury","factorLabel":"Mercury","ruleKey":"medieval_translation_of_light","ruleTitle":"Medieval translation of light","doctrineClaim":"Medieval translation of light","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Medieval","predicateKeys":["bodies.configured","medieval_relation.translation_of_light"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-SAHL-MASHALLAH"],"sourceKeys":["SAHL_AND_MASHALLAH_DYKES"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"SAHL_AND_MASHALLAH_DYKES","citationKey":"TRAD-SAHL-MASHALLAH","locator":"55"},{"sourceKey":"SAHL_AND_MASHALLAH_DYKES","citationKey":"TRAD-SAHL-MASHALLAH","locator":"66"},{"sourceKey":"SAHL_AND_MASHALLAH_DYKES","citationKey":"TRAD-SAHL-MASHALLAH","locator":"76"}],"chartEvidence":["whole-sign ray is conjunction","whole-sign ray is sextile"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"bodies.configured","predicateLabel":"configured(Mercury, Saturn, conjunction)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["whole-sign ray is conjunction"],"source":"SAHL_AND_MASHALLAH_DYKES 55","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"bodies.configured","predicateLabel":"configured(Mercury, Mars, sextile)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["whole-sign ray is sextile"],"source":"SAHL_AND_MASHALLAH_DYKES 55","sortOrder":2}],"calculationExplanation":"configured(Mercury, Saturn, conjunction) ∧ configured(Mercury, Mars, sextile) => Medieval translation of light","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Mercury separates from Saturn by conjunction and applies to Mars by sextile, so this indicates a translation-of-light relation.","interpretation":"Mercury separates from Saturn by conjunction and applies to Mars by sextile, so this indicates a translation-of-light relation.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-paulus-courage-ruler-operates","factorKey":"lot:lot-of-courage","factorLabel":"Lot of Courage","ruleKey":"paulus_courage_ruler_operates","ruleTitle":"Lot of Courage is interpreted through its ruler, Mars","doctrineClaim":"Lot of Courage is interpreted through its ruler, Mars","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Paulus","predicateKeys":["body.condition_component_score","body.condition_valence","body.direct_motion","body.in_bound","body.in_house","body.received_by","body.solar_proximity","degree.bound_ruler","house.succedent","lot.in_house","lot.ruler"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL"],"sourceKeys":["PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1299-1322"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1575-1590"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2684-2760"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2721-2770"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"68"}],"chartEvidence":["Sagittarius 26 ruler is Mars","bound(Mars)","condition valence is bonified","dignity score is 1","house is 2","house is 6","house_strength score is 1","joy score is -1","motion is direct","motion score is 1","received by Jupiter through domicile","received by Saturn through face","received by Saturn through participating_triplicity","received by Sun through triplicity","reception score is 6","sect score is -1","solar proximity band is outside_under_beams_threshold","solar separation is 72.59 degrees","succedent(H2)","total score is 8","traditional ruler is Mars","visibility score is 1"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"lot.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Lot of Courage) = 6","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Courage","glyph":"⊗","longitude":28.85636579820971,"sign":"Aries","degree_in_sign":28.85636579820971,"house":6},"object":null,"observed":["house is 6"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"lot.ruler","predicateLabel":"ruler(Lot of Courage) = Mars","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Courage","glyph":"⊗","longitude":28.85636579820971,"sign":"Aries","degree_in_sign":28.85636579820971,"house":6},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["traditional ruler is Mars"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"house.succedent","predicateLabel":"succedent(H2)","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":["succedent(H2)"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"body.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Mars) = 2","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["house is 2"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":4},{"predicateKey":"body.direct_motion","predicateLabel":"direct_motion(Mars)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["motion is direct"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":5},{"predicateKey":"body.in_bound","predicateLabel":"bound(Mars)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["bound(Mars)"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":6},{"predicateKey":"degree.bound_ruler","predicateLabel":"bound_ruler(Sagittarius 26) = Mars","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["Sagittarius 26 ruler is Mars"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":7},{"predicateKey":"body.solar_proximity","predicateLabel":"solar_proximity(Mars) = outside_under_beams_threshold at 72.59°","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Sun","glyph":"☉","longitude":193.93174145103276,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":13.931741451032764,"house":12,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["solar proximity band is outside_under_beams_threshold","solar separation is 72.59 degrees"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":8},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Mars, Sun, triplicity)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Sun","glyph":"☉","longitude":193.93174145103276,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":13.931741451032764,"house":12,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["received by Sun through triplicity"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":9},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Mars, Jupiter, domicile)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"observed":["received by Jupiter through domicile"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":10},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Mars, Saturn, participating_triplicity)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["received by Saturn through participating_triplicity"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":11},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Mars, Saturn, face)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["received by Saturn through face"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":12},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Mars, dignity) = 1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["dignity score is 1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":13},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Mars, sect) = -1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["sect score is -1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":14},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Mars, house_strength) = 1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["house_strength score is 1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":15},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Mars, motion) = 1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["motion score is 1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":16},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Mars, visibility) = 1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["visibility score is 1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":17},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Mars, joy) = -1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["joy score is -1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":18},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Mars, reception) = 6","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["reception score is 6"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":19},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Mars, total) = 8","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["total score is 8"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":20},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_valence","predicateLabel":"condition(Mars) = bonified","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["condition valence is bonified"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":21}],"calculationExplanation":"house(Lot of Courage) = 6 ∧ ruler(Lot of Courage) = Mars ∧ succedent(H2) ∧ house(Mars) = 2 ∧ direct_motion(Mars) ∧ bound(Mars) ∧ bound_ruler(Sagittarius 26) = Mars ∧ solar_proximity(Mars) = outside_under_beams_threshold at 72.59° ∧ reception(Mars, Sun, triplicity) ∧ reception(Mars, Jupiter, domicile) ∧ reception(Mars, Saturn, participating_triplicity) ∧ reception(Mars, Saturn, face) ∧ condition_component(Mars, dignity) = 1 ∧ condition_component(Mars, sect) = -1 ∧ condition_component(Mars, house_strength) = 1 ∧ condition_component(Mars, motion) = 1 ∧ condition_component(Mars, visibility) = 1 ∧ condition_component(Mars, joy) = -1 ∧ condition_component(Mars, reception) = 6 ∧ condition_component(Mars, total) = 8 ∧ condition(Mars) = bonified => Lot of Courage is interpreted through its ruler, Mars","derivationKind":"source_shaped_synthesis","synthesisNote":"Deterministic condition synthesis over visible dignity, sect, place, motion, visibility, reception, joy, and score components.","interpretiveImplication":"The ruler of Lot of Courage is Mars in house 2 with a bonified condition, keeping daring and risk-bearing themes active through the ruler.","interpretation":"The ruler of Lot of Courage is Mars in house 2 with a bonified condition, keeping daring and risk-bearing themes active through the ruler.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-core-spirit-ruler-angular","factorKey":"lot:lot-of-spirit","factorLabel":"Lot of Spirit","ruleKey":"core_spirit_ruler_angular","ruleTitle":"Spirit ruler is angular","doctrineClaim":"Spirit ruler is angular","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["body.angular","body.in_house","house.angular","lot.in_house","lot.ruler"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL"],"sourceKeys":["PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1299-1322"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1575-1590"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2684-2760"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2721-2770"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"68"}],"chartEvidence":["angular(H7)","house is 5","house is 7","house is angular","traditional ruler is Jupiter"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"lot.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Lot of Spirit) = 5","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Spirit","glyph":"⊗","longitude":344.22667416931654,"sign":"Pisces","degree_in_sign":14.226674169316539,"house":5},"object":null,"observed":["house is 5"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"lot.ruler","predicateLabel":"ruler(Lot of Spirit) = Jupiter","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Spirit","glyph":"⊗","longitude":344.22667416931654,"sign":"Pisces","degree_in_sign":14.226674169316539,"house":5},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"observed":["traditional ruler is Jupiter"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"body.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Jupiter) = 7","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"object":null,"observed":["house is 7"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"house.angular","predicateLabel":"angular(H7)","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":["angular(H7)"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":4},{"predicateKey":"body.angular","predicateLabel":"angular(Jupiter)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"object":null,"observed":["house is angular"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":5}],"calculationExplanation":"house(Lot of Spirit) = 5 ∧ ruler(Lot of Spirit) = Jupiter ∧ house(Jupiter) = 7 ∧ angular(H7) ∧ angular(Jupiter) => Spirit ruler is angular","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Jupiter rules Lot of Spirit and is angular in house 7, foregrounding its mental, active, and intentional topics.","interpretation":"Jupiter rules Lot of Spirit and is angular in house 7, foregrounding its mental, active, and intentional topics.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-medieval-reflection-of-light","factorKey":"body:mercury","factorLabel":"Mercury","ruleKey":"medieval_reflection_of_light","ruleTitle":"Medieval reflection of light","doctrineClaim":"Medieval reflection of light","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Medieval","predicateKeys":["bodies.configured"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-ABU-MASHAR-GREAT-INTRO"],"sourceKeys":["ABU_MASHAR_GREAT_INTRODUCTION_DYKES"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"ABU_MASHAR_GREAT_INTRODUCTION_DYKES","citationKey":"TRAD-ABU-MASHAR-GREAT-INTRO","locator":"26"},{"sourceKey":"ABU_MASHAR_GREAT_INTRODUCTION_DYKES","citationKey":"TRAD-ABU-MASHAR-GREAT-INTRO","locator":"46"},{"sourceKey":"ABU_MASHAR_GREAT_INTRODUCTION_DYKES","citationKey":"TRAD-ABU-MASHAR-GREAT-INTRO","locator":"80"}],"chartEvidence":["whole-sign ray is conjunction"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"bodies.configured","predicateLabel":"configured(Mercury, Saturn, conjunction)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["whole-sign ray is conjunction"],"source":"ABU_MASHAR_GREAT_INTRODUCTION_DYKES 26","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"bodies.configured","predicateLabel":"configured(Sun, Saturn, conjunction)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Sun","glyph":"☉","longitude":193.93174145103276,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":13.931741451032764,"house":12,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["whole-sign ray is conjunction"],"source":"ABU_MASHAR_GREAT_INTRODUCTION_DYKES 26","sortOrder":2}],"calculationExplanation":"configured(Mercury, Saturn, conjunction) ∧ configured(Sun, Saturn, conjunction) => Medieval reflection of light","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Saturn receives departing light from Mercury and applying light from Sun, so this indicates a reflection-of-light relation.","interpretation":"Saturn receives departing light from Mercury and applying light from Sun, so this indicates a reflection-of-light relation.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-paulus-necessity-ruler-operates","factorKey":"lot:lot-of-necessity","factorLabel":"Lot of Necessity","ruleKey":"paulus_necessity_ruler_operates","ruleTitle":"Lot of Necessity is interpreted through its ruler, Saturn","doctrineClaim":"Lot of Necessity is interpreted through its ruler, Saturn","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Paulus","predicateKeys":["body.condition_component_score","body.condition_valence","body.direct_motion","body.house_joy","body.in_exaltation","body.in_face","body.in_house","body.in_sect","body.received_by","body.solar_proximity","body.triplicity_day","degree.face_ruler","house.cadent","lot.in_house","lot.ruler","sign.exaltation_ruler","sign.triplicity_ruler"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL"],"sourceKeys":["PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1299-1322"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1575-1590"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2684-2760"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2721-2770"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"68"}],"chartEvidence":["Libra 17 ruler is Saturn","Libra day triplicity ruler is Saturn","Libra ruler is Saturn","body is in sect","cadent(H12)","condition valence is bonified","day_triplicity(Saturn)","dignity score is 8","exaltation(Saturn)","face(Saturn)","house is 12","house is 4","house_strength score is -2","joy house is 12","joy score is 2","motion is direct","motion score is 1","received by Jupiter through bound","received by Jupiter through participating_triplicity","received by Venus through domicile","reception score is 5","rejoices in house is true","sect score is 1","solar proximity band is combust","solar separation is 3.53 degrees","total score is 11","traditional ruler is Saturn","visibility score is -4"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"lot.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Lot of Necessity) = 4","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Necessity","glyph":"⊗","longitude":311.1520572393906,"sign":"Aquarius","degree_in_sign":11.152057239390615,"house":4},"object":null,"observed":["house is 4"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"lot.ruler","predicateLabel":"ruler(Lot of Necessity) = Saturn","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Necessity","glyph":"⊗","longitude":311.1520572393906,"sign":"Aquarius","degree_in_sign":11.152057239390615,"house":4},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["traditional ruler is Saturn"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"house.cadent","predicateLabel":"cadent(H12)","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":["cadent(H12)"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"body.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Saturn) = 12","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["house is 12"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":4},{"predicateKey":"body.in_sect","predicateLabel":"BodyInSect { body: Saturn }","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["body is in sect"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":5},{"predicateKey":"body.direct_motion","predicateLabel":"direct_motion(Saturn)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["motion is direct"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":6},{"predicateKey":"body.in_exaltation","predicateLabel":"exaltation(Saturn)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["exaltation(Saturn)"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":7},{"predicateKey":"sign.exaltation_ruler","predicateLabel":"exaltation_ruler(Libra) = Saturn","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["Libra ruler is Saturn"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":8},{"predicateKey":"body.triplicity_day","predicateLabel":"day_triplicity(Saturn)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["day_triplicity(Saturn)"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":9},{"predicateKey":"sign.triplicity_ruler","predicateLabel":"triplicity_ruler(Libra.day) = Saturn","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["Libra day triplicity ruler is Saturn"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":10},{"predicateKey":"body.in_face","predicateLabel":"face(Saturn)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["face(Saturn)"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":11},{"predicateKey":"degree.face_ruler","predicateLabel":"face_ruler(Libra 17) = Saturn","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["Libra 17 ruler is Saturn"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":12},{"predicateKey":"body.solar_proximity","predicateLabel":"solar_proximity(Saturn) = combust at 3.53°","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Sun","glyph":"☉","longitude":193.93174145103276,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":13.931741451032764,"house":12,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["solar proximity band is combust","solar separation is 3.53 degrees"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":13},{"predicateKey":"body.house_joy","predicateLabel":"house_joy(Saturn) = H12; rejoices=true","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["joy house is 12","rejoices in house is true"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":14},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Saturn, Venus, domicile)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Venus","glyph":"♀","longitude":221.71180161400247,"sign":"Scorpio","degree_in_sign":11.711801614002468,"house":1,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["received by Venus through domicile"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":15},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Saturn, Jupiter, participating_triplicity)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"observed":["received by Jupiter through participating_triplicity"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":16},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Saturn, Jupiter, bound)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"observed":["received by Jupiter through bound"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":17},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Saturn, dignity) = 8","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["dignity score is 8"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":18},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Saturn, sect) = 1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["sect score is 1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":19},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Saturn, house_strength) = -2","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["house_strength score is -2"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":20},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Saturn, motion) = 1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["motion score is 1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":21},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Saturn, visibility) = -4","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["visibility score is -4"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":22},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Saturn, joy) = 2","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["joy score is 2"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":23},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Saturn, reception) = 5","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["reception score is 5"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":24},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Saturn, total) = 11","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["total score is 11"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":25},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_valence","predicateLabel":"condition(Saturn) = bonified","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["condition valence is bonified"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":26}],"calculationExplanation":"house(Lot of Necessity) = 4 ∧ ruler(Lot of Necessity) = Saturn ∧ cadent(H12) ∧ house(Saturn) = 12 ∧ BodyInSect { body: Saturn } ∧ direct_motion(Saturn) ∧ exaltation(Saturn) ∧ exaltation_ruler(Libra) = Saturn ∧ day_triplicity(Saturn) ∧ triplicity_ruler(Libra.day) = Saturn ∧ face(Saturn) ∧ face_ruler(Libra 17) = Saturn ∧ solar_proximity(Saturn) = combust at 3.53° ∧ house_joy(Saturn) = H12; rejoices=true ∧ reception(Saturn, Venus, domicile) ∧ reception(Saturn, Jupiter, participating_triplicity) ∧ reception(Saturn, Jupiter, bound) ∧ condition_component(Saturn, dignity) = 8 ∧ condition_component(Saturn, sect) = 1 ∧ condition_component(Saturn, house_strength) = -2 ∧ condition_component(Saturn, motion) = 1 ∧ condition_component(Saturn, visibility) = -4 ∧ condition_component(Saturn, joy) = 2 ∧ condition_component(Saturn, reception) = 5 ∧ condition_component(Saturn, total) = 11 ∧ condition(Saturn) = bonified => Lot of Necessity is interpreted through its ruler, Saturn","derivationKind":"source_shaped_synthesis","synthesisNote":"Deterministic condition synthesis over visible dignity, sect, place, motion, visibility, reception, joy, and score components.","interpretiveImplication":"The ruler of Lot of Necessity is Saturn in house 12 with a bonified condition, keeping constraint and struggle themes active through the ruler.","interpretation":"The ruler of Lot of Necessity is Saturn in house 12 with a bonified condition, keeping constraint and struggle themes active through the ruler.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-core-asc-ruler-bonified","factorKey":"body:mars","factorLabel":"Mars","ruleKey":"core_asc_ruler_bonified","ruleTitle":"Ascendant ruler has condition support","doctrineClaim":"Ascendant ruler has condition support","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["body.condition_component_score","body.condition_valence","body.direct_motion","body.in_bound","body.in_house","body.received_by","body.solar_proximity","body.succedent","degree.bound_ruler","house.ruler","house.succedent"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","TRAD-VALENS-ANTH"],"sourceKeys":["PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1299-1322"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1575-1590"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2684-2760"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2721-2770"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"68"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1631-1640"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1720-1728"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1724-1728"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1729-1736"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2360-2362"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2360-2363"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2361-2364"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2363-2365"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2365-2367"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2366-2368"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2368-2370"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2368-2371"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2370-2373"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2373-2376"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2375-2376"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2377-2381"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2378-2381"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2380-2383"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2382-2385"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2384-2386"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2386-2389"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2389-2390"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2389-2391"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2391-2392"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2392-2397"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2397-2399"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2399-2402"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2402-2404"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2403-2404"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2404-2405"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2405-2406"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2406"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2406-2407"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2407-2408"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2408-2409"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2409-2410"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2410-2411"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2441-2443"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2450-2451"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2454-2457"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2463-2465"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2465-2466"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2465-2468"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2472-2473"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2473-2474"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2479-2480"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2480-2481"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2481-2482"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2527"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2548"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2548; 4746-4756; 6326-6336"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2542-2544"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"4750-4753; 6331"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"68"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8024-8048"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8037-8041"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8098-8103"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"9388-9404"}],"chartEvidence":["Sagittarius 26 ruler is Mars","bound(Mars)","condition valence is bonified","dignity score is 1","house 1 ruler is Mars","house is 2","house is succedent","house_strength score is 1","joy score is -1","motion is direct","motion score is 1","received by Jupiter through domicile","received by Saturn through face","received by Saturn through participating_triplicity","received by Sun through triplicity","reception score is 6","sect score is -1","solar proximity band is outside_under_beams_threshold","solar separation is 72.59 degrees","succedent(H2)","total score is 8","visibility score is 1"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"house.ruler","predicateLabel":"ruler(H1) = Mars","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["house 1 ruler is Mars"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"body.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Mars) = 2","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["house is 2"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"house.succedent","predicateLabel":"succedent(H2)","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":["succedent(H2)"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"body.direct_motion","predicateLabel":"direct_motion(Mars)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["motion is direct"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":4},{"predicateKey":"body.in_bound","predicateLabel":"bound(Mars)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["bound(Mars)"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":5},{"predicateKey":"degree.bound_ruler","predicateLabel":"bound_ruler(Sagittarius 26) = Mars","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["Sagittarius 26 ruler is Mars"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":6},{"predicateKey":"body.solar_proximity","predicateLabel":"solar_proximity(Mars) = outside_under_beams_threshold at 72.59°","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Sun","glyph":"☉","longitude":193.93174145103276,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":13.931741451032764,"house":12,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["solar proximity band is outside_under_beams_threshold","solar separation is 72.59 degrees"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":7},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Mars, Sun, triplicity)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Sun","glyph":"☉","longitude":193.93174145103276,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":13.931741451032764,"house":12,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["received by Sun through triplicity"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":8},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Mars, Jupiter, domicile)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"observed":["received by Jupiter through domicile"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":9},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Mars, Saturn, participating_triplicity)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["received by Saturn through participating_triplicity"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":10},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Mars, Saturn, face)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["received by Saturn through face"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":11},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Mars, dignity) = 1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["dignity score is 1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":12},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Mars, sect) = -1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["sect score is -1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":13},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Mars, house_strength) = 1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["house_strength score is 1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":14},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Mars, motion) = 1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["motion score is 1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":15},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Mars, visibility) = 1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["visibility score is 1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":16},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Mars, joy) = -1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["joy score is -1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":17},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Mars, reception) = 6","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["reception score is 6"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":18},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Mars, total) = 8","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["total score is 8"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":19},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_valence","predicateLabel":"condition(Mars) = bonified","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["condition valence is bonified"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":20},{"predicateKey":"body.succedent","predicateLabel":"succedent(Mars)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["house is succedent"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":21}],"calculationExplanation":"ruler(H1) = Mars ∧ house(Mars) = 2 ∧ succedent(H2) ∧ direct_motion(Mars) ∧ bound(Mars) ∧ bound_ruler(Sagittarius 26) = Mars ∧ solar_proximity(Mars) = outside_under_beams_threshold at 72.59° ∧ reception(Mars, Sun, triplicity) ∧ reception(Mars, Jupiter, domicile) ∧ reception(Mars, Saturn, participating_triplicity) ∧ reception(Mars, Saturn, face) ∧ condition_component(Mars, dignity) = 1 ∧ condition_component(Mars, sect) = -1 ∧ condition_component(Mars, house_strength) = 1 ∧ condition_component(Mars, motion) = 1 ∧ condition_component(Mars, visibility) = 1 ∧ condition_component(Mars, joy) = -1 ∧ condition_component(Mars, reception) = 6 ∧ condition_component(Mars, total) = 8 ∧ condition(Mars) = bonified ∧ succedent(Mars) => Ascendant ruler has condition support","derivationKind":"source_shaped_synthesis","synthesisNote":"Deterministic condition synthesis over visible dignity, sect, place, motion, visibility, reception, joy, and score components.","interpretiveImplication":"Mars rules Ascendant and has moderately bonified, limited by H2 aversion to Ascendant, sect pressure, and house joy pressure; its house 2 placement and house strength remain separately inspectable for chart-level topics.","interpretation":"Mars rules Ascendant and has moderately bonified, limited by H2 aversion to Ascendant, sect pressure, and house joy pressure; its house 2 placement and house strength remain separately inspectable for chart-level topics.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-paulus-victory-ruler-operates","factorKey":"lot:lot-of-victory","factorLabel":"Lot of Victory","ruleKey":"paulus_victory_ruler_operates","ruleTitle":"Lot of Victory is interpreted through its ruler, Saturn","doctrineClaim":"Lot of Victory is interpreted through its ruler, Saturn","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Paulus","predicateKeys":["body.condition_component_score","body.condition_valence","body.direct_motion","body.house_joy","body.in_exaltation","body.in_face","body.in_house","body.in_sect","body.received_by","body.solar_proximity","body.triplicity_day","degree.face_ruler","house.cadent","lot.in_house","lot.ruler","sign.exaltation_ruler","sign.triplicity_ruler"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL"],"sourceKeys":["PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1299-1322"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1575-1590"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2684-2760"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2721-2770"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"68"}],"chartEvidence":["Libra 17 ruler is Saturn","Libra day triplicity ruler is Saturn","Libra ruler is Saturn","body is in sect","cadent(H12)","condition valence is bonified","day_triplicity(Saturn)","dignity score is 8","exaltation(Saturn)","face(Saturn)","house is 12","house is 3","house_strength score is -2","joy house is 12","joy score is 2","motion is direct","motion score is 1","received by Jupiter through bound","received by Jupiter through participating_triplicity","received by Venus through domicile","reception score is 5","rejoices in house is true","sect score is 1","solar proximity band is combust","solar separation is 3.53 degrees","total score is 11","traditional ruler is Saturn","visibility score is -4"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"lot.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Lot of Victory) = 3","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Victory","glyph":"⊗","longitude":278.7196406829929,"sign":"Capricorn","degree_in_sign":8.719640682992917,"house":3},"object":null,"observed":["house is 3"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"lot.ruler","predicateLabel":"ruler(Lot of Victory) = Saturn","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Victory","glyph":"⊗","longitude":278.7196406829929,"sign":"Capricorn","degree_in_sign":8.719640682992917,"house":3},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["traditional ruler is Saturn"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"house.cadent","predicateLabel":"cadent(H12)","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":["cadent(H12)"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"body.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Saturn) = 12","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["house is 12"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":4},{"predicateKey":"body.in_sect","predicateLabel":"BodyInSect { body: Saturn }","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["body is in sect"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":5},{"predicateKey":"body.direct_motion","predicateLabel":"direct_motion(Saturn)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["motion is direct"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":6},{"predicateKey":"body.in_exaltation","predicateLabel":"exaltation(Saturn)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["exaltation(Saturn)"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":7},{"predicateKey":"sign.exaltation_ruler","predicateLabel":"exaltation_ruler(Libra) = Saturn","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["Libra ruler is Saturn"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":8},{"predicateKey":"body.triplicity_day","predicateLabel":"day_triplicity(Saturn)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["day_triplicity(Saturn)"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":9},{"predicateKey":"sign.triplicity_ruler","predicateLabel":"triplicity_ruler(Libra.day) = Saturn","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["Libra day triplicity ruler is Saturn"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":10},{"predicateKey":"body.in_face","predicateLabel":"face(Saturn)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["face(Saturn)"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":11},{"predicateKey":"degree.face_ruler","predicateLabel":"face_ruler(Libra 17) = Saturn","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["Libra 17 ruler is Saturn"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":12},{"predicateKey":"body.solar_proximity","predicateLabel":"solar_proximity(Saturn) = combust at 3.53°","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Sun","glyph":"☉","longitude":193.93174145103276,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":13.931741451032764,"house":12,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["solar proximity band is combust","solar separation is 3.53 degrees"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":13},{"predicateKey":"body.house_joy","predicateLabel":"house_joy(Saturn) = H12; rejoices=true","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["joy house is 12","rejoices in house is true"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":14},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Saturn, Venus, domicile)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Venus","glyph":"♀","longitude":221.71180161400247,"sign":"Scorpio","degree_in_sign":11.711801614002468,"house":1,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["received by Venus through domicile"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":15},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Saturn, Jupiter, participating_triplicity)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"observed":["received by Jupiter through participating_triplicity"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":16},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Saturn, Jupiter, bound)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"observed":["received by Jupiter through bound"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":17},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Saturn, dignity) = 8","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["dignity score is 8"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":18},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Saturn, sect) = 1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["sect score is 1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":19},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Saturn, house_strength) = -2","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["house_strength score is -2"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":20},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Saturn, motion) = 1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["motion score is 1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":21},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Saturn, visibility) = -4","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["visibility score is -4"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":22},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Saturn, joy) = 2","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["joy score is 2"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":23},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Saturn, reception) = 5","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["reception score is 5"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":24},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Saturn, total) = 11","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["total score is 11"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":25},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_valence","predicateLabel":"condition(Saturn) = bonified","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["condition valence is bonified"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":26}],"calculationExplanation":"house(Lot of Victory) = 3 ∧ ruler(Lot of Victory) = Saturn ∧ cadent(H12) ∧ house(Saturn) = 12 ∧ BodyInSect { body: Saturn } ∧ direct_motion(Saturn) ∧ exaltation(Saturn) ∧ exaltation_ruler(Libra) = Saturn ∧ day_triplicity(Saturn) ∧ triplicity_ruler(Libra.day) = Saturn ∧ face(Saturn) ∧ face_ruler(Libra 17) = Saturn ∧ solar_proximity(Saturn) = combust at 3.53° ∧ house_joy(Saturn) = H12; rejoices=true ∧ reception(Saturn, Venus, domicile) ∧ reception(Saturn, Jupiter, participating_triplicity) ∧ reception(Saturn, Jupiter, bound) ∧ condition_component(Saturn, dignity) = 8 ∧ condition_component(Saturn, sect) = 1 ∧ condition_component(Saturn, house_strength) = -2 ∧ condition_component(Saturn, motion) = 1 ∧ condition_component(Saturn, visibility) = -4 ∧ condition_component(Saturn, joy) = 2 ∧ condition_component(Saturn, reception) = 5 ∧ condition_component(Saturn, total) = 11 ∧ condition(Saturn) = bonified => Lot of Victory is interpreted through its ruler, Saturn","derivationKind":"source_shaped_synthesis","synthesisNote":"Deterministic condition synthesis over visible dignity, sect, place, motion, visibility, reception, joy, and score components.","interpretiveImplication":"The ruler of Lot of Victory is Saturn in house 12 with a bonified condition, keeping confidence, contest, and associative-success themes active through the ruler.","interpretation":"The ruler of Lot of Victory is Saturn in house 12 with a bonified condition, keeping confidence, contest, and associative-success themes active through the ruler.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-core-courage-ruler-bonified","factorKey":"lot:lot-of-courage","factorLabel":"Lot of Courage","ruleKey":"core_courage_ruler_bonified","ruleTitle":"Courage ruler has condition support","doctrineClaim":"Courage ruler has condition support","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["body.condition_component_score","body.condition_valence","body.direct_motion","body.in_bound","body.in_house","body.received_by","body.solar_proximity","body.succedent","degree.bound_ruler","house.succedent","lot.in_house","lot.ruler"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL"],"sourceKeys":["PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1299-1322"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1575-1590"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2684-2760"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2721-2770"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"68"}],"chartEvidence":["Sagittarius 26 ruler is Mars","bound(Mars)","condition valence is bonified","dignity score is 1","house is 2","house is 6","house is succedent","house_strength score is 1","joy score is -1","motion is direct","motion score is 1","received by Jupiter through domicile","received by Saturn through face","received by Saturn through participating_triplicity","received by Sun through triplicity","reception score is 6","sect score is -1","solar proximity band is outside_under_beams_threshold","solar separation is 72.59 degrees","succedent(H2)","total score is 8","traditional ruler is Mars","visibility score is 1"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"lot.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Lot of Courage) = 6","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Courage","glyph":"⊗","longitude":28.85636579820971,"sign":"Aries","degree_in_sign":28.85636579820971,"house":6},"object":null,"observed":["house is 6"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"lot.ruler","predicateLabel":"ruler(Lot of Courage) = Mars","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Courage","glyph":"⊗","longitude":28.85636579820971,"sign":"Aries","degree_in_sign":28.85636579820971,"house":6},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["traditional ruler is Mars"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"body.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Mars) = 2","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["house is 2"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"house.succedent","predicateLabel":"succedent(H2)","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":["succedent(H2)"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":4},{"predicateKey":"body.direct_motion","predicateLabel":"direct_motion(Mars)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["motion is direct"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":5},{"predicateKey":"body.in_bound","predicateLabel":"bound(Mars)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["bound(Mars)"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":6},{"predicateKey":"degree.bound_ruler","predicateLabel":"bound_ruler(Sagittarius 26) = Mars","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["Sagittarius 26 ruler is Mars"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":7},{"predicateKey":"body.solar_proximity","predicateLabel":"solar_proximity(Mars) = outside_under_beams_threshold at 72.59°","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Sun","glyph":"☉","longitude":193.93174145103276,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":13.931741451032764,"house":12,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["solar proximity band is outside_under_beams_threshold","solar separation is 72.59 degrees"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":8},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Mars, Sun, triplicity)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Sun","glyph":"☉","longitude":193.93174145103276,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":13.931741451032764,"house":12,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["received by Sun through triplicity"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":9},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Mars, Jupiter, domicile)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"observed":["received by Jupiter through domicile"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":10},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Mars, Saturn, participating_triplicity)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["received by Saturn through participating_triplicity"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":11},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Mars, Saturn, face)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["received by Saturn through face"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":12},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Mars, dignity) = 1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["dignity score is 1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":13},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Mars, sect) = -1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["sect score is -1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":14},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Mars, house_strength) = 1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["house_strength score is 1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":15},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Mars, motion) = 1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["motion score is 1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":16},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Mars, visibility) = 1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["visibility score is 1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":17},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Mars, joy) = -1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["joy score is -1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":18},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Mars, reception) = 6","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["reception score is 6"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":19},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Mars, total) = 8","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["total score is 8"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":20},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_valence","predicateLabel":"condition(Mars) = bonified","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["condition valence is bonified"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":21},{"predicateKey":"body.succedent","predicateLabel":"succedent(Mars)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["house is succedent"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":22}],"calculationExplanation":"house(Lot of Courage) = 6 ∧ ruler(Lot of Courage) = Mars ∧ house(Mars) = 2 ∧ succedent(H2) ∧ direct_motion(Mars) ∧ bound(Mars) ∧ bound_ruler(Sagittarius 26) = Mars ∧ solar_proximity(Mars) = outside_under_beams_threshold at 72.59° ∧ reception(Mars, Sun, triplicity) ∧ reception(Mars, Jupiter, domicile) ∧ reception(Mars, Saturn, participating_triplicity) ∧ reception(Mars, Saturn, face) ∧ condition_component(Mars, dignity) = 1 ∧ condition_component(Mars, sect) = -1 ∧ condition_component(Mars, house_strength) = 1 ∧ condition_component(Mars, motion) = 1 ∧ condition_component(Mars, visibility) = 1 ∧ condition_component(Mars, joy) = -1 ∧ condition_component(Mars, reception) = 6 ∧ condition_component(Mars, total) = 8 ∧ condition(Mars) = bonified ∧ succedent(Mars) => Courage ruler has condition support","derivationKind":"source_shaped_synthesis","synthesisNote":"Deterministic condition synthesis over visible dignity, sect, place, motion, visibility, reception, joy, and score components.","interpretiveImplication":"Mars rules Lot of Courage and has moderately bonified, limited by H2 aversion to Ascendant, sect pressure, and house joy pressure; its house 2 placement and house strength remain separately inspectable for daring, force, and risk-bearing topics.","interpretation":"Mars rules Lot of Courage and has moderately bonified, limited by H2 aversion to Ascendant, sect pressure, and house joy pressure; its house 2 placement and house strength remain separately inspectable for daring, force, and risk-bearing topics.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-core-necessity-ruler-bonified","factorKey":"lot:lot-of-necessity","factorLabel":"Lot of Necessity","ruleKey":"core_necessity_ruler_bonified","ruleTitle":"Necessity ruler has condition support","doctrineClaim":"Necessity ruler has condition support","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["body.condition_component_score","body.condition_valence","body.direct_motion","body.house_joy","body.in_exaltation","body.in_face","body.in_house","body.in_sect","body.received_by","body.solar_proximity","body.triplicity_day","degree.face_ruler","house.cadent","lot.in_house","lot.ruler","sign.exaltation_ruler","sign.triplicity_ruler"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL"],"sourceKeys":["PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1299-1322"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1575-1590"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2684-2760"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2721-2770"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"68"}],"chartEvidence":["Libra 17 ruler is Saturn","Libra day triplicity ruler is Saturn","Libra ruler is Saturn","body is in sect","cadent(H12)","condition valence is bonified","day_triplicity(Saturn)","dignity score is 8","exaltation(Saturn)","face(Saturn)","house is 12","house is 4","house_strength score is -2","joy house is 12","joy score is 2","motion is direct","motion score is 1","received by Jupiter through bound","received by Jupiter through participating_triplicity","received by Venus through domicile","reception score is 5","rejoices in house is true","sect score is 1","solar proximity band is combust","solar separation is 3.53 degrees","total score is 11","traditional ruler is Saturn","visibility score is -4"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"lot.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Lot of Necessity) = 4","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Necessity","glyph":"⊗","longitude":311.1520572393906,"sign":"Aquarius","degree_in_sign":11.152057239390615,"house":4},"object":null,"observed":["house is 4"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"lot.ruler","predicateLabel":"ruler(Lot of Necessity) = Saturn","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Necessity","glyph":"⊗","longitude":311.1520572393906,"sign":"Aquarius","degree_in_sign":11.152057239390615,"house":4},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["traditional ruler is Saturn"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"body.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Saturn) = 12","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["house is 12"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"house.cadent","predicateLabel":"cadent(H12)","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":["cadent(H12)"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":4},{"predicateKey":"body.in_sect","predicateLabel":"BodyInSect { body: Saturn }","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["body is in sect"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":5},{"predicateKey":"body.direct_motion","predicateLabel":"direct_motion(Saturn)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["motion is direct"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":6},{"predicateKey":"body.in_exaltation","predicateLabel":"exaltation(Saturn)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["exaltation(Saturn)"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":7},{"predicateKey":"sign.exaltation_ruler","predicateLabel":"exaltation_ruler(Libra) = Saturn","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["Libra ruler is Saturn"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":8},{"predicateKey":"body.triplicity_day","predicateLabel":"day_triplicity(Saturn)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["day_triplicity(Saturn)"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":9},{"predicateKey":"sign.triplicity_ruler","predicateLabel":"triplicity_ruler(Libra.day) = Saturn","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["Libra day triplicity ruler is Saturn"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":10},{"predicateKey":"body.in_face","predicateLabel":"face(Saturn)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["face(Saturn)"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":11},{"predicateKey":"degree.face_ruler","predicateLabel":"face_ruler(Libra 17) = Saturn","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["Libra 17 ruler is Saturn"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":12},{"predicateKey":"body.solar_proximity","predicateLabel":"solar_proximity(Saturn) = combust at 3.53°","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Sun","glyph":"☉","longitude":193.93174145103276,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":13.931741451032764,"house":12,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["solar proximity band is combust","solar separation is 3.53 degrees"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":13},{"predicateKey":"body.house_joy","predicateLabel":"house_joy(Saturn) = H12; rejoices=true","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["joy house is 12","rejoices in house is true"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":14},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Saturn, Venus, domicile)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Venus","glyph":"♀","longitude":221.71180161400247,"sign":"Scorpio","degree_in_sign":11.711801614002468,"house":1,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["received by Venus through domicile"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":15},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Saturn, Jupiter, participating_triplicity)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"observed":["received by Jupiter through participating_triplicity"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":16},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Saturn, Jupiter, bound)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"observed":["received by Jupiter through bound"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":17},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Saturn, dignity) = 8","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["dignity score is 8"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":18},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Saturn, sect) = 1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["sect score is 1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":19},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Saturn, house_strength) = -2","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["house_strength score is -2"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":20},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Saturn, motion) = 1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["motion score is 1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":21},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Saturn, visibility) = -4","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["visibility score is -4"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":22},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Saturn, joy) = 2","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["joy score is 2"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":23},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Saturn, reception) = 5","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["reception score is 5"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":24},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Saturn, total) = 11","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["total score is 11"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":25},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_valence","predicateLabel":"condition(Saturn) = bonified","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["condition valence is bonified"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":26}],"calculationExplanation":"house(Lot of Necessity) = 4 ∧ ruler(Lot of Necessity) = Saturn ∧ house(Saturn) = 12 ∧ cadent(H12) ∧ BodyInSect { body: Saturn } ∧ direct_motion(Saturn) ∧ exaltation(Saturn) ∧ exaltation_ruler(Libra) = Saturn ∧ day_triplicity(Saturn) ∧ triplicity_ruler(Libra.day) = Saturn ∧ face(Saturn) ∧ face_ruler(Libra 17) = Saturn ∧ solar_proximity(Saturn) = combust at 3.53° ∧ house_joy(Saturn) = H12; rejoices=true ∧ reception(Saturn, Venus, domicile) ∧ reception(Saturn, Jupiter, participating_triplicity) ∧ reception(Saturn, Jupiter, bound) ∧ condition_component(Saturn, dignity) = 8 ∧ condition_component(Saturn, sect) = 1 ∧ condition_component(Saturn, house_strength) = -2 ∧ condition_component(Saturn, motion) = 1 ∧ condition_component(Saturn, visibility) = -4 ∧ condition_component(Saturn, joy) = 2 ∧ condition_component(Saturn, reception) = 5 ∧ condition_component(Saturn, total) = 11 ∧ condition(Saturn) = bonified => Necessity ruler has condition support","derivationKind":"source_shaped_synthesis","synthesisNote":"Deterministic condition synthesis over visible dignity, sect, place, motion, visibility, reception, joy, and score components.","interpretiveImplication":"Saturn rules Lot of Necessity and has slightly bonified, limited by H12 aversion to Ascendant, cadent house pressure, and visibility pressure; its house 12 placement and house strength remain separately inspectable for constraint, struggle, and coercive topics.","interpretation":"Saturn rules Lot of Necessity and has slightly bonified, limited by H12 aversion to Ascendant, cadent house pressure, and visibility pressure; its house 12 placement and house strength remain separately inspectable for constraint, struggle, and coercive topics.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-paulus-eros-ruler-operates","factorKey":"lot:lot-of-eros","factorLabel":"Lot of Eros","ruleKey":"paulus_eros_ruler_operates","ruleTitle":"Lot of Eros is interpreted through its ruler, Moon","doctrineClaim":"Lot of Eros is interpreted through its ruler, Moon","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Paulus","predicateKeys":["body.condition_component_score","body.condition_valence","body.direct_motion","body.in_house","body.received_by","body.solar_proximity","house.succedent","lot.in_house","lot.ruler"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL"],"sourceKeys":["PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1299-1322"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1575-1590"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2684-2760"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2721-2770"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"68"}],"chartEvidence":["condition valence is bonified","house is 8","house is 9","house_strength score is 1","joy score is -1","motion is direct","motion score is 1","received by Jupiter through face","received by Jupiter through participating_triplicity","received by Mercury through bound","received by Mercury through domicile","received by Saturn through triplicity","reception score is 7","sect score is -2","solar proximity band is outside_under_beams_threshold","solar separation is 131.02 degrees","succedent(H8)","total score is 7","traditional ruler is Moon","visibility score is 1"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"lot.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Lot of Eros) = 9","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Eros","glyph":"⊗","longitude":115.25154647929185,"sign":"Cancer","degree_in_sign":25.251546479291846,"house":9},"object":null,"observed":["house is 9"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"lot.ruler","predicateLabel":"ruler(Lot of Eros) = Moon","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Eros","glyph":"⊗","longitude":115.25154647929185,"sign":"Cancer","degree_in_sign":25.251546479291846,"house":9},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["traditional ruler is Moon"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"house.succedent","predicateLabel":"succedent(H8)","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":["succedent(H8)"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"body.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Moon) = 8","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["house is 8"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":4},{"predicateKey":"body.direct_motion","predicateLabel":"direct_motion(Moon)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["motion is direct"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":5},{"predicateKey":"body.solar_proximity","predicateLabel":"solar_proximity(Moon) = outside_under_beams_threshold at 131.02°","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Sun","glyph":"☉","longitude":193.93174145103276,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":13.931741451032764,"house":12,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["solar proximity band is outside_under_beams_threshold","solar separation is 131.02 degrees"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":6},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Moon, Mercury, domicile)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["received by Mercury through domicile"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":7},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Moon, Mercury, bound)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["received by Mercury through bound"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":8},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Moon, Jupiter, participating_triplicity)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"observed":["received by Jupiter through participating_triplicity"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":9},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Moon, Jupiter, face)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"observed":["received by Jupiter through face"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":10},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Moon, Saturn, triplicity)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["received by Saturn through triplicity"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":11},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Moon, sect) = -2","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["sect score is -2"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":12},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Moon, house_strength) = 1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["house_strength score is 1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":13},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Moon, motion) = 1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["motion score is 1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":14},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Moon, visibility) = 1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["visibility score is 1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":15},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Moon, joy) = -1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["joy score is -1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":16},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Moon, reception) = 7","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["reception score is 7"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":17},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Moon, total) = 7","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["total score is 7"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":18},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_valence","predicateLabel":"condition(Moon) = bonified","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["condition valence is bonified"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":19}],"calculationExplanation":"house(Lot of Eros) = 9 ∧ ruler(Lot of Eros) = Moon ∧ succedent(H8) ∧ house(Moon) = 8 ∧ direct_motion(Moon) ∧ solar_proximity(Moon) = outside_under_beams_threshold at 131.02° ∧ reception(Moon, Mercury, domicile) ∧ reception(Moon, Mercury, bound) ∧ reception(Moon, Jupiter, participating_triplicity) ∧ reception(Moon, Jupiter, face) ∧ reception(Moon, Saturn, triplicity) ∧ condition_component(Moon, sect) = -2 ∧ condition_component(Moon, house_strength) = 1 ∧ condition_component(Moon, motion) = 1 ∧ condition_component(Moon, visibility) = 1 ∧ condition_component(Moon, joy) = -1 ∧ condition_component(Moon, reception) = 7 ∧ condition_component(Moon, total) = 7 ∧ condition(Moon) = bonified => Lot of Eros is interpreted through its ruler, Moon","derivationKind":"source_shaped_synthesis","synthesisNote":"Deterministic condition synthesis over visible dignity, sect, place, motion, visibility, reception, joy, and score components.","interpretiveImplication":"The ruler of Lot of Eros is Moon in house 8 with a bonified condition, keeping desire and friendship themes active through the ruler.","interpretation":"The ruler of Lot of Eros is Moon in house 8 with a bonified condition, keeping desire and friendship themes active through the ruler.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-ptolemy-malefic-in-exaltation","factorKey":"body:saturn","factorLabel":"Saturn","ruleKey":"ptolemy_malefic_in_exaltation","ruleTitle":"Ptolemaic malefic Saturn in exaltation","doctrineClaim":"Ptolemaic malefic Saturn in exaltation","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Ptolemy","predicateKeys":["body.in_exaltation","body.in_house","house.cadent","sign.exaltation_ruler"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA"],"sourceKeys":["TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"49"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"57"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"79"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"81"}],"chartEvidence":["Libra ruler is Saturn","cadent(H12)","exaltation(Saturn)","house is 12"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"house.cadent","predicateLabel":"cadent(H12)","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":["cadent(H12)"],"source":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS 44","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"body.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Saturn) = 12","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["house is 12"],"source":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS 44","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"body.in_exaltation","predicateLabel":"exaltation(Saturn)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["exaltation(Saturn)"],"source":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS 44","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"sign.exaltation_ruler","predicateLabel":"exaltation_ruler(Libra) = Saturn","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["Libra ruler is Saturn"],"source":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS 44","sortOrder":4}],"calculationExplanation":"cadent(H12) ∧ house(Saturn) = 12 ∧ exaltation(Saturn) ∧ exaltation_ruler(Libra) = Saturn => Ptolemaic malefic Saturn in exaltation","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Malefic Saturn is in its exaltation in house 12, so this indicates a Ptolemaic exaltation condition without pretending the malefic quality disappears.","interpretation":"Malefic Saturn is in its exaltation in house 12, so this indicates a Ptolemaic exaltation condition without pretending the malefic quality disappears.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-core-eros-ruler-bonified","factorKey":"lot:lot-of-eros","factorLabel":"Lot of Eros","ruleKey":"core_eros_ruler_bonified","ruleTitle":"Lot of Eros ruler has condition support","doctrineClaim":"Lot of Eros ruler has condition support","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["body.condition_component_score","body.condition_valence","body.direct_motion","body.in_house","body.received_by","body.solar_proximity","body.succedent","house.succedent","lot.in_house","lot.ruler"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL"],"sourceKeys":["PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1299-1322"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1575-1590"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2684-2760"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2721-2770"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"68"}],"chartEvidence":["condition valence is bonified","house is 8","house is 9","house is succedent","house_strength score is 1","joy score is -1","motion is direct","motion score is 1","received by Jupiter through face","received by Jupiter through participating_triplicity","received by Mercury through bound","received by Mercury through domicile","received by Saturn through triplicity","reception score is 7","sect score is -2","solar proximity band is outside_under_beams_threshold","solar separation is 131.02 degrees","succedent(H8)","total score is 7","traditional ruler is Moon","visibility score is 1"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"lot.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Lot of Eros) = 9","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Eros","glyph":"⊗","longitude":115.25154647929185,"sign":"Cancer","degree_in_sign":25.251546479291846,"house":9},"object":null,"observed":["house is 9"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"lot.ruler","predicateLabel":"ruler(Lot of Eros) = Moon","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Eros","glyph":"⊗","longitude":115.25154647929185,"sign":"Cancer","degree_in_sign":25.251546479291846,"house":9},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["traditional ruler is Moon"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"body.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Moon) = 8","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["house is 8"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"house.succedent","predicateLabel":"succedent(H8)","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":["succedent(H8)"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":4},{"predicateKey":"body.direct_motion","predicateLabel":"direct_motion(Moon)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["motion is direct"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":5},{"predicateKey":"body.solar_proximity","predicateLabel":"solar_proximity(Moon) = outside_under_beams_threshold at 131.02°","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Sun","glyph":"☉","longitude":193.93174145103276,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":13.931741451032764,"house":12,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["solar proximity band is outside_under_beams_threshold","solar separation is 131.02 degrees"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":6},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Moon, Mercury, domicile)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["received by Mercury through domicile"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":7},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Moon, Mercury, bound)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["received by Mercury through bound"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":8},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Moon, Jupiter, participating_triplicity)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"observed":["received by Jupiter through participating_triplicity"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":9},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Moon, Jupiter, face)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"observed":["received by Jupiter through face"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":10},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Moon, Saturn, triplicity)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["received by Saturn through triplicity"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":11},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Moon, sect) = -2","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["sect score is -2"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":12},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Moon, house_strength) = 1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["house_strength score is 1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":13},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Moon, motion) = 1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["motion score is 1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":14},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Moon, visibility) = 1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["visibility score is 1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":15},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Moon, joy) = -1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["joy score is -1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":16},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Moon, reception) = 7","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["reception score is 7"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":17},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Moon, total) = 7","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["total score is 7"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":18},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_valence","predicateLabel":"condition(Moon) = bonified","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["condition valence is bonified"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":19},{"predicateKey":"body.succedent","predicateLabel":"succedent(Moon)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Moon","glyph":"☽","longitude":62.90686914105744,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":2.9068691410574417,"house":8,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["house is succedent"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":20}],"calculationExplanation":"house(Lot of Eros) = 9 ∧ ruler(Lot of Eros) = Moon ∧ house(Moon) = 8 ∧ succedent(H8) ∧ direct_motion(Moon) ∧ solar_proximity(Moon) = outside_under_beams_threshold at 131.02° ∧ reception(Moon, Mercury, domicile) ∧ reception(Moon, Mercury, bound) ∧ reception(Moon, Jupiter, participating_triplicity) ∧ reception(Moon, Jupiter, face) ∧ reception(Moon, Saturn, triplicity) ∧ condition_component(Moon, sect) = -2 ∧ condition_component(Moon, house_strength) = 1 ∧ condition_component(Moon, motion) = 1 ∧ condition_component(Moon, visibility) = 1 ∧ condition_component(Moon, joy) = -1 ∧ condition_component(Moon, reception) = 7 ∧ condition_component(Moon, total) = 7 ∧ condition(Moon) = bonified ∧ succedent(Moon) => Lot of Eros ruler has condition support","derivationKind":"source_shaped_synthesis","synthesisNote":"Deterministic condition synthesis over visible dignity, sect, place, motion, visibility, reception, joy, and score components.","interpretiveImplication":"Moon rules Lot of Eros and has moderately bonified, limited by H8 aversion to Ascendant, sect pressure, and house joy pressure; its house 8 placement and house strength remain separately inspectable for desire, friendship, and mutual-favor topics.","interpretation":"Moon rules Lot of Eros and has moderately bonified, limited by H8 aversion to Ascendant, sect pressure, and house joy pressure; its house 8 placement and house strength remain separately inspectable for desire, friendship, and mutual-favor topics.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-core-necessity-ruler-in-sect","factorKey":"lot:lot-of-necessity","factorLabel":"Lot of Necessity","ruleKey":"core_necessity_ruler_in_sect","ruleTitle":"Necessity ruler is in sect","doctrineClaim":"Necessity ruler is in sect","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["body.in_house","body.in_sect","house.cadent","lot.in_house","lot.ruler"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL"],"sourceKeys":["PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1299-1322"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1575-1590"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2684-2760"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2721-2770"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"68"}],"chartEvidence":["body is in sect","cadent(H12)","house is 12","house is 4","traditional ruler is Saturn"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"lot.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Lot of Necessity) = 4","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Necessity","glyph":"⊗","longitude":311.1520572393906,"sign":"Aquarius","degree_in_sign":11.152057239390615,"house":4},"object":null,"observed":["house is 4"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"lot.ruler","predicateLabel":"ruler(Lot of Necessity) = Saturn","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Necessity","glyph":"⊗","longitude":311.1520572393906,"sign":"Aquarius","degree_in_sign":11.152057239390615,"house":4},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["traditional ruler is Saturn"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"body.in_sect","predicateLabel":"BodyInSect { body: Saturn }","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["body is in sect"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"house.cadent","predicateLabel":"cadent(H12)","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":["cadent(H12)"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":4},{"predicateKey":"body.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Saturn) = 12","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["house is 12"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":5}],"calculationExplanation":"house(Lot of Necessity) = 4 ∧ ruler(Lot of Necessity) = Saturn ∧ BodyInSect { body: Saturn } ∧ cadent(H12) ∧ house(Saturn) = 12 => Necessity ruler is in sect","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Saturn rules Lot of Necessity and is in sect, so it is read as better able to express constraint, struggle, and coercive topics.","interpretation":"Saturn rules Lot of Necessity and is in sect, so it is read as better able to express constraint, struggle, and coercive topics.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-core-victory-ruler-bonified","factorKey":"lot:lot-of-victory","factorLabel":"Lot of Victory","ruleKey":"core_victory_ruler_bonified","ruleTitle":"Victory ruler has condition support","doctrineClaim":"Victory ruler has condition support","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["body.condition_component_score","body.condition_valence","body.direct_motion","body.house_joy","body.in_exaltation","body.in_face","body.in_house","body.in_sect","body.received_by","body.solar_proximity","body.triplicity_day","degree.face_ruler","house.cadent","lot.in_house","lot.ruler","sign.exaltation_ruler","sign.triplicity_ruler"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL"],"sourceKeys":["PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1299-1322"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1575-1590"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2684-2760"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2721-2770"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"68"}],"chartEvidence":["Libra 17 ruler is Saturn","Libra day triplicity ruler is Saturn","Libra ruler is Saturn","body is in sect","cadent(H12)","condition valence is bonified","day_triplicity(Saturn)","dignity score is 8","exaltation(Saturn)","face(Saturn)","house is 12","house is 3","house_strength score is -2","joy house is 12","joy score is 2","motion is direct","motion score is 1","received by Jupiter through bound","received by Jupiter through participating_triplicity","received by Venus through domicile","reception score is 5","rejoices in house is true","sect score is 1","solar proximity band is combust","solar separation is 3.53 degrees","total score is 11","traditional ruler is Saturn","visibility score is -4"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"lot.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Lot of Victory) = 3","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Victory","glyph":"⊗","longitude":278.7196406829929,"sign":"Capricorn","degree_in_sign":8.719640682992917,"house":3},"object":null,"observed":["house is 3"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"lot.ruler","predicateLabel":"ruler(Lot of Victory) = Saturn","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Victory","glyph":"⊗","longitude":278.7196406829929,"sign":"Capricorn","degree_in_sign":8.719640682992917,"house":3},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["traditional ruler is Saturn"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"body.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Saturn) = 12","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["house is 12"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"house.cadent","predicateLabel":"cadent(H12)","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":["cadent(H12)"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":4},{"predicateKey":"body.in_sect","predicateLabel":"BodyInSect { body: Saturn }","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["body is in sect"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":5},{"predicateKey":"body.direct_motion","predicateLabel":"direct_motion(Saturn)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["motion is direct"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":6},{"predicateKey":"body.in_exaltation","predicateLabel":"exaltation(Saturn)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["exaltation(Saturn)"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":7},{"predicateKey":"sign.exaltation_ruler","predicateLabel":"exaltation_ruler(Libra) = Saturn","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["Libra ruler is Saturn"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":8},{"predicateKey":"body.triplicity_day","predicateLabel":"day_triplicity(Saturn)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["day_triplicity(Saturn)"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":9},{"predicateKey":"sign.triplicity_ruler","predicateLabel":"triplicity_ruler(Libra.day) = Saturn","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["Libra day triplicity ruler is Saturn"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":10},{"predicateKey":"body.in_face","predicateLabel":"face(Saturn)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["face(Saturn)"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":11},{"predicateKey":"degree.face_ruler","predicateLabel":"face_ruler(Libra 17) = Saturn","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["Libra 17 ruler is Saturn"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":12},{"predicateKey":"body.solar_proximity","predicateLabel":"solar_proximity(Saturn) = combust at 3.53°","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Sun","glyph":"☉","longitude":193.93174145103276,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":13.931741451032764,"house":12,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["solar proximity band is combust","solar separation is 3.53 degrees"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":13},{"predicateKey":"body.house_joy","predicateLabel":"house_joy(Saturn) = H12; rejoices=true","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["joy house is 12","rejoices in house is true"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":14},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Saturn, Venus, domicile)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Venus","glyph":"♀","longitude":221.71180161400247,"sign":"Scorpio","degree_in_sign":11.711801614002468,"house":1,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["received by Venus through domicile"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":15},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Saturn, Jupiter, participating_triplicity)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"observed":["received by Jupiter through participating_triplicity"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":16},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Saturn, Jupiter, bound)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"observed":["received by Jupiter through bound"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":17},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Saturn, dignity) = 8","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["dignity score is 8"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":18},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Saturn, sect) = 1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["sect score is 1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":19},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Saturn, house_strength) = -2","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["house_strength score is -2"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":20},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Saturn, motion) = 1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["motion score is 1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":21},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Saturn, visibility) = -4","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["visibility score is -4"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":22},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Saturn, joy) = 2","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["joy score is 2"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":23},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Saturn, reception) = 5","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["reception score is 5"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":24},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Saturn, total) = 11","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["total score is 11"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":25},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_valence","predicateLabel":"condition(Saturn) = bonified","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["condition valence is bonified"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":26}],"calculationExplanation":"house(Lot of Victory) = 3 ∧ ruler(Lot of Victory) = Saturn ∧ house(Saturn) = 12 ∧ cadent(H12) ∧ BodyInSect { body: Saturn } ∧ direct_motion(Saturn) ∧ exaltation(Saturn) ∧ exaltation_ruler(Libra) = Saturn ∧ day_triplicity(Saturn) ∧ triplicity_ruler(Libra.day) = Saturn ∧ face(Saturn) ∧ face_ruler(Libra 17) = Saturn ∧ solar_proximity(Saturn) = combust at 3.53° ∧ house_joy(Saturn) = H12; rejoices=true ∧ reception(Saturn, Venus, domicile) ∧ reception(Saturn, Jupiter, participating_triplicity) ∧ reception(Saturn, Jupiter, bound) ∧ condition_component(Saturn, dignity) = 8 ∧ condition_component(Saturn, sect) = 1 ∧ condition_component(Saturn, house_strength) = -2 ∧ condition_component(Saturn, motion) = 1 ∧ condition_component(Saturn, visibility) = -4 ∧ condition_component(Saturn, joy) = 2 ∧ condition_component(Saturn, reception) = 5 ∧ condition_component(Saturn, total) = 11 ∧ condition(Saturn) = bonified => Victory ruler has condition support","derivationKind":"source_shaped_synthesis","synthesisNote":"Deterministic condition synthesis over visible dignity, sect, place, motion, visibility, reception, joy, and score components.","interpretiveImplication":"Saturn rules Lot of Victory and has slightly bonified, limited by H12 aversion to Ascendant, cadent house pressure, and visibility pressure; its house 12 placement and house strength remain separately inspectable for confidence, contest, and associative-success topics.","interpretation":"Saturn rules Lot of Victory and has slightly bonified, limited by H12 aversion to Ascendant, cadent house pressure, and visibility pressure; its house 12 placement and house strength remain separately inspectable for confidence, contest, and associative-success topics.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-ptolemy-asc-ruler-and-sect-light-configure","factorKey":"body:mars","factorLabel":"Mars","ruleKey":"ptolemy_asc_ruler_and_sect_light_configure","ruleTitle":"Ptolemaic Ascendant ruler and sect light configure","doctrineClaim":"Ptolemaic Ascendant ruler and sect light configure","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Ptolemy","predicateKeys":["bodies.configured"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA"],"sourceKeys":["TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"49"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"57"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"79"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"81"}],"chartEvidence":["whole-sign ray is sextile"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"bodies.configured","predicateLabel":"configured(Mars, Sun, sextile)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Sun","glyph":"☉","longitude":193.93174145103276,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":13.931741451032764,"house":12,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["whole-sign ray is sextile"],"source":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS 44","sortOrder":1}],"calculationExplanation":"configured(Mars, Sun, sextile) => Ptolemaic Ascendant ruler and sect light configure","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Mars and the sect light Sun see one another by sextile, so this is read as a Ptolemaic sign relationship.","interpretation":"Mars and the sect light Sun see one another by sextile, so this is read as a Ptolemaic sign relationship.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-core-victory-ruler-in-sect","factorKey":"lot:lot-of-victory","factorLabel":"Lot of Victory","ruleKey":"core_victory_ruler_in_sect","ruleTitle":"Victory ruler is in sect","doctrineClaim":"Victory ruler is in sect","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["body.in_house","body.in_sect","house.cadent","lot.in_house","lot.ruler"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL"],"sourceKeys":["PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1299-1322"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1575-1590"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2684-2760"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2721-2770"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"68"}],"chartEvidence":["body is in sect","cadent(H12)","house is 12","house is 3","traditional ruler is Saturn"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"lot.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Lot of Victory) = 3","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Victory","glyph":"⊗","longitude":278.7196406829929,"sign":"Capricorn","degree_in_sign":8.719640682992917,"house":3},"object":null,"observed":["house is 3"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"lot.ruler","predicateLabel":"ruler(Lot of Victory) = Saturn","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Victory","glyph":"⊗","longitude":278.7196406829929,"sign":"Capricorn","degree_in_sign":8.719640682992917,"house":3},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["traditional ruler is Saturn"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"body.in_sect","predicateLabel":"BodyInSect { body: Saturn }","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["body is in sect"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"house.cadent","predicateLabel":"cadent(H12)","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":["cadent(H12)"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":4},{"predicateKey":"body.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Saturn) = 12","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["house is 12"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":5}],"calculationExplanation":"house(Lot of Victory) = 3 ∧ ruler(Lot of Victory) = Saturn ∧ BodyInSect { body: Saturn } ∧ cadent(H12) ∧ house(Saturn) = 12 => Victory ruler is in sect","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Saturn rules Lot of Victory and is in sect, so it is read as better able to express confidence, contest, and associative-success topics.","interpretation":"Saturn rules Lot of Victory and is in sect, so it is read as better able to express confidence, contest, and associative-success topics.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-paulus-ascendant-monomoiria","factorKey":"rule:paulus-ascendant-monomoiria","factorLabel":"Ascendant falls under Mercury's monomoirion","ruleKey":"paulus_ascendant_monomoiria","ruleTitle":"Ascendant falls under Mercury's monomoirion","doctrineClaim":"Ascendant falls under Mercury's monomoirion","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Paulus","predicateKeys":["ascendant.monomoiria_ruler"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL"],"sourceKeys":["PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1299-1322"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1575-1590"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2684-2760"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2721-2770"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"68"}],"chartEvidence":["AscendantMonomoiriaRuler { ruler: Mercury, degree: 4 }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"ascendant.monomoiria_ruler","predicateLabel":"AscendantMonomoiriaRuler { ruler: Mercury, degree: 4 }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":1}],"calculationExplanation":"AscendantMonomoiriaRuler { ruler: Mercury, degree: 4 } => Ascendant falls under Mercury's monomoirion","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"The Ascendant is in degree 4 of Scorpio, so Paulus' degree-by-degree monomoiria assigns the ascending degree to Mercury.","interpretation":"The Ascendant is in degree 4 of Scorpio, so Paulus' degree-by-degree monomoiria assigns the ascending degree to Mercury.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-paulus-sect-light-monomoiria","factorKey":"rule:paulus-sect-light-monomoiria","factorLabel":"Sun falls under Sun's monomoirion","ruleKey":"paulus_sect_light_monomoiria","ruleTitle":"Sun falls under Sun's monomoirion","doctrineClaim":"Sun falls under Sun's monomoirion","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Paulus","predicateKeys":["body.monomoiria_ruler"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL"],"sourceKeys":["PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1299-1322"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1575-1590"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2684-2760"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2721-2770"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"68"}],"chartEvidence":["BodyMonomoiriaRuler { body: Sun, ruler: Sun, degree: 14 }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"body.monomoiria_ruler","predicateLabel":"BodyMonomoiriaRuler { body: Sun, ruler: Sun, degree: 14 }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":1}],"calculationExplanation":"BodyMonomoiriaRuler { body: Sun, ruler: Sun, degree: 14 } => Sun falls under Sun's monomoirion","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"The day sect light is in Sun degree 14 of Libra, so Paulus' degree-by-degree monomoiria assigns it to Sun.","interpretation":"The day sect light is in Sun degree 14 of Libra, so Paulus' degree-by-degree monomoiria assigns it to Sun.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-paulus-spirit-monomoiria","factorKey":"rule:paulus-spirit-monomoiria","factorLabel":"Lot of Spirit falls under Jupiter's monomoirion","ruleKey":"paulus_spirit_monomoiria","ruleTitle":"Lot of Spirit falls under Jupiter's monomoirion","doctrineClaim":"Lot of Spirit falls under Jupiter's monomoirion","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Paulus","predicateKeys":["lot.monomoiria_ruler"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL"],"sourceKeys":["PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1299-1322"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1575-1590"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2684-2760"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2721-2770"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"68"}],"chartEvidence":["LotMonomoiriaRuler { lot: Spirit, ruler: Jupiter, degree: 15 }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"lot.monomoiria_ruler","predicateLabel":"LotMonomoiriaRuler { lot: Spirit, ruler: Jupiter, degree: 15 }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":1}],"calculationExplanation":"LotMonomoiriaRuler { lot: Spirit, ruler: Jupiter, degree: 15 } => Lot of Spirit falls under Jupiter's monomoirion","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Lot of Spirit is in degree 15 of Pisces, so Paulus' degree-by-degree monomoiria assigns that occupied degree to Jupiter.","interpretation":"Lot of Spirit is in degree 15 of Pisces, so Paulus' degree-by-degree monomoiria assigns that occupied degree to Jupiter.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-paulus-necessity-monomoiria","factorKey":"rule:paulus-necessity-monomoiria","factorLabel":"Lot of Necessity falls under Venus's monomoirion","ruleKey":"paulus_necessity_monomoiria","ruleTitle":"Lot of Necessity falls under Venus's monomoirion","doctrineClaim":"Lot of Necessity falls under Venus's monomoirion","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Paulus","predicateKeys":["lot.monomoiria_ruler"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL"],"sourceKeys":["PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1299-1322"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1575-1590"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2684-2760"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2721-2770"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"68"}],"chartEvidence":["LotMonomoiriaRuler { lot: Necessity, ruler: Venus, degree: 12 }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"lot.monomoiria_ruler","predicateLabel":"LotMonomoiriaRuler { lot: Necessity, ruler: Venus, degree: 12 }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":1}],"calculationExplanation":"LotMonomoiriaRuler { lot: Necessity, ruler: Venus, degree: 12 } => Lot of Necessity falls under Venus's monomoirion","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Lot of Necessity is in degree 12 of Aquarius, so Paulus' degree-by-degree monomoiria assigns that occupied degree to Venus.","interpretation":"Lot of Necessity is in degree 12 of Aquarius, so Paulus' degree-by-degree monomoiria assigns that occupied degree to Venus.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-paulus-eros-monomoiria","factorKey":"rule:paulus-eros-monomoiria","factorLabel":"Lot of Eros falls under Sun's monomoirion","ruleKey":"paulus_eros_monomoiria","ruleTitle":"Lot of Eros falls under Sun's monomoirion","doctrineClaim":"Lot of Eros falls under Sun's monomoirion","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Paulus","predicateKeys":["lot.monomoiria_ruler"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL"],"sourceKeys":["PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1299-1322"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1575-1590"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2684-2760"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2721-2770"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"68"}],"chartEvidence":["LotMonomoiriaRuler { lot: Eros, ruler: Sun, degree: 26 }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"lot.monomoiria_ruler","predicateLabel":"LotMonomoiriaRuler { lot: Eros, ruler: Sun, degree: 26 }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":1}],"calculationExplanation":"LotMonomoiriaRuler { lot: Eros, ruler: Sun, degree: 26 } => Lot of Eros falls under Sun's monomoirion","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Lot of Eros is in degree 26 of Cancer, so Paulus' degree-by-degree monomoiria assigns that occupied degree to Sun.","interpretation":"Lot of Eros is in degree 26 of Cancer, so Paulus' degree-by-degree monomoiria assigns that occupied degree to Sun.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-applying","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-applying","factorLabel":"Planetary applying aspect","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_applying","ruleTitle":"Planetary applying aspect","doctrineClaim":"Planetary applying aspect","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["applying_or_separating","ecliptic_aspect","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","TRAD-GEORGE-AA2"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"123"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"42"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"85"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"95"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"}],"chartEvidence":["ApplyingOrSeparating { source: Sun, target: Saturn, phase: \"applying\" }","EclipticAspect { source: Sun, target: Saturn, aspect: Conjunction }","RelationSourceBody { body: Sun }","RelationTargetBody { body: Saturn }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Sun }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: Saturn }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"ecliptic_aspect","predicateLabel":"EclipticAspect { source: Sun, target: Saturn, aspect: Conjunction }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"applying_or_separating","predicateLabel":"ApplyingOrSeparating { source: Sun, target: Saturn, phase: \"applying\" }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":4}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Sun } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: Saturn } ∧ EclipticAspect { source: Sun, target: Saturn, aspect: Conjunction } ∧ ApplyingOrSeparating { source: Sun, target: Saturn, phase: \"applying\" } => Planetary applying aspect","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Sun is applying from an ecliptic conjunction with Saturn, based on the existing pair-relation aspect and speed data.","interpretation":"Sun is applying from an ecliptic conjunction with Saturn, based on the existing pair-relation aspect and speed data.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-applying","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-applying","factorLabel":"Planetary applying aspect","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_applying","ruleTitle":"Planetary applying aspect","doctrineClaim":"Planetary applying aspect","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["applying_or_separating","ecliptic_aspect","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","TRAD-GEORGE-AA2"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"123"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"42"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"85"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"95"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"}],"chartEvidence":["ApplyingOrSeparating { source: Sun, target: MeanNode, phase: \"applying\" }","EclipticAspect { source: Sun, target: MeanNode, aspect: Trine }","RelationSourceBody { body: Sun }","RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Sun }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"ecliptic_aspect","predicateLabel":"EclipticAspect { source: Sun, target: MeanNode, aspect: Trine }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"applying_or_separating","predicateLabel":"ApplyingOrSeparating { source: Sun, target: MeanNode, phase: \"applying\" }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":4}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Sun } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode } ∧ EclipticAspect { source: Sun, target: MeanNode, aspect: Trine } ∧ ApplyingOrSeparating { source: Sun, target: MeanNode, phase: \"applying\" } => Planetary applying aspect","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Sun is applying from an ecliptic trine with Mean Node, based on the existing pair-relation aspect and speed data.","interpretation":"Sun is applying from an ecliptic trine with Mean Node, based on the existing pair-relation aspect and speed data.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-applying","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-applying","factorLabel":"Planetary applying aspect","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_applying","ruleTitle":"Planetary applying aspect","doctrineClaim":"Planetary applying aspect","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["applying_or_separating","ecliptic_aspect","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","TRAD-GEORGE-AA2"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"123"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"42"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"85"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"95"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"}],"chartEvidence":["ApplyingOrSeparating { source: Mercury, target: Mars, phase: \"applying\" }","EclipticAspect { source: Mercury, target: Mars, aspect: Sextile }","RelationSourceBody { body: Mercury }","RelationTargetBody { body: Mars }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Mercury }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: Mars }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"ecliptic_aspect","predicateLabel":"EclipticAspect { source: Mercury, target: Mars, aspect: Sextile }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"applying_or_separating","predicateLabel":"ApplyingOrSeparating { source: Mercury, target: Mars, phase: \"applying\" }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":4}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Mercury } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: Mars } ∧ EclipticAspect { source: Mercury, target: Mars, aspect: Sextile } ∧ ApplyingOrSeparating { source: Mercury, target: Mars, phase: \"applying\" } => Planetary applying aspect","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Mercury is applying from an ecliptic sextile with Mars, based on the existing pair-relation aspect and speed data.","interpretation":"Mercury is applying from an ecliptic sextile with Mars, based on the existing pair-relation aspect and speed data.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-applying","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-applying","factorLabel":"Planetary applying aspect","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_applying","ruleTitle":"Planetary applying aspect","doctrineClaim":"Planetary applying aspect","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["applying_or_separating","ecliptic_aspect","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","TRAD-GEORGE-AA2"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"123"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"42"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"85"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"95"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"}],"chartEvidence":["ApplyingOrSeparating { source: Jupiter, target: MeanNode, phase: \"applying\" }","EclipticAspect { source: Jupiter, target: MeanNode, aspect: Square }","RelationSourceBody { body: Jupiter }","RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Jupiter }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"ecliptic_aspect","predicateLabel":"EclipticAspect { source: Jupiter, target: MeanNode, aspect: Square }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"applying_or_separating","predicateLabel":"ApplyingOrSeparating { source: Jupiter, target: MeanNode, phase: \"applying\" }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":4}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Jupiter } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode } ∧ EclipticAspect { source: Jupiter, target: MeanNode, aspect: Square } ∧ ApplyingOrSeparating { source: Jupiter, target: MeanNode, phase: \"applying\" } => Planetary applying aspect","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Jupiter is applying from an ecliptic square with Mean Node, based on the existing pair-relation aspect and speed data.","interpretation":"Jupiter is applying from an ecliptic square with Mean Node, based on the existing pair-relation aspect and speed data.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-applying","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-applying","factorLabel":"Planetary applying aspect","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_applying","ruleTitle":"Planetary applying aspect","doctrineClaim":"Planetary applying aspect","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["applying_or_separating","ecliptic_aspect","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","TRAD-GEORGE-AA2"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"123"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"42"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"85"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"95"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"}],"chartEvidence":["ApplyingOrSeparating { source: Saturn, target: MeanNode, phase: \"applying\" }","EclipticAspect { source: Saturn, target: MeanNode, aspect: Trine }","RelationSourceBody { body: Saturn }","RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Saturn }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"ecliptic_aspect","predicateLabel":"EclipticAspect { source: Saturn, target: MeanNode, aspect: Trine }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"applying_or_separating","predicateLabel":"ApplyingOrSeparating { source: Saturn, target: MeanNode, phase: \"applying\" }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":4}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Saturn } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode } ∧ EclipticAspect { source: Saturn, target: MeanNode, aspect: Trine } ∧ ApplyingOrSeparating { source: Saturn, target: MeanNode, phase: \"applying\" } => Planetary applying aspect","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Saturn is applying from an ecliptic trine with Mean Node, based on the existing pair-relation aspect and speed data.","interpretation":"Saturn is applying from an ecliptic trine with Mean Node, based on the existing pair-relation aspect and speed data.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-enclosure","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-enclosure","factorLabel":"Planetary enclosure","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_enclosure","ruleTitle":"Planetary enclosure","doctrineClaim":"Planetary enclosure","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["enclosure_kind","guard_left_body","guard_right_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-ABU-MASHAR-GREAT-INTRO","TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","TRAD-GEORGE-AA2"],"sourceKeys":["ABU_MASHAR_GREAT_INTRODUCTION_DYKES","ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"ABU_MASHAR_GREAT_INTRODUCTION_DYKES","citationKey":"TRAD-ABU-MASHAR-GREAT-INTRO","locator":"26"},{"sourceKey":"ABU_MASHAR_GREAT_INTRODUCTION_DYKES","citationKey":"TRAD-ABU-MASHAR-GREAT-INTRO","locator":"46"},{"sourceKey":"ABU_MASHAR_GREAT_INTRODUCTION_DYKES","citationKey":"TRAD-ABU-MASHAR-GREAT-INTRO","locator":"80"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"123"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"42"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"85"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"95"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"}],"chartEvidence":["EnclosureKind { enclosure_kind: \"by_ray\" }","GuardLeftBody { body: Moon }","GuardRightBody { body: Saturn }","RelationTargetBody { body: Sun }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"guard_left_body","predicateLabel":"GuardLeftBody { body: Moon }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"ABU_MASHAR_GREAT_INTRODUCTION_DYKES 26","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: Sun }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"ABU_MASHAR_GREAT_INTRODUCTION_DYKES 26","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"guard_right_body","predicateLabel":"GuardRightBody { body: Saturn }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"ABU_MASHAR_GREAT_INTRODUCTION_DYKES 26","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"enclosure_kind","predicateLabel":"EnclosureKind { enclosure_kind: \"by_ray\" }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"ABU_MASHAR_GREAT_INTRODUCTION_DYKES 26","sortOrder":4}],"calculationExplanation":"GuardLeftBody { body: Moon } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: Sun } ∧ GuardRightBody { body: Saturn } ∧ EnclosureKind { enclosure_kind: \"by_ray\" } => Planetary enclosure","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Sun is uninterrupted between its immediate guards Moon and Saturn, and both guards reach it by by ray, so this indicates enclosure as relation state rather than medieval besiegement.","interpretation":"Sun is uninterrupted between its immediate guards Moon and Saturn, and both guards reach it by by ray, so this indicates enclosure as relation state rather than medieval besiegement.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-enclosure","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-enclosure","factorLabel":"Planetary enclosure","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_enclosure","ruleTitle":"Planetary enclosure","doctrineClaim":"Planetary enclosure","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["enclosure_kind","guard_left_body","guard_right_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-ABU-MASHAR-GREAT-INTRO","TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","TRAD-GEORGE-AA2"],"sourceKeys":["ABU_MASHAR_GREAT_INTRODUCTION_DYKES","ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"ABU_MASHAR_GREAT_INTRODUCTION_DYKES","citationKey":"TRAD-ABU-MASHAR-GREAT-INTRO","locator":"26"},{"sourceKey":"ABU_MASHAR_GREAT_INTRODUCTION_DYKES","citationKey":"TRAD-ABU-MASHAR-GREAT-INTRO","locator":"46"},{"sourceKey":"ABU_MASHAR_GREAT_INTRODUCTION_DYKES","citationKey":"TRAD-ABU-MASHAR-GREAT-INTRO","locator":"80"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"123"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"42"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"85"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"95"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"}],"chartEvidence":["EnclosureKind { enclosure_kind: \"co_presence\" }","GuardLeftBody { body: Sun }","GuardRightBody { body: Mercury }","RelationTargetBody { body: Saturn }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"guard_left_body","predicateLabel":"GuardLeftBody { body: Sun }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"ABU_MASHAR_GREAT_INTRODUCTION_DYKES 26","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: Saturn }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"ABU_MASHAR_GREAT_INTRODUCTION_DYKES 26","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"guard_right_body","predicateLabel":"GuardRightBody { body: Mercury }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"ABU_MASHAR_GREAT_INTRODUCTION_DYKES 26","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"enclosure_kind","predicateLabel":"EnclosureKind { enclosure_kind: \"co_presence\" }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"ABU_MASHAR_GREAT_INTRODUCTION_DYKES 26","sortOrder":4}],"calculationExplanation":"GuardLeftBody { body: Sun } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: Saturn } ∧ GuardRightBody { body: Mercury } ∧ EnclosureKind { enclosure_kind: \"co_presence\" } => Planetary enclosure","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Saturn is uninterrupted between its immediate guards Sun and Mercury, and both guards reach it by co presence, so this indicates enclosure as relation state rather than medieval besiegement.","interpretation":"Saturn is uninterrupted between its immediate guards Sun and Mercury, and both guards reach it by co presence, so this indicates enclosure as relation state rather than medieval besiegement.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-overcoming","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-overcoming","factorLabel":"Planetary overcoming direction","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_overcoming","ruleTitle":"Planetary overcoming direction","doctrineClaim":"Planetary overcoming direction","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["classical_ray","overcoming_direction","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","TRAD-GEORGE-AA2"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"123"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"42"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"85"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"95"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"}],"chartEvidence":["ClassicalRay { source: Sun, target: Moon, ray: Trine }","OvercomingDirection { source: Sun, target: Moon, direction: \"overcome_by\" }","RelationSourceBody { body: Sun }","RelationTargetBody { body: Moon }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Sun }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: Moon }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"classical_ray","predicateLabel":"ClassicalRay { source: Sun, target: Moon, ray: Trine }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"overcoming_direction","predicateLabel":"OvercomingDirection { source: Sun, target: Moon, direction: \"overcome_by\" }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":4}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Sun } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: Moon } ∧ ClassicalRay { source: Sun, target: Moon, ray: Trine } ∧ OvercomingDirection { source: Sun, target: Moon, direction: \"overcome_by\" } => Planetary overcoming direction","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Sun and Moon witness one another by trine, with overcome by recorded as the conservative sign-order direction. This does not add dexter/sinister dominance or reception weighting.","interpretation":"Sun and Moon witness one another by trine, with overcome by recorded as the conservative sign-order direction. This does not add dexter/sinister dominance or reception weighting.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-overcoming","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-overcoming","factorLabel":"Planetary overcoming direction","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_overcoming","ruleTitle":"Planetary overcoming direction","doctrineClaim":"Planetary overcoming direction","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["classical_ray","overcoming_direction","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","TRAD-GEORGE-AA2"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"123"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"42"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"85"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"95"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"}],"chartEvidence":["ClassicalRay { source: Sun, target: Mars, ray: Sextile }","OvercomingDirection { source: Sun, target: Mars, direction: \"overcoming\" }","RelationSourceBody { body: Sun }","RelationTargetBody { body: Mars }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Sun }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: Mars }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"classical_ray","predicateLabel":"ClassicalRay { source: Sun, target: Mars, ray: Sextile }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"overcoming_direction","predicateLabel":"OvercomingDirection { source: Sun, target: Mars, direction: \"overcoming\" }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":4}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Sun } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: Mars } ∧ ClassicalRay { source: Sun, target: Mars, ray: Sextile } ∧ OvercomingDirection { source: Sun, target: Mars, direction: \"overcoming\" } => Planetary overcoming direction","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Sun and Mars witness one another by sextile, with overcoming recorded as the conservative sign-order direction. This does not add dexter/sinister dominance or reception weighting.","interpretation":"Sun and Mars witness one another by sextile, with overcoming recorded as the conservative sign-order direction. This does not add dexter/sinister dominance or reception weighting.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-overcoming","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-overcoming","factorLabel":"Planetary overcoming direction","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_overcoming","ruleTitle":"Planetary overcoming direction","doctrineClaim":"Planetary overcoming direction","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["classical_ray","overcoming_direction","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","TRAD-GEORGE-AA2"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"123"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"42"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"85"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"95"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"}],"chartEvidence":["ClassicalRay { source: Sun, target: MeanNode, ray: Trine }","OvercomingDirection { source: Sun, target: MeanNode, direction: \"overcoming\" }","RelationSourceBody { body: Sun }","RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Sun }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"classical_ray","predicateLabel":"ClassicalRay { source: Sun, target: MeanNode, ray: Trine }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"overcoming_direction","predicateLabel":"OvercomingDirection { source: Sun, target: MeanNode, direction: \"overcoming\" }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":4}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Sun } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode } ∧ ClassicalRay { source: Sun, target: MeanNode, ray: Trine } ∧ OvercomingDirection { source: Sun, target: MeanNode, direction: \"overcoming\" } => Planetary overcoming direction","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Sun and Mean Node witness one another by trine, with overcoming recorded as the conservative sign-order direction. This does not add dexter/sinister dominance or reception weighting.","interpretation":"Sun and Mean Node witness one another by trine, with overcoming recorded as the conservative sign-order direction. This does not add dexter/sinister dominance or reception weighting.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-overcoming","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-overcoming","factorLabel":"Planetary overcoming direction","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_overcoming","ruleTitle":"Planetary overcoming direction","doctrineClaim":"Planetary overcoming direction","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["classical_ray","overcoming_direction","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","TRAD-GEORGE-AA2"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"123"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"42"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"85"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"95"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"}],"chartEvidence":["ClassicalRay { source: Moon, target: Mercury, ray: Trine }","OvercomingDirection { source: Moon, target: Mercury, direction: \"overcoming\" }","RelationSourceBody { body: Moon }","RelationTargetBody { body: Mercury }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Moon }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: Mercury }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"classical_ray","predicateLabel":"ClassicalRay { source: Moon, target: Mercury, ray: Trine }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"overcoming_direction","predicateLabel":"OvercomingDirection { source: Moon, target: Mercury, direction: \"overcoming\" }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":4}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Moon } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: Mercury } ∧ ClassicalRay { source: Moon, target: Mercury, ray: Trine } ∧ OvercomingDirection { source: Moon, target: Mercury, direction: \"overcoming\" } => Planetary overcoming direction","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Moon and Mercury witness one another by trine, with overcoming recorded as the conservative sign-order direction. This does not add dexter/sinister dominance or reception weighting.","interpretation":"Moon and Mercury witness one another by trine, with overcoming recorded as the conservative sign-order direction. This does not add dexter/sinister dominance or reception weighting.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-overcoming","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-overcoming","factorLabel":"Planetary overcoming direction","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_overcoming","ruleTitle":"Planetary overcoming direction","doctrineClaim":"Planetary overcoming direction","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["classical_ray","overcoming_direction","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","TRAD-GEORGE-AA2"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"123"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"42"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"85"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"95"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"}],"chartEvidence":["ClassicalRay { source: Moon, target: Mars, ray: Opposition }","OvercomingDirection { source: Moon, target: Mars, direction: \"overcoming\" }","RelationSourceBody { body: Moon }","RelationTargetBody { body: Mars }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Moon }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: Mars }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"classical_ray","predicateLabel":"ClassicalRay { source: Moon, target: Mars, ray: Opposition }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"overcoming_direction","predicateLabel":"OvercomingDirection { source: Moon, target: Mars, direction: \"overcoming\" }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":4}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Moon } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: Mars } ∧ ClassicalRay { source: Moon, target: Mars, ray: Opposition } ∧ OvercomingDirection { source: Moon, target: Mars, direction: \"overcoming\" } => Planetary overcoming direction","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Moon and Mars witness one another by opposition, with overcoming recorded as the conservative sign-order direction. This does not add dexter/sinister dominance or reception weighting.","interpretation":"Moon and Mars witness one another by opposition, with overcoming recorded as the conservative sign-order direction. This does not add dexter/sinister dominance or reception weighting.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-overcoming","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-overcoming","factorLabel":"Planetary overcoming direction","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_overcoming","ruleTitle":"Planetary overcoming direction","doctrineClaim":"Planetary overcoming direction","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["classical_ray","overcoming_direction","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","TRAD-GEORGE-AA2"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"123"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"42"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"85"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"95"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"}],"chartEvidence":["ClassicalRay { source: Moon, target: Saturn, ray: Trine }","OvercomingDirection { source: Moon, target: Saturn, direction: \"overcoming\" }","RelationSourceBody { body: Moon }","RelationTargetBody { body: Saturn }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Moon }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: Saturn }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"classical_ray","predicateLabel":"ClassicalRay { source: Moon, target: Saturn, ray: Trine }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"overcoming_direction","predicateLabel":"OvercomingDirection { source: Moon, target: Saturn, direction: \"overcoming\" }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":4}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Moon } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: Saturn } ∧ ClassicalRay { source: Moon, target: Saturn, ray: Trine } ∧ OvercomingDirection { source: Moon, target: Saturn, direction: \"overcoming\" } => Planetary overcoming direction","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Moon and Saturn witness one another by trine, with overcoming recorded as the conservative sign-order direction. This does not add dexter/sinister dominance or reception weighting.","interpretation":"Moon and Saturn witness one another by trine, with overcoming recorded as the conservative sign-order direction. This does not add dexter/sinister dominance or reception weighting.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-overcoming","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-overcoming","factorLabel":"Planetary overcoming direction","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_overcoming","ruleTitle":"Planetary overcoming direction","doctrineClaim":"Planetary overcoming direction","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["classical_ray","overcoming_direction","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","TRAD-GEORGE-AA2"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"123"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"42"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"85"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"95"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"}],"chartEvidence":["ClassicalRay { source: Moon, target: MeanNode, ray: Trine }","OvercomingDirection { source: Moon, target: MeanNode, direction: \"overcoming\" }","RelationSourceBody { body: Moon }","RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Moon }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"classical_ray","predicateLabel":"ClassicalRay { source: Moon, target: MeanNode, ray: Trine }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"overcoming_direction","predicateLabel":"OvercomingDirection { source: Moon, target: MeanNode, direction: \"overcoming\" }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":4}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Moon } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode } ∧ ClassicalRay { source: Moon, target: MeanNode, ray: Trine } ∧ OvercomingDirection { source: Moon, target: MeanNode, direction: \"overcoming\" } => Planetary overcoming direction","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Moon and Mean Node witness one another by trine, with overcoming recorded as the conservative sign-order direction. This does not add dexter/sinister dominance or reception weighting.","interpretation":"Moon and Mean Node witness one another by trine, with overcoming recorded as the conservative sign-order direction. This does not add dexter/sinister dominance or reception weighting.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-overcoming","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-overcoming","factorLabel":"Planetary overcoming direction","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_overcoming","ruleTitle":"Planetary overcoming direction","doctrineClaim":"Planetary overcoming direction","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["classical_ray","overcoming_direction","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","TRAD-GEORGE-AA2"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"123"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"42"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"85"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"95"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"}],"chartEvidence":["ClassicalRay { source: Mercury, target: Mars, ray: Sextile }","OvercomingDirection { source: Mercury, target: Mars, direction: \"overcoming\" }","RelationSourceBody { body: Mercury }","RelationTargetBody { body: Mars }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Mercury }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: Mars }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"classical_ray","predicateLabel":"ClassicalRay { source: Mercury, target: Mars, ray: Sextile }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"overcoming_direction","predicateLabel":"OvercomingDirection { source: Mercury, target: Mars, direction: \"overcoming\" }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":4}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Mercury } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: Mars } ∧ ClassicalRay { source: Mercury, target: Mars, ray: Sextile } ∧ OvercomingDirection { source: Mercury, target: Mars, direction: \"overcoming\" } => Planetary overcoming direction","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Mercury and Mars witness one another by sextile, with overcoming recorded as the conservative sign-order direction. This does not add dexter/sinister dominance or reception weighting.","interpretation":"Mercury and Mars witness one another by sextile, with overcoming recorded as the conservative sign-order direction. This does not add dexter/sinister dominance or reception weighting.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-overcoming","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-overcoming","factorLabel":"Planetary overcoming direction","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_overcoming","ruleTitle":"Planetary overcoming direction","doctrineClaim":"Planetary overcoming direction","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["classical_ray","overcoming_direction","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","TRAD-GEORGE-AA2"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"123"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"42"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"85"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"95"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"}],"chartEvidence":["ClassicalRay { source: Mercury, target: MeanNode, ray: Trine }","OvercomingDirection { source: Mercury, target: MeanNode, direction: \"overcoming\" }","RelationSourceBody { body: Mercury }","RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Mercury }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"classical_ray","predicateLabel":"ClassicalRay { source: Mercury, target: MeanNode, ray: Trine }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"overcoming_direction","predicateLabel":"OvercomingDirection { source: Mercury, target: MeanNode, direction: \"overcoming\" }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":4}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Mercury } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode } ∧ ClassicalRay { source: Mercury, target: MeanNode, ray: Trine } ∧ OvercomingDirection { source: Mercury, target: MeanNode, direction: \"overcoming\" } => Planetary overcoming direction","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Mercury and Mean Node witness one another by trine, with overcoming recorded as the conservative sign-order direction. This does not add dexter/sinister dominance or reception weighting.","interpretation":"Mercury and Mean Node witness one another by trine, with overcoming recorded as the conservative sign-order direction. This does not add dexter/sinister dominance or reception weighting.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-overcoming","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-overcoming","factorLabel":"Planetary overcoming direction","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_overcoming","ruleTitle":"Planetary overcoming direction","doctrineClaim":"Planetary overcoming direction","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["classical_ray","overcoming_direction","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","TRAD-GEORGE-AA2"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"123"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"42"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"85"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"95"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"}],"chartEvidence":["ClassicalRay { source: Venus, target: Jupiter, ray: Opposition }","OvercomingDirection { source: Venus, target: Jupiter, direction: \"overcome_by\" }","RelationSourceBody { body: Venus }","RelationTargetBody { body: Jupiter }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Venus }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: Jupiter }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"classical_ray","predicateLabel":"ClassicalRay { source: Venus, target: Jupiter, ray: Opposition }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"overcoming_direction","predicateLabel":"OvercomingDirection { source: Venus, target: Jupiter, direction: \"overcome_by\" }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":4}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Venus } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: Jupiter } ∧ ClassicalRay { source: Venus, target: Jupiter, ray: Opposition } ∧ OvercomingDirection { source: Venus, target: Jupiter, direction: \"overcome_by\" } => Planetary overcoming direction","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Venus and Jupiter witness one another by opposition, with overcome by recorded as the conservative sign-order direction. This does not add dexter/sinister dominance or reception weighting.","interpretation":"Venus and Jupiter witness one another by opposition, with overcome by recorded as the conservative sign-order direction. This does not add dexter/sinister dominance or reception weighting.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-overcoming","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-overcoming","factorLabel":"Planetary overcoming direction","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_overcoming","ruleTitle":"Planetary overcoming direction","doctrineClaim":"Planetary overcoming direction","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["classical_ray","overcoming_direction","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","TRAD-GEORGE-AA2"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"123"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"42"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"85"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"95"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"}],"chartEvidence":["ClassicalRay { source: Venus, target: MeanNode, ray: Square }","OvercomingDirection { source: Venus, target: MeanNode, direction: \"overcoming\" }","RelationSourceBody { body: Venus }","RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Venus }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"classical_ray","predicateLabel":"ClassicalRay { source: Venus, target: MeanNode, ray: Square }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"overcoming_direction","predicateLabel":"OvercomingDirection { source: Venus, target: MeanNode, direction: \"overcoming\" }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":4}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Venus } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode } ∧ ClassicalRay { source: Venus, target: MeanNode, ray: Square } ∧ OvercomingDirection { source: Venus, target: MeanNode, direction: \"overcoming\" } => Planetary overcoming direction","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Venus and Mean Node witness one another by square, with overcoming recorded as the conservative sign-order direction. This does not add dexter/sinister dominance or reception weighting.","interpretation":"Venus and Mean Node witness one another by square, with overcoming recorded as the conservative sign-order direction. This does not add dexter/sinister dominance or reception weighting.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-overcoming","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-overcoming","factorLabel":"Planetary overcoming direction","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_overcoming","ruleTitle":"Planetary overcoming direction","doctrineClaim":"Planetary overcoming direction","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["classical_ray","overcoming_direction","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","TRAD-GEORGE-AA2"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"123"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"42"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"85"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"95"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"}],"chartEvidence":["ClassicalRay { source: Mars, target: Saturn, ray: Sextile }","OvercomingDirection { source: Mars, target: Saturn, direction: \"overcome_by\" }","RelationSourceBody { body: Mars }","RelationTargetBody { body: Saturn }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Mars }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: Saturn }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"classical_ray","predicateLabel":"ClassicalRay { source: Mars, target: Saturn, ray: Sextile }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"overcoming_direction","predicateLabel":"OvercomingDirection { source: Mars, target: Saturn, direction: \"overcome_by\" }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":4}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Mars } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: Saturn } ∧ ClassicalRay { source: Mars, target: Saturn, ray: Sextile } ∧ OvercomingDirection { source: Mars, target: Saturn, direction: \"overcome_by\" } => Planetary overcoming direction","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Mars and Saturn witness one another by sextile, with overcome by recorded as the conservative sign-order direction. This does not add dexter/sinister dominance or reception weighting.","interpretation":"Mars and Saturn witness one another by sextile, with overcome by recorded as the conservative sign-order direction. This does not add dexter/sinister dominance or reception weighting.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-overcoming","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-overcoming","factorLabel":"Planetary overcoming direction","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_overcoming","ruleTitle":"Planetary overcoming direction","doctrineClaim":"Planetary overcoming direction","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["classical_ray","overcoming_direction","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","TRAD-GEORGE-AA2"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"123"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"42"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"85"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"95"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"}],"chartEvidence":["ClassicalRay { source: Mars, target: MeanNode, ray: Sextile }","OvercomingDirection { source: Mars, target: MeanNode, direction: \"overcoming\" }","RelationSourceBody { body: Mars }","RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Mars }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"classical_ray","predicateLabel":"ClassicalRay { source: Mars, target: MeanNode, ray: Sextile }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"overcoming_direction","predicateLabel":"OvercomingDirection { source: Mars, target: MeanNode, direction: \"overcoming\" }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":4}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Mars } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode } ∧ ClassicalRay { source: Mars, target: MeanNode, ray: Sextile } ∧ OvercomingDirection { source: Mars, target: MeanNode, direction: \"overcoming\" } => Planetary overcoming direction","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Mars and Mean Node witness one another by sextile, with overcoming recorded as the conservative sign-order direction. This does not add dexter/sinister dominance or reception weighting.","interpretation":"Mars and Mean Node witness one another by sextile, with overcoming recorded as the conservative sign-order direction. This does not add dexter/sinister dominance or reception weighting.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-overcoming","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-overcoming","factorLabel":"Planetary overcoming direction","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_overcoming","ruleTitle":"Planetary overcoming direction","doctrineClaim":"Planetary overcoming direction","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["classical_ray","overcoming_direction","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","TRAD-GEORGE-AA2"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"123"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"42"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"85"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"95"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"}],"chartEvidence":["ClassicalRay { source: Jupiter, target: MeanNode, ray: Square }","OvercomingDirection { source: Jupiter, target: MeanNode, direction: \"overcoming\" }","RelationSourceBody { body: Jupiter }","RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Jupiter }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"classical_ray","predicateLabel":"ClassicalRay { source: Jupiter, target: MeanNode, ray: Square }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"overcoming_direction","predicateLabel":"OvercomingDirection { source: Jupiter, target: MeanNode, direction: \"overcoming\" }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":4}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Jupiter } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode } ∧ ClassicalRay { source: Jupiter, target: MeanNode, ray: Square } ∧ OvercomingDirection { source: Jupiter, target: MeanNode, direction: \"overcoming\" } => Planetary overcoming direction","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Jupiter and Mean Node witness one another by square, with overcoming recorded as the conservative sign-order direction. This does not add dexter/sinister dominance or reception weighting.","interpretation":"Jupiter and Mean Node witness one another by square, with overcoming recorded as the conservative sign-order direction. This does not add dexter/sinister dominance or reception weighting.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-overcoming","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-overcoming","factorLabel":"Planetary overcoming direction","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_overcoming","ruleTitle":"Planetary overcoming direction","doctrineClaim":"Planetary overcoming direction","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["classical_ray","overcoming_direction","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","TRAD-GEORGE-AA2"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"123"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"42"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"85"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"95"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"}],"chartEvidence":["ClassicalRay { source: Saturn, target: MeanNode, ray: Trine }","OvercomingDirection { source: Saturn, target: MeanNode, direction: \"overcoming\" }","RelationSourceBody { body: Saturn }","RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Saturn }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"classical_ray","predicateLabel":"ClassicalRay { source: Saturn, target: MeanNode, ray: Trine }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"overcoming_direction","predicateLabel":"OvercomingDirection { source: Saturn, target: MeanNode, direction: \"overcoming\" }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":4}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Saturn } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode } ∧ ClassicalRay { source: Saturn, target: MeanNode, ray: Trine } ∧ OvercomingDirection { source: Saturn, target: MeanNode, direction: \"overcoming\" } => Planetary overcoming direction","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Saturn and Mean Node witness one another by trine, with overcoming recorded as the conservative sign-order direction. This does not add dexter/sinister dominance or reception weighting.","interpretation":"Saturn and Mean Node witness one another by trine, with overcoming recorded as the conservative sign-order direction. This does not add dexter/sinister dominance or reception weighting.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-co-presence","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-co-presence","factorLabel":"Planetary co-presence","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_co_presence","ruleTitle":"Planetary co-presence","doctrineClaim":"Planetary co-presence","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["co_presence","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","TRAD-VALENS-ANTH"],"sourceKeys":["HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"123"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"42"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"85"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"95"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1299-1322"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1575-1590"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2684-2760"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2721-2770"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"68"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1631-1640"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1720-1728"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1724-1728"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1729-1736"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2360-2362"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2360-2363"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2361-2364"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2363-2365"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2365-2367"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2366-2368"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2368-2370"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2368-2371"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2370-2373"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2373-2376"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2375-2376"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2377-2381"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2378-2381"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2380-2383"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2382-2385"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2384-2386"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2386-2389"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2389-2390"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2389-2391"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2391-2392"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2392-2397"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2397-2399"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2399-2402"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2402-2404"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2403-2404"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2404-2405"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2405-2406"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2406"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2406-2407"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2407-2408"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2408-2409"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2409-2410"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2410-2411"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2441-2443"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2450-2451"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2454-2457"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2463-2465"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2465-2466"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2465-2468"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2472-2473"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2473-2474"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2479-2480"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2480-2481"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2481-2482"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2527"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2548"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2548; 4746-4756; 6326-6336"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2542-2544"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"4750-4753; 6331"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"68"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8024-8048"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8037-8041"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8098-8103"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"9388-9404"}],"chartEvidence":["CoPresence { source: Sun, target: Mercury }","RelationSourceBody { body: Sun }","RelationTargetBody { body: Mercury }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Sun }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: Mercury }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"co_presence","predicateLabel":"CoPresence { source: Sun, target: Mercury }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":3}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Sun } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: Mercury } ∧ CoPresence { source: Sun, target: Mercury } => Planetary co-presence","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Sun and Mercury occupy the same sign, so this indicates co-presence apart from ray or exact-aspect testimony.","interpretation":"Sun and Mercury occupy the same sign, so this indicates co-presence apart from ray or exact-aspect testimony.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-co-presence","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-co-presence","factorLabel":"Planetary co-presence","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_co_presence","ruleTitle":"Planetary co-presence","doctrineClaim":"Planetary co-presence","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["co_presence","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","TRAD-VALENS-ANTH"],"sourceKeys":["HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"123"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"42"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"85"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"95"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1299-1322"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1575-1590"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2684-2760"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2721-2770"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"68"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1631-1640"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1720-1728"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1724-1728"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1729-1736"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2360-2362"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2360-2363"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2361-2364"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2363-2365"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2365-2367"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2366-2368"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2368-2370"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2368-2371"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2370-2373"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2373-2376"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2375-2376"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2377-2381"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2378-2381"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2380-2383"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2382-2385"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2384-2386"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2386-2389"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2389-2390"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2389-2391"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2391-2392"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2392-2397"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2397-2399"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2399-2402"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2402-2404"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2403-2404"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2404-2405"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2405-2406"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2406"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2406-2407"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2407-2408"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2408-2409"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2409-2410"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2410-2411"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2441-2443"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2450-2451"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2454-2457"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2463-2465"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2465-2466"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2465-2468"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2472-2473"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2473-2474"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2479-2480"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2480-2481"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2481-2482"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2527"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2548"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2548; 4746-4756; 6326-6336"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2542-2544"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"4750-4753; 6331"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"68"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8024-8048"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8037-8041"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8098-8103"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"9388-9404"}],"chartEvidence":["CoPresence { source: Sun, target: Saturn }","RelationSourceBody { body: Sun }","RelationTargetBody { body: Saturn }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Sun }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: Saturn }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"co_presence","predicateLabel":"CoPresence { source: Sun, target: Saturn }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":3}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Sun } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: Saturn } ∧ CoPresence { source: Sun, target: Saturn } => Planetary co-presence","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Sun and Saturn occupy the same sign, so this indicates co-presence apart from ray or exact-aspect testimony.","interpretation":"Sun and Saturn occupy the same sign, so this indicates co-presence apart from ray or exact-aspect testimony.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-co-presence","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-co-presence","factorLabel":"Planetary co-presence","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_co_presence","ruleTitle":"Planetary co-presence","doctrineClaim":"Planetary co-presence","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["co_presence","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","TRAD-VALENS-ANTH"],"sourceKeys":["HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"123"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"42"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"85"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"95"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1299-1322"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1575-1590"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2684-2760"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2721-2770"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"68"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1631-1640"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1720-1728"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1724-1728"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1729-1736"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2360-2362"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2360-2363"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2361-2364"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2363-2365"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2365-2367"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2366-2368"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2368-2370"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2368-2371"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2370-2373"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2373-2376"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2375-2376"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2377-2381"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2378-2381"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2380-2383"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2382-2385"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2384-2386"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2386-2389"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2389-2390"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2389-2391"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2391-2392"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2392-2397"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2397-2399"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2399-2402"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2402-2404"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2403-2404"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2404-2405"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2405-2406"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2406"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2406-2407"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2407-2408"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2408-2409"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2409-2410"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2410-2411"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2441-2443"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2450-2451"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2454-2457"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2463-2465"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2465-2466"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2465-2468"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2472-2473"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2473-2474"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2479-2480"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2480-2481"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2481-2482"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2527"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2548"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2548; 4746-4756; 6326-6336"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2542-2544"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"4750-4753; 6331"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"68"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8024-8048"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8037-8041"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8098-8103"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"9388-9404"}],"chartEvidence":["CoPresence { source: Mercury, target: Saturn }","RelationSourceBody { body: Mercury }","RelationTargetBody { body: Saturn }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Mercury }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: Saturn }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"co_presence","predicateLabel":"CoPresence { source: Mercury, target: Saturn }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":3}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Mercury } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: Saturn } ∧ CoPresence { source: Mercury, target: Saturn } => Planetary co-presence","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Mercury and Saturn occupy the same sign, so this indicates co-presence apart from ray or exact-aspect testimony.","interpretation":"Mercury and Saturn occupy the same sign, so this indicates co-presence apart from ray or exact-aspect testimony.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","factorLabel":"Planetary classical witnessing","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_classical_witnessing","ruleTitle":"Planetary classical witnessing","doctrineClaim":"Planetary classical witnessing","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["classical_ray","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"123"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"42"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"85"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"95"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"49"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"57"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"79"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"81"}],"chartEvidence":["ClassicalRay { source: Sun, target: Moon, ray: Trine }","RelationSourceBody { body: Sun }","RelationTargetBody { body: Moon }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Sun }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: Moon }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"classical_ray","predicateLabel":"ClassicalRay { source: Sun, target: Moon, ray: Trine }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":3}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Sun } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: Moon } ∧ ClassicalRay { source: Sun, target: Moon, ray: Trine } => Planetary classical witnessing","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Sun and Moon witness one another by trine, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","interpretation":"Sun and Moon witness one another by trine, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","factorLabel":"Planetary classical witnessing","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_classical_witnessing","ruleTitle":"Planetary classical witnessing","doctrineClaim":"Planetary classical witnessing","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["classical_ray","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"123"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"42"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"85"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"95"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"49"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"57"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"79"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"81"}],"chartEvidence":["ClassicalRay { source: Sun, target: Mercury, ray: Conjunction }","RelationSourceBody { body: Sun }","RelationTargetBody { body: Mercury }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Sun }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: Mercury }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"classical_ray","predicateLabel":"ClassicalRay { source: Sun, target: Mercury, ray: Conjunction }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":3}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Sun } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: Mercury } ∧ ClassicalRay { source: Sun, target: Mercury, ray: Conjunction } => Planetary classical witnessing","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Sun and Mercury witness one another by conjunction, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","interpretation":"Sun and Mercury witness one another by conjunction, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","factorLabel":"Planetary classical witnessing","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_classical_witnessing","ruleTitle":"Planetary classical witnessing","doctrineClaim":"Planetary classical witnessing","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["classical_ray","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"123"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"42"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"85"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"95"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"49"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"57"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"79"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"81"}],"chartEvidence":["ClassicalRay { source: Sun, target: Mars, ray: Sextile }","RelationSourceBody { body: Sun }","RelationTargetBody { body: Mars }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Sun }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: Mars }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"classical_ray","predicateLabel":"ClassicalRay { source: Sun, target: Mars, ray: Sextile }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":3}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Sun } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: Mars } ∧ ClassicalRay { source: Sun, target: Mars, ray: Sextile } => Planetary classical witnessing","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Sun and Mars witness one another by sextile, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","interpretation":"Sun and Mars witness one another by sextile, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","factorLabel":"Planetary classical witnessing","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_classical_witnessing","ruleTitle":"Planetary classical witnessing","doctrineClaim":"Planetary classical witnessing","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["classical_ray","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"123"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"42"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"85"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"95"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"49"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"57"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"79"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"81"}],"chartEvidence":["ClassicalRay { source: Sun, target: Saturn, ray: Conjunction }","RelationSourceBody { body: Sun }","RelationTargetBody { body: Saturn }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Sun }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: Saturn }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"classical_ray","predicateLabel":"ClassicalRay { source: Sun, target: Saturn, ray: Conjunction }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":3}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Sun } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: Saturn } ∧ ClassicalRay { source: Sun, target: Saturn, ray: Conjunction } => Planetary classical witnessing","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Sun and Saturn witness one another by conjunction, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","interpretation":"Sun and Saturn witness one another by conjunction, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","factorLabel":"Planetary classical witnessing","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_classical_witnessing","ruleTitle":"Planetary classical witnessing","doctrineClaim":"Planetary classical witnessing","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["classical_ray","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"123"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"42"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"85"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"95"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"49"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"57"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"79"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"81"}],"chartEvidence":["ClassicalRay { source: Sun, target: MeanNode, ray: Trine }","RelationSourceBody { body: Sun }","RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Sun }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"classical_ray","predicateLabel":"ClassicalRay { source: Sun, target: MeanNode, ray: Trine }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":3}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Sun } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode } ∧ ClassicalRay { source: Sun, target: MeanNode, ray: Trine } => Planetary classical witnessing","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Sun and Mean Node witness one another by trine, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","interpretation":"Sun and Mean Node witness one another by trine, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","factorLabel":"Planetary classical witnessing","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_classical_witnessing","ruleTitle":"Planetary classical witnessing","doctrineClaim":"Planetary classical witnessing","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["classical_ray","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"123"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"42"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"85"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"95"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"49"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"57"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"79"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"81"}],"chartEvidence":["ClassicalRay { source: Moon, target: Mercury, ray: Trine }","RelationSourceBody { body: Moon }","RelationTargetBody { body: Mercury }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Moon }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: Mercury }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"classical_ray","predicateLabel":"ClassicalRay { source: Moon, target: Mercury, ray: Trine }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":3}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Moon } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: Mercury } ∧ ClassicalRay { source: Moon, target: Mercury, ray: Trine } => Planetary classical witnessing","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Moon and Mercury witness one another by trine, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","interpretation":"Moon and Mercury witness one another by trine, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","factorLabel":"Planetary classical witnessing","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_classical_witnessing","ruleTitle":"Planetary classical witnessing","doctrineClaim":"Planetary classical witnessing","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["classical_ray","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"123"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"42"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"85"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"95"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"49"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"57"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"79"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"81"}],"chartEvidence":["ClassicalRay { source: Moon, target: Mars, ray: Opposition }","RelationSourceBody { body: Moon }","RelationTargetBody { body: Mars }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Moon }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: Mars }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"classical_ray","predicateLabel":"ClassicalRay { source: Moon, target: Mars, ray: Opposition }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":3}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Moon } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: Mars } ∧ ClassicalRay { source: Moon, target: Mars, ray: Opposition } => Planetary classical witnessing","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Moon and Mars witness one another by opposition, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","interpretation":"Moon and Mars witness one another by opposition, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","factorLabel":"Planetary classical witnessing","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_classical_witnessing","ruleTitle":"Planetary classical witnessing","doctrineClaim":"Planetary classical witnessing","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["classical_ray","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"123"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"42"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"85"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"95"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"49"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"57"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"79"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"81"}],"chartEvidence":["ClassicalRay { source: Moon, target: Saturn, ray: Trine }","RelationSourceBody { body: Moon }","RelationTargetBody { body: Saturn }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Moon }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: Saturn }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"classical_ray","predicateLabel":"ClassicalRay { source: Moon, target: Saturn, ray: Trine }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":3}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Moon } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: Saturn } ∧ ClassicalRay { source: Moon, target: Saturn, ray: Trine } => Planetary classical witnessing","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Moon and Saturn witness one another by trine, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","interpretation":"Moon and Saturn witness one another by trine, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","factorLabel":"Planetary classical witnessing","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_classical_witnessing","ruleTitle":"Planetary classical witnessing","doctrineClaim":"Planetary classical witnessing","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["classical_ray","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"123"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"42"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"85"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"95"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"49"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"57"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"79"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"81"}],"chartEvidence":["ClassicalRay { source: Moon, target: MeanNode, ray: Trine }","RelationSourceBody { body: Moon }","RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Moon }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"classical_ray","predicateLabel":"ClassicalRay { source: Moon, target: MeanNode, ray: Trine }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":3}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Moon } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode } ∧ ClassicalRay { source: Moon, target: MeanNode, ray: Trine } => Planetary classical witnessing","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Moon and Mean Node witness one another by trine, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","interpretation":"Moon and Mean Node witness one another by trine, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","factorLabel":"Planetary classical witnessing","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_classical_witnessing","ruleTitle":"Planetary classical witnessing","doctrineClaim":"Planetary classical witnessing","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["classical_ray","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"123"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"42"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"85"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"95"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"49"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"57"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"79"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"81"}],"chartEvidence":["ClassicalRay { source: Mercury, target: Mars, ray: Sextile }","RelationSourceBody { body: Mercury }","RelationTargetBody { body: Mars }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Mercury }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: Mars }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"classical_ray","predicateLabel":"ClassicalRay { source: Mercury, target: Mars, ray: Sextile }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":3}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Mercury } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: Mars } ∧ ClassicalRay { source: Mercury, target: Mars, ray: Sextile } => Planetary classical witnessing","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Mercury and Mars witness one another by sextile, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","interpretation":"Mercury and Mars witness one another by sextile, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","factorLabel":"Planetary classical witnessing","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_classical_witnessing","ruleTitle":"Planetary classical witnessing","doctrineClaim":"Planetary classical witnessing","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["classical_ray","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"123"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"42"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"85"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"95"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"49"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"57"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"79"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"81"}],"chartEvidence":["ClassicalRay { source: Mercury, target: Saturn, ray: Conjunction }","RelationSourceBody { body: Mercury }","RelationTargetBody { body: Saturn }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Mercury }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: Saturn }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"classical_ray","predicateLabel":"ClassicalRay { source: Mercury, target: Saturn, ray: Conjunction }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":3}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Mercury } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: Saturn } ∧ ClassicalRay { source: Mercury, target: Saturn, ray: Conjunction } => Planetary classical witnessing","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Mercury and Saturn witness one another by conjunction, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","interpretation":"Mercury and Saturn witness one another by conjunction, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","factorLabel":"Planetary classical witnessing","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_classical_witnessing","ruleTitle":"Planetary classical witnessing","doctrineClaim":"Planetary classical witnessing","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["classical_ray","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"123"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"42"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"85"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"95"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"49"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"57"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"79"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"81"}],"chartEvidence":["ClassicalRay { source: Mercury, target: MeanNode, ray: Trine }","RelationSourceBody { body: Mercury }","RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Mercury }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"classical_ray","predicateLabel":"ClassicalRay { source: Mercury, target: MeanNode, ray: Trine }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":3}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Mercury } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode } ∧ ClassicalRay { source: Mercury, target: MeanNode, ray: Trine } => Planetary classical witnessing","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Mercury and Mean Node witness one another by trine, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","interpretation":"Mercury and Mean Node witness one another by trine, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","factorLabel":"Planetary classical witnessing","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_classical_witnessing","ruleTitle":"Planetary classical witnessing","doctrineClaim":"Planetary classical witnessing","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["classical_ray","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"123"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"42"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"85"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"95"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"49"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"57"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"79"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"81"}],"chartEvidence":["ClassicalRay { source: Venus, target: Jupiter, ray: Opposition }","RelationSourceBody { body: Venus }","RelationTargetBody { body: Jupiter }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Venus }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: Jupiter }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"classical_ray","predicateLabel":"ClassicalRay { source: Venus, target: Jupiter, ray: Opposition }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":3}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Venus } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: Jupiter } ∧ ClassicalRay { source: Venus, target: Jupiter, ray: Opposition } => Planetary classical witnessing","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Venus and Jupiter witness one another by opposition, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","interpretation":"Venus and Jupiter witness one another by opposition, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","factorLabel":"Planetary classical witnessing","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_classical_witnessing","ruleTitle":"Planetary classical witnessing","doctrineClaim":"Planetary classical witnessing","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["classical_ray","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"123"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"42"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"85"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"95"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"49"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"57"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"79"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"81"}],"chartEvidence":["ClassicalRay { source: Venus, target: MeanNode, ray: Square }","RelationSourceBody { body: Venus }","RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Venus }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"classical_ray","predicateLabel":"ClassicalRay { source: Venus, target: MeanNode, ray: Square }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":3}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Venus } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode } ∧ ClassicalRay { source: Venus, target: MeanNode, ray: Square } => Planetary classical witnessing","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Venus and Mean Node witness one another by square, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","interpretation":"Venus and Mean Node witness one another by square, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","factorLabel":"Planetary classical witnessing","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_classical_witnessing","ruleTitle":"Planetary classical witnessing","doctrineClaim":"Planetary classical witnessing","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["classical_ray","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"123"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"42"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"85"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"95"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"49"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"57"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"79"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"81"}],"chartEvidence":["ClassicalRay { source: Mars, target: Saturn, ray: Sextile }","RelationSourceBody { body: Mars }","RelationTargetBody { body: Saturn }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Mars }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: Saturn }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"classical_ray","predicateLabel":"ClassicalRay { source: Mars, target: Saturn, ray: Sextile }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":3}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Mars } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: Saturn } ∧ ClassicalRay { source: Mars, target: Saturn, ray: Sextile } => Planetary classical witnessing","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Mars and Saturn witness one another by sextile, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","interpretation":"Mars and Saturn witness one another by sextile, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","factorLabel":"Planetary classical witnessing","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_classical_witnessing","ruleTitle":"Planetary classical witnessing","doctrineClaim":"Planetary classical witnessing","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["classical_ray","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"123"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"42"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"85"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"95"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"49"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"57"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"79"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"81"}],"chartEvidence":["ClassicalRay { source: Mars, target: MeanNode, ray: Sextile }","RelationSourceBody { body: Mars }","RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Mars }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"classical_ray","predicateLabel":"ClassicalRay { source: Mars, target: MeanNode, ray: Sextile }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":3}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Mars } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode } ∧ ClassicalRay { source: Mars, target: MeanNode, ray: Sextile } => Planetary classical witnessing","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Mars and Mean Node witness one another by sextile, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","interpretation":"Mars and Mean Node witness one another by sextile, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","factorLabel":"Planetary classical witnessing","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_classical_witnessing","ruleTitle":"Planetary classical witnessing","doctrineClaim":"Planetary classical witnessing","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["classical_ray","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"123"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"42"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"85"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"95"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"49"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"57"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"79"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"81"}],"chartEvidence":["ClassicalRay { source: Jupiter, target: MeanNode, ray: Square }","RelationSourceBody { body: Jupiter }","RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Jupiter }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"classical_ray","predicateLabel":"ClassicalRay { source: Jupiter, target: MeanNode, ray: Square }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":3}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Jupiter } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode } ∧ ClassicalRay { source: Jupiter, target: MeanNode, ray: Square } => Planetary classical witnessing","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Jupiter and Mean Node witness one another by square, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","interpretation":"Jupiter and Mean Node witness one another by square, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","factorLabel":"Planetary classical witnessing","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_classical_witnessing","ruleTitle":"Planetary classical witnessing","doctrineClaim":"Planetary classical witnessing","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["classical_ray","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"123"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"42"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"85"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"95"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"49"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"57"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"79"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"81"}],"chartEvidence":["ClassicalRay { source: Saturn, target: MeanNode, ray: Trine }","RelationSourceBody { body: Saturn }","RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Saturn }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"classical_ray","predicateLabel":"ClassicalRay { source: Saturn, target: MeanNode, ray: Trine }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":3}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Saturn } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode } ∧ ClassicalRay { source: Saturn, target: MeanNode, ray: Trine } => Planetary classical witnessing","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Saturn and Mean Node witness one another by trine, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","interpretation":"Saturn and Mean Node witness one another by trine, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-aversion","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-aversion","factorLabel":"Planetary aversion","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_aversion","ruleTitle":"Planetary aversion","doctrineClaim":"Planetary aversion","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["aversion","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","TRAD-VALENS-ANTH"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"49"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"57"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"79"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"81"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1631-1640"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1720-1728"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1724-1728"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1729-1736"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2360-2362"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2360-2363"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2361-2364"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2363-2365"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2365-2367"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2366-2368"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2368-2370"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2368-2371"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2370-2373"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2373-2376"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2375-2376"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2377-2381"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2378-2381"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2380-2383"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2382-2385"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2384-2386"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2386-2389"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2389-2390"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2389-2391"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2391-2392"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2392-2397"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2397-2399"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2399-2402"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2402-2404"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2403-2404"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2404-2405"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2405-2406"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2406"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2406-2407"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2407-2408"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2408-2409"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2409-2410"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2410-2411"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2441-2443"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2450-2451"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2454-2457"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2463-2465"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2465-2466"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2465-2468"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2472-2473"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2473-2474"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2479-2480"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2480-2481"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2481-2482"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2527"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2548"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2548; 4746-4756; 6326-6336"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2542-2544"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"4750-4753; 6331"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"68"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8024-8048"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8037-8041"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8098-8103"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"9388-9404"}],"chartEvidence":["Aversion { source: Sun, target: Venus }","RelationSourceBody { body: Sun }","RelationTargetBody { body: Venus }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Sun }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: Venus }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"aversion","predicateLabel":"Aversion { source: Sun, target: Venus }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE 105","sortOrder":3}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Sun } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: Venus } ∧ Aversion { source: Sun, target: Venus } => Planetary aversion","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Sun and Venus do not share a classical whole-sign ray, so this indicates aversion without adding reception or condition weighting.","interpretation":"Sun and Venus do not share a classical whole-sign ray, so this indicates aversion without adding reception or condition weighting.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-aversion","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-aversion","factorLabel":"Planetary aversion","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_aversion","ruleTitle":"Planetary aversion","doctrineClaim":"Planetary aversion","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["aversion","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","TRAD-VALENS-ANTH"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"49"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"57"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"79"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"81"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1631-1640"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1720-1728"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1724-1728"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1729-1736"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2360-2362"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2360-2363"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2361-2364"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2363-2365"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2365-2367"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2366-2368"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2368-2370"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2368-2371"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2370-2373"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2373-2376"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2375-2376"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2377-2381"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2378-2381"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2380-2383"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2382-2385"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2384-2386"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2386-2389"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2389-2390"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2389-2391"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2391-2392"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2392-2397"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2397-2399"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2399-2402"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2402-2404"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2403-2404"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2404-2405"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2405-2406"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2406"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2406-2407"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2407-2408"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2408-2409"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2409-2410"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2410-2411"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2441-2443"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2450-2451"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2454-2457"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2463-2465"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2465-2466"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2465-2468"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2472-2473"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2473-2474"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2479-2480"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2480-2481"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2481-2482"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2527"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2548"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2548; 4746-4756; 6326-6336"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2542-2544"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"4750-4753; 6331"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"68"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8024-8048"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8037-8041"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8098-8103"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"9388-9404"}],"chartEvidence":["Aversion { source: Sun, target: Jupiter }","RelationSourceBody { body: Sun }","RelationTargetBody { body: Jupiter }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Sun }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: Jupiter }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"aversion","predicateLabel":"Aversion { source: Sun, target: Jupiter }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE 105","sortOrder":3}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Sun } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: Jupiter } ∧ Aversion { source: Sun, target: Jupiter } => Planetary aversion","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Sun and Jupiter do not share a classical whole-sign ray, so this indicates aversion without adding reception or condition weighting.","interpretation":"Sun and Jupiter do not share a classical whole-sign ray, so this indicates aversion without adding reception or condition weighting.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-aversion","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-aversion","factorLabel":"Planetary aversion","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_aversion","ruleTitle":"Planetary aversion","doctrineClaim":"Planetary aversion","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["aversion","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","TRAD-VALENS-ANTH"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"49"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"57"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"79"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"81"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1631-1640"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1720-1728"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1724-1728"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1729-1736"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2360-2362"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2360-2363"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2361-2364"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2363-2365"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2365-2367"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2366-2368"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2368-2370"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2368-2371"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2370-2373"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2373-2376"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2375-2376"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2377-2381"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2378-2381"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2380-2383"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2382-2385"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2384-2386"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2386-2389"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2389-2390"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2389-2391"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2391-2392"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2392-2397"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2397-2399"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2399-2402"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2402-2404"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2403-2404"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2404-2405"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2405-2406"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2406"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2406-2407"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2407-2408"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2408-2409"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2409-2410"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2410-2411"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2441-2443"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2450-2451"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2454-2457"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2463-2465"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2465-2466"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2465-2468"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2472-2473"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2473-2474"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2479-2480"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2480-2481"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2481-2482"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2527"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2548"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2548; 4746-4756; 6326-6336"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2542-2544"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"4750-4753; 6331"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"68"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8024-8048"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8037-8041"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8098-8103"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"9388-9404"}],"chartEvidence":["Aversion { source: Moon, target: Venus }","RelationSourceBody { body: Moon }","RelationTargetBody { body: Venus }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Moon }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: Venus }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"aversion","predicateLabel":"Aversion { source: Moon, target: Venus }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE 105","sortOrder":3}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Moon } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: Venus } ∧ Aversion { source: Moon, target: Venus } => Planetary aversion","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Moon and Venus do not share a classical whole-sign ray, so this indicates aversion without adding reception or condition weighting.","interpretation":"Moon and Venus do not share a classical whole-sign ray, so this indicates aversion without adding reception or condition weighting.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-aversion","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-aversion","factorLabel":"Planetary aversion","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_aversion","ruleTitle":"Planetary aversion","doctrineClaim":"Planetary aversion","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["aversion","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","TRAD-VALENS-ANTH"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"49"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"57"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"79"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"81"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1631-1640"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1720-1728"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1724-1728"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1729-1736"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2360-2362"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2360-2363"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2361-2364"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2363-2365"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2365-2367"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2366-2368"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2368-2370"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2368-2371"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2370-2373"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2373-2376"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2375-2376"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2377-2381"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2378-2381"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2380-2383"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2382-2385"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2384-2386"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2386-2389"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2389-2390"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2389-2391"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2391-2392"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2392-2397"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2397-2399"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2399-2402"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2402-2404"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2403-2404"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2404-2405"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2405-2406"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2406"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2406-2407"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2407-2408"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2408-2409"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2409-2410"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2410-2411"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2441-2443"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2450-2451"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2454-2457"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2463-2465"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2465-2466"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2465-2468"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2472-2473"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2473-2474"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2479-2480"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2480-2481"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2481-2482"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2527"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2548"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2548; 4746-4756; 6326-6336"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2542-2544"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"4750-4753; 6331"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"68"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8024-8048"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8037-8041"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8098-8103"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"9388-9404"}],"chartEvidence":["Aversion { source: Moon, target: Jupiter }","RelationSourceBody { body: Moon }","RelationTargetBody { body: Jupiter }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Moon }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: Jupiter }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"aversion","predicateLabel":"Aversion { source: Moon, target: Jupiter }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE 105","sortOrder":3}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Moon } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: Jupiter } ∧ Aversion { source: Moon, target: Jupiter } => Planetary aversion","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Moon and Jupiter do not share a classical whole-sign ray, so this indicates aversion without adding reception or condition weighting.","interpretation":"Moon and Jupiter do not share a classical whole-sign ray, so this indicates aversion without adding reception or condition weighting.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-aversion","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-aversion","factorLabel":"Planetary aversion","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_aversion","ruleTitle":"Planetary aversion","doctrineClaim":"Planetary aversion","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["aversion","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","TRAD-VALENS-ANTH"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"49"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"57"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"79"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"81"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1631-1640"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1720-1728"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1724-1728"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1729-1736"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2360-2362"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2360-2363"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2361-2364"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2363-2365"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2365-2367"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2366-2368"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2368-2370"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2368-2371"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2370-2373"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2373-2376"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2375-2376"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2377-2381"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2378-2381"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2380-2383"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2382-2385"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2384-2386"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2386-2389"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2389-2390"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2389-2391"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2391-2392"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2392-2397"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2397-2399"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2399-2402"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2402-2404"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2403-2404"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2404-2405"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2405-2406"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2406"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2406-2407"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2407-2408"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2408-2409"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2409-2410"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2410-2411"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2441-2443"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2450-2451"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2454-2457"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2463-2465"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2465-2466"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2465-2468"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2472-2473"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2473-2474"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2479-2480"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2480-2481"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2481-2482"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2527"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2548"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2548; 4746-4756; 6326-6336"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2542-2544"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"4750-4753; 6331"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"68"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8024-8048"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8037-8041"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8098-8103"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"9388-9404"}],"chartEvidence":["Aversion { source: Mercury, target: Venus }","RelationSourceBody { body: Mercury }","RelationTargetBody { body: Venus }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Mercury }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: Venus }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"aversion","predicateLabel":"Aversion { source: Mercury, target: Venus }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE 105","sortOrder":3}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Mercury } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: Venus } ∧ Aversion { source: Mercury, target: Venus } => Planetary aversion","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Mercury and Venus do not share a classical whole-sign ray, so this indicates aversion without adding reception or condition weighting.","interpretation":"Mercury and Venus do not share a classical whole-sign ray, so this indicates aversion without adding reception or condition weighting.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-aversion","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-aversion","factorLabel":"Planetary aversion","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_aversion","ruleTitle":"Planetary aversion","doctrineClaim":"Planetary aversion","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["aversion","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","TRAD-VALENS-ANTH"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"49"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"57"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"79"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"81"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1631-1640"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1720-1728"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1724-1728"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1729-1736"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2360-2362"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2360-2363"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2361-2364"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2363-2365"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2365-2367"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2366-2368"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2368-2370"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2368-2371"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2370-2373"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2373-2376"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2375-2376"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2377-2381"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2378-2381"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2380-2383"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2382-2385"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2384-2386"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2386-2389"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2389-2390"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2389-2391"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2391-2392"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2392-2397"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2397-2399"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2399-2402"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2402-2404"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2403-2404"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2404-2405"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2405-2406"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2406"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2406-2407"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2407-2408"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2408-2409"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2409-2410"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2410-2411"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2441-2443"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2450-2451"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2454-2457"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2463-2465"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2465-2466"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2465-2468"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2472-2473"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2473-2474"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2479-2480"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2480-2481"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2481-2482"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2527"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2548"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2548; 4746-4756; 6326-6336"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2542-2544"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"4750-4753; 6331"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"68"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8024-8048"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8037-8041"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8098-8103"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"9388-9404"}],"chartEvidence":["Aversion { source: Mercury, target: Jupiter }","RelationSourceBody { body: Mercury }","RelationTargetBody { body: Jupiter }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Mercury }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: Jupiter }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"aversion","predicateLabel":"Aversion { source: Mercury, target: Jupiter }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE 105","sortOrder":3}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Mercury } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: Jupiter } ∧ Aversion { source: Mercury, target: Jupiter } => Planetary aversion","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Mercury and Jupiter do not share a classical whole-sign ray, so this indicates aversion without adding reception or condition weighting.","interpretation":"Mercury and Jupiter do not share a classical whole-sign ray, so this indicates aversion without adding reception or condition weighting.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-aversion","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-aversion","factorLabel":"Planetary aversion","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_aversion","ruleTitle":"Planetary aversion","doctrineClaim":"Planetary aversion","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["aversion","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","TRAD-VALENS-ANTH"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"49"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"57"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"79"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"81"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1631-1640"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1720-1728"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1724-1728"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1729-1736"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2360-2362"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2360-2363"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2361-2364"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2363-2365"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2365-2367"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2366-2368"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2368-2370"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2368-2371"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2370-2373"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2373-2376"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2375-2376"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2377-2381"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2378-2381"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2380-2383"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2382-2385"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2384-2386"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2386-2389"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2389-2390"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2389-2391"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2391-2392"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2392-2397"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2397-2399"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2399-2402"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2402-2404"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2403-2404"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2404-2405"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2405-2406"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2406"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2406-2407"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2407-2408"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2408-2409"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2409-2410"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2410-2411"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2441-2443"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2450-2451"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2454-2457"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2463-2465"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2465-2466"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2465-2468"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2472-2473"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2473-2474"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2479-2480"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2480-2481"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2481-2482"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2527"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2548"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2548; 4746-4756; 6326-6336"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2542-2544"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"4750-4753; 6331"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"68"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8024-8048"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8037-8041"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8098-8103"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"9388-9404"}],"chartEvidence":["Aversion { source: Venus, target: Mars }","RelationSourceBody { body: Venus }","RelationTargetBody { body: Mars }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Venus }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: Mars }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"aversion","predicateLabel":"Aversion { source: Venus, target: Mars }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE 105","sortOrder":3}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Venus } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: Mars } ∧ Aversion { source: Venus, target: Mars } => Planetary aversion","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Venus and Mars do not share a classical whole-sign ray, so this indicates aversion without adding reception or condition weighting.","interpretation":"Venus and Mars do not share a classical whole-sign ray, so this indicates aversion without adding reception or condition weighting.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-aversion","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-aversion","factorLabel":"Planetary aversion","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_aversion","ruleTitle":"Planetary aversion","doctrineClaim":"Planetary aversion","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["aversion","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","TRAD-VALENS-ANTH"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"49"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"57"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"79"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"81"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1631-1640"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1720-1728"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1724-1728"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1729-1736"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2360-2362"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2360-2363"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2361-2364"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2363-2365"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2365-2367"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2366-2368"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2368-2370"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2368-2371"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2370-2373"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2373-2376"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2375-2376"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2377-2381"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2378-2381"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2380-2383"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2382-2385"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2384-2386"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2386-2389"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2389-2390"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2389-2391"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2391-2392"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2392-2397"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2397-2399"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2399-2402"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2402-2404"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2403-2404"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2404-2405"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2405-2406"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2406"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2406-2407"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2407-2408"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2408-2409"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2409-2410"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2410-2411"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2441-2443"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2450-2451"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2454-2457"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2463-2465"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2465-2466"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2465-2468"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2472-2473"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2473-2474"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2479-2480"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2480-2481"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2481-2482"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2527"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2548"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2548; 4746-4756; 6326-6336"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2542-2544"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"4750-4753; 6331"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"68"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8024-8048"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8037-8041"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8098-8103"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"9388-9404"}],"chartEvidence":["Aversion { source: Venus, target: Saturn }","RelationSourceBody { body: Venus }","RelationTargetBody { body: Saturn }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Venus }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: Saturn }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"aversion","predicateLabel":"Aversion { source: Venus, target: Saturn }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE 105","sortOrder":3}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Venus } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: Saturn } ∧ Aversion { source: Venus, target: Saturn } => Planetary aversion","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Venus and Saturn do not share a classical whole-sign ray, so this indicates aversion without adding reception or condition weighting.","interpretation":"Venus and Saturn do not share a classical whole-sign ray, so this indicates aversion without adding reception or condition weighting.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-aversion","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-aversion","factorLabel":"Planetary aversion","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_aversion","ruleTitle":"Planetary aversion","doctrineClaim":"Planetary aversion","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["aversion","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","TRAD-VALENS-ANTH"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"49"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"57"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"79"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"81"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1631-1640"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1720-1728"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1724-1728"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1729-1736"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2360-2362"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2360-2363"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2361-2364"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2363-2365"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2365-2367"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2366-2368"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2368-2370"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2368-2371"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2370-2373"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2373-2376"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2375-2376"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2377-2381"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2378-2381"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2380-2383"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2382-2385"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2384-2386"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2386-2389"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2389-2390"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2389-2391"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2391-2392"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2392-2397"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2397-2399"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2399-2402"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2402-2404"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2403-2404"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2404-2405"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2405-2406"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2406"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2406-2407"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2407-2408"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2408-2409"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2409-2410"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2410-2411"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2441-2443"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2450-2451"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2454-2457"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2463-2465"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2465-2466"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2465-2468"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2472-2473"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2473-2474"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2479-2480"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2480-2481"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2481-2482"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2527"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2548"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2548; 4746-4756; 6326-6336"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2542-2544"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"4750-4753; 6331"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"68"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8024-8048"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8037-8041"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8098-8103"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"9388-9404"}],"chartEvidence":["Aversion { source: Mars, target: Jupiter }","RelationSourceBody { body: Mars }","RelationTargetBody { body: Jupiter }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Mars }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: Jupiter }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"aversion","predicateLabel":"Aversion { source: Mars, target: Jupiter }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE 105","sortOrder":3}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Mars } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: Jupiter } ∧ Aversion { source: Mars, target: Jupiter } => Planetary aversion","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Mars and Jupiter do not share a classical whole-sign ray, so this indicates aversion without adding reception or condition weighting.","interpretation":"Mars and Jupiter do not share a classical whole-sign ray, so this indicates aversion without adding reception or condition weighting.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-aversion","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-aversion","factorLabel":"Planetary aversion","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_aversion","ruleTitle":"Planetary aversion","doctrineClaim":"Planetary aversion","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["aversion","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","TRAD-VALENS-ANTH"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"49"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"57"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"79"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"81"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1631-1640"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1720-1728"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1724-1728"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1729-1736"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2360-2362"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2360-2363"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2361-2364"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2363-2365"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2365-2367"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2366-2368"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2368-2370"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2368-2371"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2370-2373"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2373-2376"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2375-2376"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2377-2381"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2378-2381"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2380-2383"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2382-2385"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2384-2386"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2386-2389"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2389-2390"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2389-2391"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2391-2392"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2392-2397"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2397-2399"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2399-2402"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2402-2404"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2403-2404"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2404-2405"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2405-2406"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2406"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2406-2407"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2407-2408"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2408-2409"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2409-2410"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2410-2411"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2441-2443"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2450-2451"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2454-2457"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2463-2465"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2465-2466"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2465-2468"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2472-2473"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2473-2474"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2479-2480"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2480-2481"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2481-2482"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2527"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2548"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2548; 4746-4756; 6326-6336"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2542-2544"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"4750-4753; 6331"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"68"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8024-8048"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8037-8041"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8098-8103"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"9388-9404"}],"chartEvidence":["Aversion { source: Jupiter, target: Saturn }","RelationSourceBody { body: Jupiter }","RelationTargetBody { body: Saturn }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Jupiter }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: Saturn }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"aversion","predicateLabel":"Aversion { source: Jupiter, target: Saturn }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE 105","sortOrder":3}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Jupiter } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: Saturn } ∧ Aversion { source: Jupiter, target: Saturn } => Planetary aversion","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Jupiter and Saturn do not share a classical whole-sign ray, so this indicates aversion without adding reception or condition weighting.","interpretation":"Jupiter and Saturn do not share a classical whole-sign ray, so this indicates aversion without adding reception or condition weighting.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-separating","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-separating","factorLabel":"Planetary separating aspect","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_separating","ruleTitle":"Planetary separating aspect","doctrineClaim":"Planetary separating aspect","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["applying_or_separating","ecliptic_aspect","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","TRAD-GEORGE-AA2"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"123"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"42"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"85"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"95"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"}],"chartEvidence":["ApplyingOrSeparating { source: Mercury, target: Saturn, phase: \"separating\" }","EclipticAspect { source: Mercury, target: Saturn, aspect: Conjunction }","RelationSourceBody { body: Mercury }","RelationTargetBody { body: Saturn }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Mercury }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: Saturn }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"ecliptic_aspect","predicateLabel":"EclipticAspect { source: Mercury, target: Saturn, aspect: Conjunction }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"applying_or_separating","predicateLabel":"ApplyingOrSeparating { source: Mercury, target: Saturn, phase: \"separating\" }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":4}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Mercury } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: Saturn } ∧ EclipticAspect { source: Mercury, target: Saturn, aspect: Conjunction } ∧ ApplyingOrSeparating { source: Mercury, target: Saturn, phase: \"separating\" } => Planetary separating aspect","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Mercury is separating from an ecliptic conjunction with Saturn, based on the existing pair-relation aspect and speed data.","interpretation":"Mercury is separating from an ecliptic conjunction with Saturn, based on the existing pair-relation aspect and speed data.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-planetary-relation-separating","factorKey":"rule:planetary-relation-separating","factorLabel":"Planetary separating aspect","ruleKey":"planetary_relation_separating","ruleTitle":"Planetary separating aspect","doctrineClaim":"Planetary separating aspect","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-general","topic":"General","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["applying_or_separating","ecliptic_aspect","relation_source_body","relation_target_body"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","TRAD-GEORGE-AA2"],"sourceKeys":["ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"123"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"42"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"85"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"95"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94"}],"chartEvidence":["ApplyingOrSeparating { source: Mercury, target: MeanNode, phase: \"separating\" }","EclipticAspect { source: Mercury, target: MeanNode, aspect: Trine }","RelationSourceBody { body: Mercury }","RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode }"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"relation_source_body","predicateLabel":"RelationSourceBody { body: Mercury }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"relation_target_body","predicateLabel":"RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"ecliptic_aspect","predicateLabel":"EclipticAspect { source: Mercury, target: MeanNode, aspect: Trine }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"applying_or_separating","predicateLabel":"ApplyingOrSeparating { source: Mercury, target: MeanNode, phase: \"separating\" }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN 105","sortOrder":4}],"calculationExplanation":"RelationSourceBody { body: Mercury } ∧ RelationTargetBody { body: MeanNode } ∧ EclipticAspect { source: Mercury, target: MeanNode, aspect: Trine } ∧ ApplyingOrSeparating { source: Mercury, target: MeanNode, phase: \"separating\" } => Planetary separating aspect","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Mercury is separating from an ecliptic trine with Mean Node, based on the existing pair-relation aspect and speed data.","interpretation":"Mercury is separating from an ecliptic trine with Mean Node, based on the existing pair-relation aspect and speed data.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-core-fortune-ruler-witnessed-by-malefic","factorKey":"lot:lot-of-fortune","factorLabel":"Lot of Fortune","ruleKey":"core_fortune_ruler_witnessed_by_malefic","ruleTitle":"Fortune ruler is witnessed by malefic","doctrineClaim":"Fortune ruler is witnessed by malefic","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-status","topic":"Status","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["body.in_house","body.witnessed_by_malefic","house.cadent","lot.in_house","lot.ruler"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-VALENS-ANTH"],"sourceKeys":["VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1631-1640"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1720-1728"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1724-1728"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1729-1736"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2360-2362"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2360-2363"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2361-2364"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2363-2365"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2365-2367"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2366-2368"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2368-2370"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2368-2371"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2370-2373"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2373-2376"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2375-2376"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2377-2381"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2378-2381"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2380-2383"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2382-2385"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2384-2386"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2386-2389"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2389-2390"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2389-2391"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2391-2392"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2392-2397"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2397-2399"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2399-2402"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2402-2404"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2403-2404"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2404-2405"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2405-2406"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2406"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2406-2407"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2407-2408"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2408-2409"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2409-2410"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2410-2411"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2441-2443"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2450-2451"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2454-2457"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2463-2465"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2465-2466"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2465-2468"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2472-2473"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2473-2474"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2479-2480"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2480-2481"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2481-2482"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2527"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2548"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2548; 4746-4756; 6326-6336"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2542-2544"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"4750-4753; 6331"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"68"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8024-8048"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8037-8041"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8098-8103"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"9388-9404"}],"chartEvidence":["cadent(H12)","house is 12","house is 8","malefic witness by conjunction","malefic witness by sextile","traditional ruler is Mercury"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"lot.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Lot of Fortune) = 8","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Fortune","glyph":"⊗","longitude":82.17692954936592,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":22.176929549365923,"house":8},"object":null,"observed":["house is 8"],"source":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY 1631-1640","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"lot.ruler","predicateLabel":"ruler(Lot of Fortune) = Mercury","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Fortune","glyph":"⊗","longitude":82.17692954936592,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":22.176929549365923,"house":8},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["traditional ruler is Mercury"],"source":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY 1631-1640","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"house.cadent","predicateLabel":"cadent(H12)","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":["cadent(H12)"],"source":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY 1631-1640","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"body.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Mercury) = 12","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["house is 12"],"source":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY 1631-1640","sortOrder":4},{"predicateKey":"body.witnessed_by_malefic","predicateLabel":"malefic_witness(Mercury, Mars, sextile)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["malefic witness by sextile"],"source":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY 1631-1640","sortOrder":5},{"predicateKey":"body.witnessed_by_malefic","predicateLabel":"malefic_witness(Mercury, Saturn, conjunction)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["malefic witness by conjunction"],"source":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY 1631-1640","sortOrder":6}],"calculationExplanation":"house(Lot of Fortune) = 8 ∧ ruler(Lot of Fortune) = Mercury ∧ cadent(H12) ∧ house(Mercury) = 12 ∧ malefic_witness(Mercury, Mars, sextile) ∧ malefic_witness(Mercury, Saturn, conjunction) => Fortune ruler is witnessed by malefic","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Mercury rules Lot of Fortune and receives malefic testimony from Mars, Saturn, so it is read as expressing bodily, material, and reputational topics under more pressure.","interpretation":"Mercury rules Lot of Fortune and receives malefic testimony from Mars, Saturn, so it is read as expressing bodily, material, and reputational topics under more pressure.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-paulus-fortune-ruler-operates","factorKey":"lot:lot-of-fortune","factorLabel":"Lot of Fortune","ruleKey":"paulus_fortune_ruler_operates","ruleTitle":"Lot of Fortune is interpreted through its ruler, Mercury","doctrineClaim":"Lot of Fortune is interpreted through its ruler, Mercury","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-status","topic":"Status","tradition":"Paulus","predicateKeys":["body.condition_component_score","body.condition_valence","body.direct_motion","body.in_house","body.received_by","body.solar_proximity","body.triplicity_night","house.cadent","lot.in_house","lot.ruler","sign.triplicity_ruler"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL"],"sourceKeys":["PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1299-1322"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1575-1590"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2684-2760"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2721-2770"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"68"}],"chartEvidence":["Libra night triplicity ruler is Mercury","cadent(H12)","condition valence is bonified","house is 12","house is 8","house_strength score is -2","joy score is -1","motion is direct","motion score is 1","night_triplicity(Mercury)","received by Jupiter through face","received by Jupiter through participating_triplicity","received by Saturn through exaltation","received by Saturn through triplicity","received by Venus through bound","received by Venus through domicile","reception score is 9","solar proximity band is under_beams","solar separation is 9.25 degrees","total score is 5","traditional ruler is Mercury","visibility score is -2"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"lot.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Lot of Fortune) = 8","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Fortune","glyph":"⊗","longitude":82.17692954936592,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":22.176929549365923,"house":8},"object":null,"observed":["house is 8"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"lot.ruler","predicateLabel":"ruler(Lot of Fortune) = Mercury","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Fortune","glyph":"⊗","longitude":82.17692954936592,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":22.176929549365923,"house":8},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["traditional ruler is Mercury"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"house.cadent","predicateLabel":"cadent(H12)","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":["cadent(H12)"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"body.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Mercury) = 12","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["house is 12"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":4},{"predicateKey":"body.direct_motion","predicateLabel":"direct_motion(Mercury)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["motion is direct"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":5},{"predicateKey":"body.triplicity_night","predicateLabel":"night_triplicity(Mercury)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["night_triplicity(Mercury)"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":6},{"predicateKey":"sign.triplicity_ruler","predicateLabel":"triplicity_ruler(Libra.night) = Mercury","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["Libra night triplicity ruler is Mercury"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":7},{"predicateKey":"body.solar_proximity","predicateLabel":"solar_proximity(Mercury) = under_beams at 9.25°","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Sun","glyph":"☉","longitude":193.93174145103276,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":13.931741451032764,"house":12,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["solar proximity band is under_beams","solar separation is 9.25 degrees"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":8},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Mercury, Venus, domicile)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Venus","glyph":"♀","longitude":221.71180161400247,"sign":"Scorpio","degree_in_sign":11.711801614002468,"house":1,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["received by Venus through domicile"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":9},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Mercury, Venus, bound)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Venus","glyph":"♀","longitude":221.71180161400247,"sign":"Scorpio","degree_in_sign":11.711801614002468,"house":1,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["received by Venus through bound"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":10},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Mercury, Jupiter, participating_triplicity)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"observed":["received by Jupiter through participating_triplicity"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":11},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Mercury, Jupiter, face)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"observed":["received by Jupiter through face"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":12},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Mercury, Saturn, exaltation)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["received by Saturn through exaltation"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":13},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Mercury, Saturn, triplicity)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["received by Saturn through triplicity"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":14},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Mercury, house_strength) = -2","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["house_strength score is -2"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":15},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Mercury, motion) = 1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["motion score is 1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":16},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Mercury, visibility) = -2","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["visibility score is -2"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":17},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Mercury, joy) = -1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["joy score is -1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":18},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Mercury, reception) = 9","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["reception score is 9"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":19},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Mercury, total) = 5","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["total score is 5"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":20},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_valence","predicateLabel":"condition(Mercury) = bonified","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["condition valence is bonified"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":21}],"calculationExplanation":"house(Lot of Fortune) = 8 ∧ ruler(Lot of Fortune) = Mercury ∧ cadent(H12) ∧ house(Mercury) = 12 ∧ direct_motion(Mercury) ∧ night_triplicity(Mercury) ∧ triplicity_ruler(Libra.night) = Mercury ∧ solar_proximity(Mercury) = under_beams at 9.25° ∧ reception(Mercury, Venus, domicile) ∧ reception(Mercury, Venus, bound) ∧ reception(Mercury, Jupiter, participating_triplicity) ∧ reception(Mercury, Jupiter, face) ∧ reception(Mercury, Saturn, exaltation) ∧ reception(Mercury, Saturn, triplicity) ∧ condition_component(Mercury, house_strength) = -2 ∧ condition_component(Mercury, motion) = 1 ∧ condition_component(Mercury, visibility) = -2 ∧ condition_component(Mercury, joy) = -1 ∧ condition_component(Mercury, reception) = 9 ∧ condition_component(Mercury, total) = 5 ∧ condition(Mercury) = bonified => Lot of Fortune is interpreted through its ruler, Mercury","derivationKind":"source_shaped_synthesis","synthesisNote":"Deterministic condition synthesis over visible dignity, sect, place, motion, visibility, reception, joy, and score components.","interpretiveImplication":"The ruler of Lot of Fortune is Mercury in house 12 with a bonified condition, keeping Fortune's bodily and status significations active.","interpretation":"The ruler of Lot of Fortune is Mercury in house 12 with a bonified condition, keeping Fortune's bodily and status significations active.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-ptolemy-asc-ruler-in-aversion-to-ascendant","factorKey":"body:mars","factorLabel":"Mars","ruleKey":"ptolemy_asc_ruler_in_aversion_to_ascendant","ruleTitle":"Ptolemaic Ascendant ruler in aversion to the Ascendant","doctrineClaim":"Ptolemaic Ascendant ruler in aversion to the Ascendant","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-status","topic":"Status","tradition":"Ptolemy","predicateKeys":["ascendant.in_aversion_to_body","body.in_house","house.ruler","house.succedent"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA"],"sourceKeys":["TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"44"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"49"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"57"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"73"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"79"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"81"}],"chartEvidence":["AscendantInAversionToBody { body: Mars }","house 1 ruler is Mars","house is 2","succedent(H2)"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"house.ruler","predicateLabel":"ruler(H1) = Mars","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["house 1 ruler is Mars"],"source":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS 44","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"house.succedent","predicateLabel":"succedent(H2)","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":["succedent(H2)"],"source":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS 44","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"body.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Mars) = 2","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mars","glyph":"♂","longitude":266.52236561049745,"sign":"Sagittarius","degree_in_sign":26.522365610497445,"house":2,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["house is 2"],"source":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS 44","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"ascendant.in_aversion_to_body","predicateLabel":"AscendantInAversionToBody { body: Mars }","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":[],"source":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS 44","sortOrder":4}],"calculationExplanation":"ruler(H1) = Mars ∧ succedent(H2) ∧ house(Mars) = 2 ∧ AscendantInAversionToBody { body: Mars } => Ptolemaic Ascendant ruler in aversion to the Ascendant","derivationKind":"direct_rule","synthesisNote":null,"interpretiveImplication":"Mars rules the Ascendant from house 2 but is in aversion to the Ascendant at the whole-sign level, so this is read as a Ptolemaic aversion condition.","interpretation":"Mars rules the Ascendant from house 2 but is in aversion to the Ascendant at the whole-sign level, so this is read as a Ptolemaic aversion condition.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"evidence-core-fortune-ruler-bonified","factorKey":"lot:lot-of-fortune","factorLabel":"Lot of Fortune","ruleKey":"core_fortune_ruler_bonified","ruleTitle":"Fortune ruler has condition support","doctrineClaim":"Fortune ruler has condition support","doctrineGroupKey":"topic-status","topic":"Status","tradition":"Multi-source","predicateKeys":["body.condition_component_score","body.condition_valence","body.direct_motion","body.in_house","body.received_by","body.solar_proximity","body.triplicity_night","house.cadent","lot.in_house","lot.ruler","sign.triplicity_ruler"],"citationKeys":["TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL"],"sourceKeys":["PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM"],"locators":[{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1299-1322"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1575-1590"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2684-2760"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2721-2770"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"68"}],"chartEvidence":["Libra night triplicity ruler is Mercury","cadent(H12)","condition valence is bonified","house is 12","house is 8","house_strength score is -2","joy score is -1","motion is direct","motion score is 1","night_triplicity(Mercury)","received by Jupiter through face","received by Jupiter through participating_triplicity","received by Saturn through exaltation","received by Saturn through triplicity","received by Venus through bound","received by Venus through domicile","reception score is 9","solar proximity band is under_beams","solar separation is 9.25 degrees","total score is 5","traditional ruler is Mercury","visibility score is -2"],"proofSteps":[{"predicateKey":"lot.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Lot of Fortune) = 8","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Fortune","glyph":"⊗","longitude":82.17692954936592,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":22.176929549365923,"house":8},"object":null,"observed":["house is 8"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":1},{"predicateKey":"lot.ruler","predicateLabel":"ruler(Lot of Fortune) = Mercury","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"lot","label":"Lot of Fortune","glyph":"⊗","longitude":82.17692954936592,"sign":"Gemini","degree_in_sign":22.176929549365923,"house":8},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["traditional ruler is Mercury"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":2},{"predicateKey":"body.in_house","predicateLabel":"house(Mercury) = 12","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["house is 12"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":3},{"predicateKey":"house.cadent","predicateLabel":"cadent(H12)","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":null,"observed":["cadent(H12)"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":4},{"predicateKey":"body.direct_motion","predicateLabel":"direct_motion(Mercury)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["motion is direct"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":5},{"predicateKey":"body.triplicity_night","predicateLabel":"night_triplicity(Mercury)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["night_triplicity(Mercury)"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":6},{"predicateKey":"sign.triplicity_ruler","predicateLabel":"triplicity_ruler(Libra.night) = Mercury","applies":true,"subject":null,"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["Libra night triplicity ruler is Mercury"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":7},{"predicateKey":"body.solar_proximity","predicateLabel":"solar_proximity(Mercury) = under_beams at 9.25°","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Sun","glyph":"☉","longitude":193.93174145103276,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":13.931741451032764,"house":12,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["solar proximity band is under_beams","solar separation is 9.25 degrees"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":8},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Mercury, Venus, domicile)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Venus","glyph":"♀","longitude":221.71180161400247,"sign":"Scorpio","degree_in_sign":11.711801614002468,"house":1,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["received by Venus through domicile"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":9},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Mercury, Venus, bound)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Venus","glyph":"♀","longitude":221.71180161400247,"sign":"Scorpio","degree_in_sign":11.711801614002468,"house":1,"condition":"strong bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["received by Venus through bound"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":10},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Mercury, Jupiter, participating_triplicity)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"observed":["received by Jupiter through participating_triplicity"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":11},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Mercury, Jupiter, face)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Jupiter","glyph":"♃","longitude":49.744512992968254,"sign":"Taurus","degree_in_sign":19.744512992968254,"house":7,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"retrograde"},"observed":["received by Jupiter through face"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":12},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Mercury, Saturn, exaltation)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["received by Saturn through exaltation"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":13},{"predicateKey":"body.received_by","predicateLabel":"reception(Mercury, Saturn, triplicity)","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":{"kind":"body","label":"Saturn","glyph":"♄","longitude":197.46145270828455,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":17.461452708284554,"house":12,"condition":"excellent bonified","motion":"direct"},"observed":["received by Saturn through triplicity"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":14},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Mercury, house_strength) = -2","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["house_strength score is -2"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":15},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Mercury, motion) = 1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["motion score is 1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":16},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Mercury, visibility) = -2","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["visibility score is -2"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":17},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Mercury, joy) = -1","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["joy score is -1"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":18},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Mercury, reception) = 9","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["reception score is 9"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":19},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_component_score","predicateLabel":"condition_component(Mercury, total) = 5","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["total score is 5"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":20},{"predicateKey":"body.condition_valence","predicateLabel":"condition(Mercury) = bonified","applies":true,"subject":{"kind":"body","label":"Mercury","glyph":"☿","longitude":203.18475907679525,"sign":"Libra","degree_in_sign":23.184759076795245,"house":12,"condition":"mixed bonified","motion":"direct"},"object":null,"observed":["condition valence is bonified"],"source":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM 1299-1322","sortOrder":21}],"calculationExplanation":"house(Lot of Fortune) = 8 ∧ ruler(Lot of Fortune) = Mercury ∧ house(Mercury) = 12 ∧ cadent(H12) ∧ direct_motion(Mercury) ∧ night_triplicity(Mercury) ∧ triplicity_ruler(Libra.night) = Mercury ∧ solar_proximity(Mercury) = under_beams at 9.25° ∧ reception(Mercury, Venus, domicile) ∧ reception(Mercury, Venus, bound) ∧ reception(Mercury, Jupiter, participating_triplicity) ∧ reception(Mercury, Jupiter, face) ∧ reception(Mercury, Saturn, exaltation) ∧ reception(Mercury, Saturn, triplicity) ∧ condition_component(Mercury, house_strength) = -2 ∧ condition_component(Mercury, motion) = 1 ∧ condition_component(Mercury, visibility) = -2 ∧ condition_component(Mercury, joy) = -1 ∧ condition_component(Mercury, reception) = 9 ∧ condition_component(Mercury, total) = 5 ∧ condition(Mercury) = bonified => Fortune ruler has condition support","derivationKind":"source_shaped_synthesis","synthesisNote":"Deterministic condition synthesis over visible dignity, sect, place, motion, visibility, reception, joy, and score components.","interpretiveImplication":"Mercury rules Lot of Fortune and has slightly bonified, limited by H12 aversion to Ascendant, cadent house pressure, visibility pressure, and house joy pressure; its house 12 placement and house strength remain separately inspectable for bodily, material, and reputational topics.","interpretation":"Mercury rules Lot of Fortune and has slightly bonified, limited by H12 aversion to Ascendant, cadent house pressure, visibility pressure, and house joy pressure; its house 12 placement and house strength remain separately inspectable for bodily, material, and reputational topics.","applicability":{"status":"applies","reason":null},"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}}],"sourceNotes":[{"id":"source-note-trad-abu-mashar-great-intro-abu-mashar-great-introduction-dykes-26","sourceKey":"ABU_MASHAR_GREAT_INTRODUCTION_DYKES","citationKey":"TRAD-ABU-MASHAR-GREAT-INTRO","locator":"26","title":"The Great Introduction to the Science of the Judgments of the Stars","author":"Abu Ma'shar","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Benjamin N. Dykes","publicSummary":"Abu Ma'shar: The Great Introduction to the Science of the Judgments of the Stars (2010), translated by Benjamin N. Dykes [TRAD-ABU-MASHAR-GREAT-INTRO]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-abu-mashar-great-intro-abu-mashar-great-introduction-dykes-46","sourceKey":"ABU_MASHAR_GREAT_INTRODUCTION_DYKES","citationKey":"TRAD-ABU-MASHAR-GREAT-INTRO","locator":"46","title":"The Great Introduction to the Science of the Judgments of the Stars","author":"Abu Ma'shar","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Benjamin N. Dykes","publicSummary":"Abu Ma'shar: The Great Introduction to the Science of the Judgments of the Stars (2010), translated by Benjamin N. Dykes [TRAD-ABU-MASHAR-GREAT-INTRO]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-abu-mashar-great-intro-abu-mashar-great-introduction-dykes-80","sourceKey":"ABU_MASHAR_GREAT_INTRODUCTION_DYKES","citationKey":"TRAD-ABU-MASHAR-GREAT-INTRO","locator":"80","title":"The Great Introduction to the Science of the Judgments of the Stars","author":"Abu Ma'shar","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Benjamin N. Dykes","publicSummary":"Abu Ma'shar: The Great Introduction to the Science of the Judgments of the Stars (2010), translated by Benjamin N. Dykes [TRAD-ABU-MASHAR-GREAT-INTRO]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-brennan-ha-hellenistic-astrology-brennan-105","sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"105","title":"Hellenistic Astrology: The Study of Fate and Fortune","author":"Chris Brennan","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2017","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":null,"publicSummary":"Chris Brennan: Hellenistic Astrology: The Study of Fate and Fortune (2017) [TRAD-BRENNAN-HA]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-brennan-ha-hellenistic-astrology-brennan-123","sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"123","title":"Hellenistic Astrology: The Study of Fate and Fortune","author":"Chris Brennan","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2017","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":null,"publicSummary":"Chris Brennan: Hellenistic Astrology: The Study of Fate and Fortune (2017) [TRAD-BRENNAN-HA]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-brennan-ha-hellenistic-astrology-brennan-42","sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"42","title":"Hellenistic Astrology: The Study of Fate and Fortune","author":"Chris Brennan","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2017","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":null,"publicSummary":"Chris Brennan: Hellenistic Astrology: The Study of Fate and Fortune (2017) [TRAD-BRENNAN-HA]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-brennan-ha-hellenistic-astrology-brennan-43","sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"43","title":"Hellenistic Astrology: The Study of Fate and Fortune","author":"Chris Brennan","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2017","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":null,"publicSummary":"Chris Brennan: Hellenistic Astrology: The Study of Fate and Fortune (2017) [TRAD-BRENNAN-HA]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-brennan-ha-hellenistic-astrology-brennan-73","sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"73","title":"Hellenistic Astrology: The Study of Fate and Fortune","author":"Chris Brennan","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2017","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":null,"publicSummary":"Chris Brennan: Hellenistic Astrology: The Study of Fate and Fortune (2017) [TRAD-BRENNAN-HA]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-brennan-ha-hellenistic-astrology-brennan-85","sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"85","title":"Hellenistic Astrology: The Study of Fate and Fortune","author":"Chris Brennan","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2017","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":null,"publicSummary":"Chris Brennan: Hellenistic Astrology: The Study of Fate and Fortune (2017) [TRAD-BRENNAN-HA]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-brennan-ha-hellenistic-astrology-brennan-95","sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"95","title":"Hellenistic Astrology: The Study of Fate and Fortune","author":"Chris Brennan","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2017","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":null,"publicSummary":"Chris Brennan: Hellenistic Astrology: The Study of Fate and Fortune (2017) [TRAD-BRENNAN-HA]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-george-aa2-ancient-astrology-in-theory-and-practice-2-george-105","sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105","title":"Ancient Astrology in Theory and Practice, Volume 2","author":"Demetra George","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2022","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":null,"publicSummary":"Demetra George: Ancient Astrology in Theory and Practice, Volume 2 (2022) [TRAD-GEORGE-AA2]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-george-aa2-ancient-astrology-in-theory-and-practice-2-george-126","sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126","title":"Ancient Astrology in Theory and Practice, Volume 2","author":"Demetra George","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2022","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":null,"publicSummary":"Demetra George: Ancient Astrology in Theory and Practice, Volume 2 (2022) [TRAD-GEORGE-AA2]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-george-aa2-ancient-astrology-in-theory-and-practice-2-george-43","sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43","title":"Ancient Astrology in Theory and Practice, Volume 2","author":"Demetra George","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2022","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":null,"publicSummary":"Demetra George: Ancient Astrology in Theory and Practice, Volume 2 (2022) [TRAD-GEORGE-AA2]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-george-aa2-ancient-astrology-in-theory-and-practice-2-george-47","sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47","title":"Ancient Astrology in Theory and Practice, Volume 2","author":"Demetra George","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2022","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":null,"publicSummary":"Demetra George: Ancient Astrology in Theory and Practice, Volume 2 (2022) [TRAD-GEORGE-AA2]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-george-aa2-ancient-astrology-in-theory-and-practice-2-george-75","sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75","title":"Ancient Astrology in Theory and Practice, Volume 2","author":"Demetra George","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2022","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":null,"publicSummary":"Demetra George: Ancient Astrology in Theory and Practice, Volume 2 (2022) [TRAD-GEORGE-AA2]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-george-aa2-ancient-astrology-in-theory-and-practice-2-george-91","sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91","title":"Ancient Astrology in Theory and Practice, Volume 2","author":"Demetra George","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2022","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":null,"publicSummary":"Demetra George: Ancient Astrology in Theory and Practice, Volume 2 (2022) [TRAD-GEORGE-AA2]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-george-aa2-ancient-astrology-in-theory-and-practice-2-george-94","sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94","title":"Ancient Astrology in Theory and Practice, Volume 2","author":"Demetra George","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2022","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":null,"publicSummary":"Demetra George: Ancient Astrology in Theory and Practice, Volume 2 (2022) [TRAD-GEORGE-AA2]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-paulus-late-classical-paulus-late-classical-greenbaum-1299-1322","sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1299-1322","title":"Late Classical Astrology","author":"Paulus Alexandrinus","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2001","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Dorian Gieseler Greenbaum","publicSummary":"Paulus Alexandrinus: Late Classical Astrology (2001), translated by Dorian Gieseler Greenbaum [TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-paulus-late-classical-paulus-late-classical-greenbaum-1575-1590","sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1575-1590","title":"Late Classical Astrology","author":"Paulus Alexandrinus","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2001","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Dorian Gieseler Greenbaum","publicSummary":"Paulus Alexandrinus: Late Classical Astrology (2001), translated by Dorian Gieseler Greenbaum [TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-paulus-late-classical-paulus-late-classical-greenbaum-2684-2760","sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2684-2760","title":"Late Classical Astrology","author":"Paulus Alexandrinus","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2001","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Dorian Gieseler Greenbaum","publicSummary":"Paulus Alexandrinus: Late Classical Astrology (2001), translated by Dorian Gieseler Greenbaum [TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-paulus-late-classical-paulus-late-classical-greenbaum-2721-2770","sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2721-2770","title":"Late Classical Astrology","author":"Paulus Alexandrinus","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2001","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Dorian Gieseler Greenbaum","publicSummary":"Paulus Alexandrinus: Late Classical Astrology (2001), translated by Dorian Gieseler Greenbaum [TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-paulus-late-classical-paulus-late-classical-greenbaum-68","sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"68","title":"Late Classical Astrology","author":"Paulus Alexandrinus","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2001","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Dorian Gieseler Greenbaum","publicSummary":"Paulus Alexandrinus: Late Classical Astrology (2001), translated by Dorian Gieseler Greenbaum [TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-ptolemy-tetra-tetrabiblos-robbins-44","sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"44","title":"Tetrabiblos","author":"Claudius Ptolemy","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"1940","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"F. E. Robbins","publicSummary":"Claudius Ptolemy: Tetrabiblos (1940), translated by F. E. Robbins [TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-ptolemy-tetra-tetrabiblos-robbins-49","sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"49","title":"Tetrabiblos","author":"Claudius Ptolemy","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"1940","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"F. E. Robbins","publicSummary":"Claudius Ptolemy: Tetrabiblos (1940), translated by F. E. Robbins [TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-ptolemy-tetra-tetrabiblos-robbins-57","sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"57","title":"Tetrabiblos","author":"Claudius Ptolemy","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"1940","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"F. E. Robbins","publicSummary":"Claudius Ptolemy: Tetrabiblos (1940), translated by F. E. Robbins [TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-ptolemy-tetra-tetrabiblos-robbins-73","sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"73","title":"Tetrabiblos","author":"Claudius Ptolemy","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"1940","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"F. E. Robbins","publicSummary":"Claudius Ptolemy: Tetrabiblos (1940), translated by F. E. Robbins [TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-ptolemy-tetra-tetrabiblos-robbins-79","sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"79","title":"Tetrabiblos","author":"Claudius Ptolemy","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"1940","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"F. E. Robbins","publicSummary":"Claudius Ptolemy: Tetrabiblos (1940), translated by F. E. Robbins [TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-ptolemy-tetra-tetrabiblos-robbins-81","sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"81","title":"Tetrabiblos","author":"Claudius Ptolemy","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"1940","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"F. E. Robbins","publicSummary":"Claudius Ptolemy: Tetrabiblos (1940), translated by F. E. Robbins [TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-sahl-mashallah-sahl-and-mashallah-dykes-55","sourceKey":"SAHL_AND_MASHALLAH_DYKES","citationKey":"TRAD-SAHL-MASHALLAH","locator":"55","title":"Works of Sahl and Masha'allah","author":"Sahl ibn Bishr and Masha'allah","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2008","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Benjamin N. Dykes","publicSummary":"Sahl ibn Bishr and Masha'allah: Works of Sahl and Masha'allah (2008), translated by Benjamin N. Dykes [TRAD-SAHL-MASHALLAH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-sahl-mashallah-sahl-and-mashallah-dykes-66","sourceKey":"SAHL_AND_MASHALLAH_DYKES","citationKey":"TRAD-SAHL-MASHALLAH","locator":"66","title":"Works of Sahl and Masha'allah","author":"Sahl ibn Bishr and Masha'allah","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2008","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Benjamin N. Dykes","publicSummary":"Sahl ibn Bishr and Masha'allah: Works of Sahl and Masha'allah (2008), translated by Benjamin N. Dykes [TRAD-SAHL-MASHALLAH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-sahl-mashallah-sahl-and-mashallah-dykes-76","sourceKey":"SAHL_AND_MASHALLAH_DYKES","citationKey":"TRAD-SAHL-MASHALLAH","locator":"76","title":"Works of Sahl and Masha'allah","author":"Sahl ibn Bishr and Masha'allah","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2008","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Benjamin N. Dykes","publicSummary":"Sahl ibn Bishr and Masha'allah: Works of Sahl and Masha'allah (2008), translated by Benjamin N. Dykes [TRAD-SAHL-MASHALLAH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-1631-1640","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1631-1640","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-1720-1728","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1720-1728","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-1724-1728","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1724-1728","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-1729-1736","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1729-1736","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-2360-2362","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2360-2362","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-2360-2363","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2360-2363","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-2361-2364","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2361-2364","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-2363-2365","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2363-2365","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-2365-2367","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2365-2367","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-2366-2368","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2366-2368","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-2368-2370","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2368-2370","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-2368-2371","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2368-2371","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-2370-2373","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2370-2373","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-2373-2376","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2373-2376","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-2375-2376","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2375-2376","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-2377-2381","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2377-2381","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-2378-2381","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2378-2381","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-2380-2383","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2380-2383","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-2382-2385","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2382-2385","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-2384-2386","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2384-2386","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-2386-2389","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2386-2389","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-2389-2390","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2389-2390","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-2389-2391","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2389-2391","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-2391-2392","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2391-2392","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-2392-2397","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2392-2397","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-2397-2399","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2397-2399","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-2399-2402","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2399-2402","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-2402-2404","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2402-2404","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-2403-2404","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2403-2404","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-2404-2405","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2404-2405","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-2405-2406","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2405-2406","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-2406","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2406","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-2406-2407","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2406-2407","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-2407-2408","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2407-2408","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-2408-2409","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2408-2409","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-2409-2410","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2409-2410","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-2410-2411","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2410-2411","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-2441-2443","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2441-2443","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-2450-2451","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2450-2451","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-2454-2457","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2454-2457","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-2463-2465","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2463-2465","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-2465-2466","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2465-2466","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-2465-2468","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2465-2468","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-2472-2473","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2472-2473","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-2473-2474","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2473-2474","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-2479-2480","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2479-2480","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-2480-2481","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2480-2481","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-2481-2482","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2481-2482","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-2521-2527","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2527","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-2521-2548","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2548","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-2521-2548-4746-4756-6326-6336","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2548; 4746-4756; 6326-6336","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-2542-2544","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2542-2544","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-44","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"44","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-4750-4753-6331","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"4750-4753; 6331","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-68","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"68","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-8024-8048","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8024-8048","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-8037-8041","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8037-8041","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-8098-8103","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8098-8103","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}},{"id":"source-note-trad-valens-anth-valens-anthology-riley-9388-9404","sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"9388-9404","title":"Anthology","author":"Vettius Valens","year":null,"editionOrPublicationYear":"2010","citationRegistryVersion":"registry.citations.engine-v1","sourceTradition":null,"sourceTitle":null,"originalAuthor":null,"originalPublishedDate":null,"translatedDate":null,"translator":"Mark T. Riley","publicSummary":"Vettius Valens: Anthology (2010), translated by Mark T. Riley [TRAD-VALENS-ANTH]","paraphrase":null,"excerpt":null,"excerptWordCount":null,"sourcePolicy":{"publicationStatus":"published","excerptPolicy":"citation_only","maxExcerptWords":null,"allowPrivateNotes":false,"allowDraftSourceText":false,"copyrightClass":"modern_copyrighted"}}],"relatedSourceContext":null,"interpretationRows":[{"id":"interpretation-body:mars-medieval-evidence-medieval-besiegement-by-ray","topic":"General","heading":"Mars","body":"Sun is enclosed by Mars and Saturn specifically by ray, so this indicates the narrower besiegement-by-ray condition.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-medieval-besiegement-by-ray"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-body:mars-medieval-evidence-medieval-besiegement-by-ray","topic":"General","heading":"Mars","body":"Moon is enclosed by Mars and Saturn specifically by ray, so this indicates the narrower besiegement-by-ray condition.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-medieval-besiegement-by-ray"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-body:mars-medieval-evidence-medieval-besiegement-by-ray","topic":"General","heading":"Mars","body":"Mercury is enclosed by Mars and Saturn specifically by ray, so this indicates the narrower besiegement-by-ray condition.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-medieval-besiegement-by-ray"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-lot:lot-of-nemesis-multi-source-evidence-core-nemesis-ruler-witnessed-by-malefic","topic":"General","heading":"Lot of Nemesis","body":"Moon rules Lot of Nemesis and receives malefic testimony from Mars, Saturn, so it is read as expressing punitive, destructive, and death-quality topics under more pressure.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-core-nemesis-ruler-witnessed-by-malefic"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-lot:lot-of-spirit-paulus-evidence-paulus-spirit-ruler-operates","topic":"General","heading":"Lot of Spirit","body":"The ruler of Lot of Spirit is Jupiter in house 7 with a bonified condition, keeping Spirit's mental and active significations operative.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-paulus-spirit-ruler-operates"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-body:mars-medieval-evidence-medieval-besiegement","topic":"General","heading":"Mars","body":"Sun is enclosed by Mars and Saturn, so this indicates medieval besiegement rather than generic enclosure alone.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-medieval-besiegement"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-body:mars-medieval-evidence-medieval-besiegement","topic":"General","heading":"Mars","body":"Moon is enclosed by Mars and Saturn, so this indicates medieval besiegement rather than generic enclosure alone.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-medieval-besiegement"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-body:mars-medieval-evidence-medieval-besiegement","topic":"General","heading":"Mars","body":"Mercury is enclosed by Mars and Saturn, so this indicates medieval besiegement rather than generic enclosure alone.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-medieval-besiegement"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-lot:lot-of-courage-multi-source-evidence-core-courage-ruler-witnessed-by-malefic","topic":"General","heading":"Lot of Courage","body":"Mars rules Lot of Courage and receives malefic testimony from Saturn, so it is read as expressing daring, force, and risk-bearing topics under more pressure.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-core-courage-ruler-witnessed-by-malefic"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-lot:lot-of-necessity-multi-source-evidence-core-necessity-ruler-witnessed-by-malefic","topic":"General","heading":"Lot of Necessity","body":"Saturn rules Lot of Necessity and receives malefic testimony from Mars, so it is read as expressing constraint, struggle, and coercive topics under more pressure.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-core-necessity-ruler-witnessed-by-malefic"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-lot:lot-of-nemesis-paulus-evidence-paulus-nemesis-ruler-operates","topic":"General","heading":"Lot of Nemesis","body":"The ruler of Lot of Nemesis is Moon in house 8 with a bonified condition, keeping punitive, destructive, and death-quality themes active through the ruler.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-paulus-nemesis-ruler-operates"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-body:mars-multi-source-evidence-core-asc-ruler-witnessed-by-malefic","topic":"General","heading":"Mars","body":"Mars rules Ascendant and receives malefic testimony from Saturn, so it is read as expressing chart-level topics under more pressure.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-core-asc-ruler-witnessed-by-malefic"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-lot:lot-of-necessity-paulus-evidence-paulus-necessity-angular","topic":"General","heading":"Lot of Necessity","body":"Lot of Necessity is angular in house 4, foregrounding constraints, struggle, and restrictive conditions.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-paulus-necessity-angular"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-lot:lot-of-eros-multi-source-evidence-core-eros-ruler-witnessed-by-malefic","topic":"General","heading":"Lot of Eros","body":"Moon rules Lot of Eros and receives malefic testimony from Mars, Saturn, so it is read as expressing desire, friendship, and mutual-favor topics under more pressure.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-core-eros-ruler-witnessed-by-malefic"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-lot:lot-of-spirit-multi-source-evidence-core-spirit-ruler-bonified","topic":"General","heading":"Lot of Spirit","body":"Jupiter rules Lot of Spirit and has excellently bonified, limited by motion pressure and house joy pressure; its house 7 placement and house strength remain separately inspectable for mental, active, and intentional topics.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-core-spirit-ruler-bonified"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-lot:lot-of-victory-multi-source-evidence-core-victory-ruler-witnessed-by-malefic","topic":"General","heading":"Lot of Victory","body":"Saturn rules Lot of Victory and receives malefic testimony from Mars, so it is read as expressing confidence, contest, and associative-success topics under more pressure.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-core-victory-ruler-witnessed-by-malefic"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-lot:lot-of-spirit-multi-source-evidence-core-spirit-ruler-witnessed-by-benefic","topic":"General","heading":"Lot of Spirit","body":"Jupiter rules Lot of Spirit and receives benefic testimony from Jupiter, Venus, so it is read as expressing mental, active, and intentional topics with more support.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-core-spirit-ruler-witnessed-by-benefic"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-body:sun-ptolemy-evidence-ptolemy-sect-light-in-aversion-to-ascendant","topic":"General","heading":"Sun","body":"The sect light Sun is in house 12 but is in aversion to the Ascendant at the whole-sign level, so this is read as a Ptolemaic aversion condition.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-ptolemy-sect-light-in-aversion-to-ascendant"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-lot:lot-of-nemesis-multi-source-evidence-core-nemesis-ruler-bonified","topic":"General","heading":"Lot of Nemesis","body":"Moon rules Lot of Nemesis and has moderately bonified, limited by H8 aversion to Ascendant, sect pressure, and house joy pressure; its house 8 placement and house strength remain separately inspectable for punitive, destructive, and death-quality topics.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-core-nemesis-ruler-bonified"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-lot:lot-of-spirit-multi-source-evidence-core-spirit-ruler-in-sect","topic":"General","heading":"Lot of Spirit","body":"Jupiter rules Lot of Spirit and is in sect, so it is read as better able to express mental, active, and intentional topics. It is also angular in house 7.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-core-spirit-ruler-in-sect"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-body:mercury-medieval-evidence-medieval-translation-of-light","topic":"General","heading":"Mercury","body":"Mercury separates from Saturn by conjunction and applies to Mars by sextile, so this indicates a translation-of-light relation.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-medieval-translation-of-light"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-lot:lot-of-courage-paulus-evidence-paulus-courage-ruler-operates","topic":"General","heading":"Lot of Courage","body":"The ruler of Lot of Courage is Mars in house 2 with a bonified condition, keeping daring and risk-bearing themes active through the ruler.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-paulus-courage-ruler-operates"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-lot:lot-of-spirit-multi-source-evidence-core-spirit-ruler-angular","topic":"General","heading":"Lot of Spirit","body":"Jupiter rules Lot of Spirit and is angular in house 7, foregrounding its mental, active, and intentional topics.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-core-spirit-ruler-angular"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-body:mercury-medieval-evidence-medieval-reflection-of-light","topic":"General","heading":"Mercury","body":"Saturn receives departing light from Mercury and applying light from Sun, so this indicates a reflection-of-light relation.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-medieval-reflection-of-light"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-lot:lot-of-necessity-paulus-evidence-paulus-necessity-ruler-operates","topic":"General","heading":"Lot of Necessity","body":"The ruler of Lot of Necessity is Saturn in house 12 with a bonified condition, keeping constraint and struggle themes active through the ruler.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-paulus-necessity-ruler-operates"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-body:mars-multi-source-evidence-core-asc-ruler-bonified","topic":"General","heading":"Mars","body":"Mars rules Ascendant and has moderately bonified, limited by H2 aversion to Ascendant, sect pressure, and house joy pressure; its house 2 placement and house strength remain separately inspectable for chart-level topics.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-core-asc-ruler-bonified"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-lot:lot-of-victory-paulus-evidence-paulus-victory-ruler-operates","topic":"General","heading":"Lot of Victory","body":"The ruler of Lot of Victory is Saturn in house 12 with a bonified condition, keeping confidence, contest, and associative-success themes active through the ruler.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-paulus-victory-ruler-operates"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-lot:lot-of-courage-multi-source-evidence-core-courage-ruler-bonified","topic":"General","heading":"Lot of Courage","body":"Mars rules Lot of Courage and has moderately bonified, limited by H2 aversion to Ascendant, sect pressure, and house joy pressure; its house 2 placement and house strength remain separately inspectable for daring, force, and risk-bearing topics.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-core-courage-ruler-bonified"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-lot:lot-of-necessity-multi-source-evidence-core-necessity-ruler-bonified","topic":"General","heading":"Lot of Necessity","body":"Saturn rules Lot of Necessity and has slightly bonified, limited by H12 aversion to Ascendant, cadent house pressure, and visibility pressure; its house 12 placement and house strength remain separately inspectable for constraint, struggle, and coercive topics.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-core-necessity-ruler-bonified"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-lot:lot-of-eros-paulus-evidence-paulus-eros-ruler-operates","topic":"General","heading":"Lot of Eros","body":"The ruler of Lot of Eros is Moon in house 8 with a bonified condition, keeping desire and friendship themes active through the ruler.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-paulus-eros-ruler-operates"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-body:saturn-ptolemy-evidence-ptolemy-malefic-in-exaltation","topic":"General","heading":"Saturn","body":"Malefic Saturn is in its exaltation in house 12, so this indicates a Ptolemaic exaltation condition without pretending the malefic quality disappears.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-ptolemy-malefic-in-exaltation"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-lot:lot-of-eros-multi-source-evidence-core-eros-ruler-bonified","topic":"General","heading":"Lot of Eros","body":"Moon rules Lot of Eros and has moderately bonified, limited by H8 aversion to Ascendant, sect pressure, and house joy pressure; its house 8 placement and house strength remain separately inspectable for desire, friendship, and mutual-favor topics.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-core-eros-ruler-bonified"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-lot:lot-of-necessity-multi-source-evidence-core-necessity-ruler-in-sect","topic":"General","heading":"Lot of Necessity","body":"Saturn rules Lot of Necessity and is in sect, so it is read as better able to express constraint, struggle, and coercive topics.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-core-necessity-ruler-in-sect"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-lot:lot-of-victory-multi-source-evidence-core-victory-ruler-bonified","topic":"General","heading":"Lot of Victory","body":"Saturn rules Lot of Victory and has slightly bonified, limited by H12 aversion to Ascendant, cadent house pressure, and visibility pressure; its house 12 placement and house strength remain separately inspectable for confidence, contest, and associative-success topics.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-core-victory-ruler-bonified"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-body:mars-ptolemy-evidence-ptolemy-asc-ruler-and-sect-light-configure","topic":"General","heading":"Mars","body":"Mars and the sect light Sun see one another by sextile, so this is read as a Ptolemaic sign relationship.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-ptolemy-asc-ruler-and-sect-light-configure"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-lot:lot-of-victory-multi-source-evidence-core-victory-ruler-in-sect","topic":"General","heading":"Lot of Victory","body":"Saturn rules Lot of Victory and is in sect, so it is read as better able to express confidence, contest, and associative-success topics.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-core-victory-ruler-in-sect"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:paulus-ascendant-monomoiria-paulus-evidence-paulus-ascendant-monomoiria","topic":"General","heading":"Ascendant falls under Mercury's monomoirion","body":"The Ascendant is in degree 4 of Scorpio, so Paulus' degree-by-degree monomoiria assigns the ascending degree to Mercury.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-paulus-ascendant-monomoiria"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:paulus-sect-light-monomoiria-paulus-evidence-paulus-sect-light-monomoiria","topic":"General","heading":"Sun falls under Sun's monomoirion","body":"The day sect light is in Sun degree 14 of Libra, so Paulus' degree-by-degree monomoiria assigns it to Sun.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-paulus-sect-light-monomoiria"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:paulus-spirit-monomoiria-paulus-evidence-paulus-spirit-monomoiria","topic":"General","heading":"Lot of Spirit falls under Jupiter's monomoirion","body":"Lot of Spirit is in degree 15 of Pisces, so Paulus' degree-by-degree monomoiria assigns that occupied degree to Jupiter.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-paulus-spirit-monomoiria"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:paulus-necessity-monomoiria-paulus-evidence-paulus-necessity-monomoiria","topic":"General","heading":"Lot of Necessity falls under Venus's monomoirion","body":"Lot of Necessity is in degree 12 of Aquarius, so Paulus' degree-by-degree monomoiria assigns that occupied degree to Venus.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-paulus-necessity-monomoiria"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:paulus-eros-monomoiria-paulus-evidence-paulus-eros-monomoiria","topic":"General","heading":"Lot of Eros falls under Sun's monomoirion","body":"Lot of Eros is in degree 26 of Cancer, so Paulus' degree-by-degree monomoiria assigns that occupied degree to Sun.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-paulus-eros-monomoiria"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-applying-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-applying","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary applying aspect","body":"Sun is applying from an ecliptic conjunction with Saturn, based on the existing pair-relation aspect and speed data.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-applying"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-applying-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-applying","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary applying aspect","body":"Sun is applying from an ecliptic trine with Mean Node, based on the existing pair-relation aspect and speed data.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-applying"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-applying-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-applying","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary applying aspect","body":"Mercury is applying from an ecliptic sextile with Mars, based on the existing pair-relation aspect and speed data.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-applying"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-applying-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-applying","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary applying aspect","body":"Jupiter is applying from an ecliptic square with Mean Node, based on the existing pair-relation aspect and speed data.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-applying"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-applying-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-applying","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary applying aspect","body":"Saturn is applying from an ecliptic trine with Mean Node, based on the existing pair-relation aspect and speed data.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-applying"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-enclosure-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-enclosure","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary enclosure","body":"Sun is uninterrupted between its immediate guards Moon and Saturn, and both guards reach it by by ray, so this indicates enclosure as relation state rather than medieval besiegement.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-enclosure"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-enclosure-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-enclosure","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary enclosure","body":"Saturn is uninterrupted between its immediate guards Sun and Mercury, and both guards reach it by co presence, so this indicates enclosure as relation state rather than medieval besiegement.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-enclosure"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-overcoming-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-overcoming","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary overcoming direction","body":"Sun and Moon witness one another by trine, with overcome by recorded as the conservative sign-order direction. This does not add dexter/sinister dominance or reception weighting.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-overcoming"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-overcoming-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-overcoming","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary overcoming direction","body":"Sun and Mars witness one another by sextile, with overcoming recorded as the conservative sign-order direction. This does not add dexter/sinister dominance or reception weighting.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-overcoming"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-overcoming-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-overcoming","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary overcoming direction","body":"Sun and Mean Node witness one another by trine, with overcoming recorded as the conservative sign-order direction. This does not add dexter/sinister dominance or reception weighting.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-overcoming"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-overcoming-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-overcoming","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary overcoming direction","body":"Moon and Mercury witness one another by trine, with overcoming recorded as the conservative sign-order direction. This does not add dexter/sinister dominance or reception weighting.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-overcoming"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-overcoming-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-overcoming","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary overcoming direction","body":"Moon and Mars witness one another by opposition, with overcoming recorded as the conservative sign-order direction. This does not add dexter/sinister dominance or reception weighting.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-overcoming"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-overcoming-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-overcoming","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary overcoming direction","body":"Moon and Saturn witness one another by trine, with overcoming recorded as the conservative sign-order direction. This does not add dexter/sinister dominance or reception weighting.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-overcoming"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-overcoming-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-overcoming","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary overcoming direction","body":"Moon and Mean Node witness one another by trine, with overcoming recorded as the conservative sign-order direction. This does not add dexter/sinister dominance or reception weighting.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-overcoming"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-overcoming-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-overcoming","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary overcoming direction","body":"Mercury and Mars witness one another by sextile, with overcoming recorded as the conservative sign-order direction. This does not add dexter/sinister dominance or reception weighting.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-overcoming"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-overcoming-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-overcoming","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary overcoming direction","body":"Mercury and Mean Node witness one another by trine, with overcoming recorded as the conservative sign-order direction. This does not add dexter/sinister dominance or reception weighting.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-overcoming"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-overcoming-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-overcoming","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary overcoming direction","body":"Venus and Jupiter witness one another by opposition, with overcome by recorded as the conservative sign-order direction. This does not add dexter/sinister dominance or reception weighting.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-overcoming"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-overcoming-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-overcoming","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary overcoming direction","body":"Venus and Mean Node witness one another by square, with overcoming recorded as the conservative sign-order direction. This does not add dexter/sinister dominance or reception weighting.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-overcoming"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-overcoming-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-overcoming","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary overcoming direction","body":"Mars and Saturn witness one another by sextile, with overcome by recorded as the conservative sign-order direction. This does not add dexter/sinister dominance or reception weighting.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-overcoming"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-overcoming-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-overcoming","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary overcoming direction","body":"Mars and Mean Node witness one another by sextile, with overcoming recorded as the conservative sign-order direction. This does not add dexter/sinister dominance or reception weighting.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-overcoming"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-overcoming-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-overcoming","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary overcoming direction","body":"Jupiter and Mean Node witness one another by square, with overcoming recorded as the conservative sign-order direction. This does not add dexter/sinister dominance or reception weighting.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-overcoming"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-overcoming-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-overcoming","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary overcoming direction","body":"Saturn and Mean Node witness one another by trine, with overcoming recorded as the conservative sign-order direction. This does not add dexter/sinister dominance or reception weighting.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-overcoming"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-co-presence-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-co-presence","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary co-presence","body":"Sun and Mercury occupy the same sign, so this indicates co-presence apart from ray or exact-aspect testimony.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-co-presence"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-co-presence-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-co-presence","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary co-presence","body":"Sun and Saturn occupy the same sign, so this indicates co-presence apart from ray or exact-aspect testimony.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-co-presence"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-co-presence-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-co-presence","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary co-presence","body":"Mercury and Saturn occupy the same sign, so this indicates co-presence apart from ray or exact-aspect testimony.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-co-presence"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-classical-witnessing-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary classical witnessing","body":"Sun and Moon witness one another by trine, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-classical-witnessing-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary classical witnessing","body":"Sun and Mercury witness one another by conjunction, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-classical-witnessing-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary classical witnessing","body":"Sun and Mars witness one another by sextile, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-classical-witnessing-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary classical witnessing","body":"Sun and Saturn witness one another by conjunction, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-classical-witnessing-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary classical witnessing","body":"Sun and Mean Node witness one another by trine, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-classical-witnessing-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary classical witnessing","body":"Moon and Mercury witness one another by trine, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-classical-witnessing-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary classical witnessing","body":"Moon and Mars witness one another by opposition, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-classical-witnessing-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary classical witnessing","body":"Moon and Saturn witness one another by trine, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-classical-witnessing-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary classical witnessing","body":"Moon and Mean Node witness one another by trine, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-classical-witnessing-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary classical witnessing","body":"Mercury and Mars witness one another by sextile, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-classical-witnessing-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary classical witnessing","body":"Mercury and Saturn witness one another by conjunction, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-classical-witnessing-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary classical witnessing","body":"Mercury and Mean Node witness one another by trine, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-classical-witnessing-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary classical witnessing","body":"Venus and Jupiter witness one another by opposition, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-classical-witnessing-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary classical witnessing","body":"Venus and Mean Node witness one another by square, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-classical-witnessing-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary classical witnessing","body":"Mars and Saturn witness one another by sextile, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-classical-witnessing-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary classical witnessing","body":"Mars and Mean Node witness one another by sextile, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-classical-witnessing-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary classical witnessing","body":"Jupiter and Mean Node witness one another by square, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-classical-witnessing-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary classical witnessing","body":"Saturn and Mean Node witness one another by trine, distinguishing whole-sign testimony from exact ecliptic aspect geometry.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-classical-witnessing"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-aversion-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-aversion","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary aversion","body":"Sun and Venus do not share a classical whole-sign ray, so this indicates aversion without adding reception or condition weighting.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-aversion"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-aversion-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-aversion","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary aversion","body":"Sun and Jupiter do not share a classical whole-sign ray, so this indicates aversion without adding reception or condition weighting.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-aversion"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-aversion-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-aversion","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary aversion","body":"Moon and Venus do not share a classical whole-sign ray, so this indicates aversion without adding reception or condition weighting.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-aversion"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-aversion-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-aversion","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary aversion","body":"Moon and Jupiter do not share a classical whole-sign ray, so this indicates aversion without adding reception or condition weighting.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-aversion"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-aversion-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-aversion","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary aversion","body":"Mercury and Venus do not share a classical whole-sign ray, so this indicates aversion without adding reception or condition weighting.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-aversion"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-aversion-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-aversion","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary aversion","body":"Mercury and Jupiter do not share a classical whole-sign ray, so this indicates aversion without adding reception or condition weighting.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-aversion"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-aversion-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-aversion","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary aversion","body":"Venus and Mars do not share a classical whole-sign ray, so this indicates aversion without adding reception or condition weighting.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-aversion"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-aversion-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-aversion","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary aversion","body":"Venus and Saturn do not share a classical whole-sign ray, so this indicates aversion without adding reception or condition weighting.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-aversion"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-aversion-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-aversion","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary aversion","body":"Mars and Jupiter do not share a classical whole-sign ray, so this indicates aversion without adding reception or condition weighting.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-aversion"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-aversion-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-aversion","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary aversion","body":"Jupiter and Saturn do not share a classical whole-sign ray, so this indicates aversion without adding reception or condition weighting.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-aversion"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-separating-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-separating","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary separating aspect","body":"Mercury is separating from an ecliptic conjunction with Saturn, based on the existing pair-relation aspect and speed data.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-separating"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-rule:planetary-relation-separating-multi-source-evidence-planetary-relation-separating","topic":"General","heading":"Planetary separating aspect","body":"Mercury is separating from an ecliptic trine with Mean Node, based on the existing pair-relation aspect and speed data.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-planetary-relation-separating"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-lot:lot-of-fortune-multi-source-evidence-core-fortune-ruler-witnessed-by-malefic","topic":"Status","heading":"Lot of Fortune","body":"Mercury rules Lot of Fortune and receives malefic testimony from Mars, Saturn, so it is read as expressing bodily, material, and reputational topics under more pressure.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-core-fortune-ruler-witnessed-by-malefic"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-lot:lot-of-fortune-paulus-evidence-paulus-fortune-ruler-operates","topic":"Status","heading":"Lot of Fortune","body":"The ruler of Lot of Fortune is Mercury in house 12 with a bonified condition, keeping Fortune's bodily and status significations active.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-paulus-fortune-ruler-operates"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-body:mars-ptolemy-evidence-ptolemy-asc-ruler-in-aversion-to-ascendant","topic":"Status","heading":"Mars","body":"Mars rules the Ascendant from house 2 but is in aversion to the Ascendant at the whole-sign level, so this is read as a Ptolemaic aversion condition.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-ptolemy-asc-ruler-in-aversion-to-ascendant"],"unavailableReason":null},{"id":"interpretation-lot:lot-of-fortune-multi-source-evidence-core-fortune-ruler-bonified","topic":"Status","heading":"Lot of Fortune","body":"Mercury rules Lot of Fortune and has slightly bonified, limited by H12 aversion to Ascendant, cadent house pressure, visibility pressure, and house joy pressure; its house 12 placement and house strength remain separately inspectable for bodily, material, and reputational topics.","evidenceRowIds":["evidence-core-fortune-ruler-bonified"],"unavailableReason":null}],"unavailableStates":[],"appendices":{"citations":[{"sourceKey":"ABU_MASHAR_GREAT_INTRODUCTION_DYKES","citationKey":"TRAD-ABU-MASHAR-GREAT-INTRO","locator":"26","title":"The Great Introduction to the Science of the Judgments of the Stars"},{"sourceKey":"ABU_MASHAR_GREAT_INTRODUCTION_DYKES","citationKey":"TRAD-ABU-MASHAR-GREAT-INTRO","locator":"46","title":"The Great Introduction to the Science of the Judgments of the Stars"},{"sourceKey":"ABU_MASHAR_GREAT_INTRODUCTION_DYKES","citationKey":"TRAD-ABU-MASHAR-GREAT-INTRO","locator":"80","title":"The Great Introduction to the Science of the Judgments of the Stars"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"105","title":"Hellenistic Astrology: The Study of Fate and Fortune"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"123","title":"Hellenistic Astrology: The Study of Fate and Fortune"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"42","title":"Hellenistic Astrology: The Study of Fate and Fortune"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"43","title":"Hellenistic Astrology: The Study of Fate and Fortune"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"73","title":"Hellenistic Astrology: The Study of Fate and Fortune"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"85","title":"Hellenistic Astrology: The Study of Fate and Fortune"},{"sourceKey":"HELLENISTIC_ASTROLOGY_BRENNAN","citationKey":"TRAD-BRENNAN-HA","locator":"95","title":"Hellenistic Astrology: The Study of Fate and Fortune"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"105","title":"Ancient Astrology in Theory and Practice, Volume 2"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"126","title":"Ancient Astrology in Theory and Practice, Volume 2"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"43","title":"Ancient Astrology in Theory and Practice, Volume 2"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"47","title":"Ancient Astrology in Theory and Practice, Volume 2"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"75","title":"Ancient Astrology in Theory and Practice, Volume 2"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"91","title":"Ancient Astrology in Theory and Practice, Volume 2"},{"sourceKey":"ANCIENT_ASTROLOGY_IN_THEORY_AND_PRACTICE_2_GEORGE","citationKey":"TRAD-GEORGE-AA2","locator":"94","title":"Ancient Astrology in Theory and Practice, Volume 2"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1299-1322","title":"Late Classical Astrology"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"1575-1590","title":"Late Classical Astrology"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2684-2760","title":"Late Classical Astrology"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"2721-2770","title":"Late Classical Astrology"},{"sourceKey":"PAULUS_LATE_CLASSICAL_GREENBAUM","citationKey":"TRAD-PAULUS-LATE-CLASSICAL","locator":"68","title":"Late Classical Astrology"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"44","title":"Tetrabiblos"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"49","title":"Tetrabiblos"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"57","title":"Tetrabiblos"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"73","title":"Tetrabiblos"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"79","title":"Tetrabiblos"},{"sourceKey":"TETRABIBLOS_ROBBINS","citationKey":"TRAD-PTOLEMY-TETRA","locator":"81","title":"Tetrabiblos"},{"sourceKey":"SAHL_AND_MASHALLAH_DYKES","citationKey":"TRAD-SAHL-MASHALLAH","locator":"55","title":"Works of Sahl and Masha'allah"},{"sourceKey":"SAHL_AND_MASHALLAH_DYKES","citationKey":"TRAD-SAHL-MASHALLAH","locator":"66","title":"Works of Sahl and Masha'allah"},{"sourceKey":"SAHL_AND_MASHALLAH_DYKES","citationKey":"TRAD-SAHL-MASHALLAH","locator":"76","title":"Works of Sahl and Masha'allah"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1631-1640","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1720-1728","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1724-1728","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"1729-1736","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2360-2362","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2360-2363","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2361-2364","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2363-2365","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2365-2367","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2366-2368","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2368-2370","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2368-2371","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2370-2373","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2373-2376","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2375-2376","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2377-2381","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2378-2381","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2380-2383","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2382-2385","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2384-2386","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2386-2389","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2389-2390","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2389-2391","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2391-2392","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2392-2397","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2397-2399","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2399-2402","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2402-2404","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2403-2404","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2404-2405","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2405-2406","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2406","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2406-2407","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2407-2408","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2408-2409","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2409-2410","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2410-2411","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2441-2443","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2450-2451","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2454-2457","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2463-2465","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2465-2466","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2465-2468","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2472-2473","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2473-2474","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2479-2480","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2480-2481","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2481-2482","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2527","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2548","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2521-2548; 4746-4756; 6326-6336","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"2542-2544","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"44","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"4750-4753; 6331","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"68","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8024-8048","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8037-8041","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"8098-8103","title":"Anthology"},{"sourceKey":"VALENS_ANTHOLOGY_RILEY","citationKey":"TRAD-VALENS-ANTH","locator":"9388-9404","title":"Anthology"}],"glossary":[]}}}